Please please please make one of the Batfam the father! Like I think that opens up so much more possibility for angst tbh than if not.
Like, with a member of the Batfam (like Tim, Jason or Dick) it adds to the idea that (Name) is NOT family, at least to the boys. If that respective Bat-boy is romantically into (Name) then that means the entire dynamic of the Batfam shifts.
But I like to imagine what it’s be like if (Name) has absolutely no idea that the Bat-boy is her baby’s father, maybe she was drunk or just genuinely forgot but it’s also so uncomfortable to think about that it’s perfect:
Dick calling her ‘baby bird’ or ‘dove’ or all these sweet nicknames seems increasingly more suspicious to the Batfam.
Jason being gentle and actually staying whenever she’s in/was in the manor raises a few alarms.
Tim preferring the coffee she makes to Alfred’s seems peculiar to.
Idk, it is totally your choice but I genuinely think that it’d be such a major shift from how most neglected!reader fanfics are.
Also, imagine the idea of ALL three of them possibly being the baby’s father. Of course they can test when the baby is born, but before….it’s a whole Mamma Mia story.
OH MY GOD MY FIRST ASK!!!!! HIIIIIIIIIIIII
I do like the idea of it as your point in making the reader more further from being seen as one of the family.
Routine!Reader honestly doesn't remember much about what happened that night, but if it was the Batboys, I'm going to say she isn't really going to care.
She doesn't know any of the family very well, making the situation not too important for her.
The batfamily will care though, very much.
If i were going to make one of the batboys the daddy, i would definetly see them trying to get a closer relationship with the reader, as she did just have their child.
But at the same time, due to Routine!Reader lacks emotion and straightforward mind, the only thing she will be thinking about is why they even care at this point. So what if she had their kid.