Might be a hot take:
The focus in online pagan and related communities to return to ancestral practices and go back to your roots is weird and kind of promotes what I consider to be a problematic way of thinking, at least in many cases.
Yes, you should respect cultures and religions and such and not just join all willy nilly and uninformed. Even in open practices, research things from people in the culture is generally a good idea.
But, I don’t think people should be confined to what their ancestors did. It shouldn’t be a “if you want to practice a pagan religion, you should look to your ancestors’s practices pre-Christianity/colonization.”
Why?
-not everyone knows the culture of their ancestors, especially that far back. Christianity and colonization erased and blurred a lot of ancestral pasts to create a “new” and “unified” identity
-recently ancestors and living grandparents/great grandparents may have practiced a mix of things that came after colonization/Christianity (like a lot of folk religions in America)
-you might just not believe that just because your ancestors did?
-Saying you can only practice the culture of your ancestors is weird and complicated. Like, ancestor wise, I’m Brazilian and Central European. I wasn’t raised with much more than recipes that were passed down from the Brazilian side/common in my geographical area that is heavily Central European. Does that mean I’m close enough to the culture to practice indigenous religions and spiritualities from those areas? Even if I don’t have anyone to teach me, and have never been there? Even if it’s a bunch of different places in those regions? Is there a genetic distance that is too far?
I was a Hellenic Polytheist for a bit. Long story. I really believed in the Theoi, I researched a lot of primary and secondary sources. Damn I went to college and got a degree in ancient Mediterranean history and religion. Yet, people told me I wasn’t Greek so I couldn’t practice it.
I just feel like having a gatekeeping view to ethnicity/ancestry and religion/culture is a bit too close to nationalism to me.
And TO BE CLEAR I’m not saying you should ignore the idea of closed religions. A lot of those aren’t just an ancestral thing anyway. A lot of them just take a formal and long initiation practice if you aren’t raised in it. Which is valid, especially for religions that are complicated, specific, and are taken advantage of by mainstream society and capitalism. It’s more about protecting a culture that other people are trying to water down and erase than keeping it in a weird ethno-religion situation.
Also to be clear, it’s not an issue if you are practicing a religion from a region you are from. Of course there isn’t a problem in that. Especially if you are doing it to connect to ancestors/older family members. That is not what this take is about.












