The Finest of Betrayal
five x reader angst
Requested by no one
A/N: first time writing with five, going for a simple good short angst that takes place after the five and lila subway incident. Love you darling❤
🍷~
50 years. 50 goddamn years. A half fucking century all thrown away because Lila convinced five fucking Hargreaves to get on that train. And believe in the name of God when one says this, that as much as it seemed inconvenient, being unfaithful to you felt like being skinned and cremated alive. The moment five kissed lila for the first time, it felt wrong. The sort of wrong that makes you want to undo your previous decade of mistakes just to make up for this one.
But people do what people do, and more often than not people cant keep their hands to themselves. And keeping his hands to himself was something five Hargreaves prided himself on, not falling into the bottomless void of meaningless attraction. What you and him had was special. It was perfect. It was picturesque.
Which is why seeing your face for first time after seven years felt like having his heart ripped out. Especially knowing that he wasnt completely innocent, seduced by the idea of lonely lusting. No, he had hidden the journal to the way home for five months, he had chosen to stay with lila longer, and christ alive he hated how he did this while knowing no matter how many strawberries he grew he could never feel half of the happiness you gave him with lila.
The current scenario at Diego and lilas house was, putting it mildly: Ugly. Yelling, cursing and a lot of klaus shutting everyone else up because he wanted to hear five and Diego's arguement. Diego had just noticed the pathetic little bracelet lila flashed in her wrist.
"Did you give this to her?" Diego asked firmly.
"I made it for her." Five corrects, that stupid, asshole smug attitude that makes him look like he thinks he knows better than everyone else making Diego's blood boil.
"You made it for her?"
"Well I sure as hell didnt make it for you, diego."
Watching this shit was hard. Really hard. At one point you tuned them all out, your breathing had gotten heavier while your brain drowned in constant voices, accusations, insults making your head spin and feel like you might throw up. You had always found it hard to be mad at five. You just couldn't. Now, it felt like all that love was a lie, seeing the way he talked about lila, defended her. Having not acknowledged you once since you got here.
All of it seemed unbearable. Heartbreaking. Foggy. So you got up and left before tears could spill from your eyes. Only then did five look at you, by then you had already exited the front door.
Fives POV:
It was easier for him to face diego before facing yn. His wife, his love and basically everything that kept him away from the edge of insanity for over half a century. Let's be honest, what the fuck was he thinking? He could never love lila. Even if she loved him.
His entire life hed been convinced God sent down and angel from heaven to perfect his life when he didnt have anything else. That angel was yn Ln. He couldn't face her. He couldn't face those mesmerising eyes and drop-dead-gorgous face that hes always known he deserves none of. How could an angel like you ever love a man as broken as him? When yn walked out that door, she took his everything with him, because she was his everything. Without her, life had no meaning. He needed her like the oxygen he breathed.
And the fact that you were hurt now because him him broke him further. He followed you out the door as soon as you walked out. Diego could fucking wait. He tried to grab her hand, in vain, he had no idea what he was expecting but when you turned to face him, he saw the water in your irises.
He broke. Nothing mattered. His chest was exploding with things he wanted to tell you, things he needs you to hear because if he loses you, its game over for him. No healing no moving on.
"Yn please... I, it wasnt.." his words stumble on top of eachother because the proud five Hargreaves could be reduced to an unconfident insecure man at your feet any moment.
"Why the fuck would you do that!?"
One word. Raw, heartbroken, hurt and red.
Why
Makes his heart drop into his stomach. How can he explain? He cant. But he needs you. In a way he cant explain.
"Please, yn. I cant explain myself. I cant, and no explanation could make this better, but please, please dont leave me. You're my everything, I don't love lila, I dont and i could never. I love you, I love you more than anything and nothing else matters more than you, darling, i.."
He keeps rambling, saying unnecessary words that only make you angrier. You wanted to yell at him, curse him out and tell him how fucking unfair it was.
Please, I can't lose you.
You heard his voice crack. No, surely, it couldn't be. No. He wasn't crying was he? You forced yourself to bring your eyes up to his face. Five Hargreaves was crying. His green eyes were glossed over with water that was pooling at the edge of his lash line.
You stare at him in a sort of disbelief. Youd only ever seen him cry once in his entire life when you were stuck in the apocalypse and he found his siblings corpses.
Maybe it was impulse, or pent up longing. Five had went so long without touching you, seeing you cry the first time hes seen you in 7 years feels overwhelming. He hugs you before you can say anything, so tight it feels like it would be a sin to let go.
"Y-youre so fucking stupid." You choke. You live him so damn much, it makes it so hard to give him what he deserves.
"I know. I'll spend every second of the time we have left making it up to you. I swear, I'll die before I ever let you get hurt again, love, I promise."
When the two of you pull back he stares at you with an adoration as if you held the sun and moon. You step back. Your obviously not done being mad at him yet.
"Dont cry, please, I hate seeing you cry, I.. I'll never forgive myslef for this. Any of this. Just..."
"No. No. No fucking way, did 30 years of marriage mean absolutely nothing to you five? Did I mean nothing to you?"
Fives gave fell again, hurt, desperate. He would grovel at your feet for a chance of forgiveness from you. Even the slightest. Because when talking to you there was no pride, and no arrogance. Because he always knew you were right.
"If you have nothing else to say, I'm going home." Was the last thing you said before walking off. He followed you again, despite having nothing else to say, if the world really was ending and he couldn't spend his last moments with you, let God send him to hell where he could perish for eternity, because he spent his entire life in heaven, now it has thrown him away all because he got too close to fucking lila.
If you hated him, wanted him dead or loathed him forever, he would stop loving you, or chasing your love. Because no matter how much betrayal hurts, five Hargreaves is prepared to sell his soul for an angels forgiveness.














