Drifter's Thoughts: What Makes A Character Annoying?
Lately I've been watching a series that's been sitting on my DVD shelf for a while now, Outlaw Star. While I can't say it's my favourite anime, I can definitely see its benefits and why people like it so much. I then got properly introduced to the character Aisha Clan-Clan, who I'd seen and heard about vaguely years before starting the series. She holds a lot of character tropes such as an energetic, in-your-face personality, a very strong drive to get what she wants and a lot of other elements that could drive viewers away from liking her or draw them towards her.
I personally can't really bring myself to dislike her, even though she has some elements to her character like I love about certain characters and that I despise about other ones. And then it got me to really think, what exactly draws the line between a character being annoying or not?
We all know of the infamous characters that are universally despised in certain fandoms, either by everyone or almost everyone. You know the obvious ones, Jar Jar Binks in the Star Wars series, Donkey in the Shrek franchise, Navi from some of the Legend Of Zelda games. The reasons for the backlash towards these characters is fairly easy to see, but then you have characters that have similarities to the aforementioned, and yet are at the very worst met with mixed reception among fans, such as the aforementioned Aisha Clan-Clan. These are just a handful of examples in a vast range of characters across many different mediums , of course.
For me, I love the character of Nora Valkyrie from RWBY, but I'm also repulsed by Nui Harime from Kill La Kill. While these two characters have clear differences, they also have similarities such as their constant cheerful expression, their near-flawless combat skills and their smugness. To really understand why a character is so annoying to one person and enjoyable to another, we need to understand the purpose of these characters, why they are in the story we're seeing played out in front of us.
One of the most common mistakes of irritating characters is that they don't add very much to the story that they're a part of. A lot of people have claimed that Jar Jar Binks only added a small amount of assistance to the protagonists in The Phantom Menace and from then on he was really just kept around for comedy relief. This was so evident that he was underplayed further and further in the prequel trilogy, with his only important role being his exchange of political power in Attack Of The Clones, that would in turn give way to the plot of the original trilogy.
With that said, such an act could have easily been done by any character, and by that point in the trilogy, the damage from Jar Jar's annoyance had already been done. In a more positive example, Nora Valkyrie in RWBY is a fairly minor character in terms of the plot from the show's first two seasons; however at the time of writing this, I've yet to see one fan of the show say that they don't like her. And with that said, she DOES pull her weight for her team, she does take part in battles, with a great amount of effort and skill as well.
However, Nui Harime falls into the category of characters who some fans of Kill La Kill find annoying and other greatly admire, but she is also a major part of the show's story. Without Nui, KLK's plot wouldn't flow as well because she's a major part of its lore. However, a character's involvement is only part of what can determine their annoyance, another being their comedic value.
It's clear what the purpose of an energetic, loud, off-the-wall character such as Aisha or Nora Valkyrie is, to bring a light-hearted laugh when they're needed to give the audience a smile. The problem that can lie with said characters is when their comedy is badly timed or not very well written. Jar Jar Binks and Donkey from the Shrek series are notorious for having scenes or lines that detract from the scenario or just fail in their attempts at humour. A lot of this can come down to them becoming predictable, coming into the scene at a bad time or just being the focus of a scene for far longer than they really need to be.
One of the key elements of comedy is timing; if a character makes a quip or slapstick act during or right after a dramatic or important scene, it's not going to sit well with an invested viewer in most cases. However on the other hand, a well written character of this type can really add well to a scene. Aisha from Outlaw Star is only brought in when she's needed in the context of the story, such as using her naturally enhanced senses to keep an eye out for a ship in a space battle. Her humour comes naturally from her character, her situation and how she's not completely up to date with what's going on, as well as her military and alien upbringing. Her way of completing a task clashes with the other main characters and this can lead to some funny lines and scenes for some viewers.
Nora also works in this respect because her scenes are used sparingly throughout RWBY; her appearances are sometimes single lines that ooze with character or actions that can relate to the viewer. She even has her quieter moments where she's more down-to-earth so she can level with her team members. Now if she was always there in almost every scene, always bouncing off the walls and always spewing catchphrases to slap onto RWBY merchandise, she'd be a far less likeable character and have much less of a fan following.
On the other hand, not every character that fans find annoying is made for comedy. Navi from the Legend of Zelda series is a fairly serious character and yet is despised by a lot of fans. Why? Because she's annoying in a different way, she's constantly nagging and distracting the player with information that they can very easily figure out for themselves. Nobody likes to be nagged, especially while doing something they enjoy. In another example, Nui Harime in some cases isn't really meant to be funny, but rather threatening towards the main protagonists. Behind her cute, frilly dress sense and constant jovial facial expression, she's a cold, heartless killer, so why do fans like myself find her annoying?
I covered this in my character study on her and Neo from RWBY, but to put if briefly, Nui is a character that comes almost out of nowhere and is comparatively very over-powered. What makes her annoying is what makes a boss character in a fighting game such as Seth in Street Fighter IV or Rugal from King Of Fighters annoying; the character(s) you've been focussing on throughout their whole journey has overcome so many struggles and defeated many rivals through creative means, only to be met with a cheap, over-powered character that knows exactly how to counter everything they do. And while someone can see a boss character that's annoying to fight coming, nobody knew what Nui was going to do when she made her debut in Kill La Kill and then everyone was either intrigued by her or enraged by her.
Fans of the show either loved her design and her condescending attitude and took a strange liking to her psychotic nature, or they got bewildered and eventually angry at her deus ex machina-like abilities. Whenever it looked like someone had finally landed an actually blow to her during battle, she would either get straight back up as if she was never even hit, or had some way of getting around her wound (which would have been fatal to anyone else) through some forced means. Moments like these would leave fans impressed by her surprises or understandably angered for being robbed of seeing an extremely powerful antagonist character be proven to have some kind of weakness.
Which brings us to one of the most important elements that can make a character annoying or not, it really comes down to the viewer a lot of the time. Like any kind of taste or opinion, everyone is made to be different in some way to one another, even if its not intentional to them. Different people have different have different levels of restraint and patience for everything, including visual media. The Kill La Kill fanbase is so torn on whether Nui is a good character or not because people have such different opinions on her character and how she's written. Aisha Clan-Clan is either loved or put down as an irritating catgirl in the Outlaw Star fandom because people tolerate her differently.
There's always going to be characters that the vast majority of fans hate like Jar Jar Binks, but there will always be different viewpoints on characters that people either love or hate. Maybe it's because they're annoying, maybe it's because they're pointless, maybe it's because they have that one little thing that can mean a lot to one fan and be completely meaningless to another. As long as the human race and free thought is around, there's always going to be different points of view and opinions. It's why we have so many political parties, why there are so many religious beliefs, and of course, why there are so many characters that fanbases will be torn on.
So really, there a lot of factors that make a character annoying in general, but in the end, in all comes down to the person watching.











