Can someone bring me hope inside my heart?
Okay. I’m pretty stupid for not noticing this sooner. BUT! I noticed it after my Spotify playlist played found & lost and lost & found one after the other.
So... found & lost plays as one of Banana Fish’s opening song. It shows the action-packed disaster life that Ash is leading in New York --- his troubled past and unforgiving present. But then Ash and Eiji found each other and that fateful encounter gave Ash a newfound meaning in life. Just like how the song says: Fate somehow brings me hope inside my heart
But then lost & found happened.
Sure...you’ll probably accuse me of thinking too much about it. Buuut hear me out.
lost & found is exactly the same song except it’s slowed down and the lyrics are almost the same with the TV version of found & lost. Except this time, lost & found says something different: Can someone bring me hope inside my heart?
This song is in the same single as RED --- so I feel like it’s designed that way to connect it to RED’s narrative --- the ending of Banana Fish. Here’s how RED’s TV Edit lyrics go:
In spite of how the world decides to see my life
Would I still have a chance for us to say good bye
Over and over again
If I decide to burn instead of fading out
I still would like the chance for us to say good bye
Over and over again
If we can be found, we sure can get lost
Through all the madness of falling in love
If we're truly lost, I don't want to be found here dying alone
The stain of red that colors the pavement
Painted with blood of somebody you love
Is this the sacrifice for the broken
Losing the purest of what's in my heart
Found & Lost talks about the madness of falling in love
But Lost & Found talks about how Ash doesn’t want to die alone. But we all know -- canonically-- that he did. Because despite all the good that Eiji had brought in his life, he wasn’t convinced of himself that there’s hope for him. Thus, he cries, “Can someone bring me hope inside my heart?” Eiji tried. But because he never saw a bright future for himself he saw that dying alone was the only way out for him.
For me, that’s what makes Banana Fish’s ending so tragic. It’s not the fact that Ash died (well, not that happy about that either tbh) but the fact that he couldn’t see himself or Eiji having a future together. He didn’t have any hope for the future. He could’ve been helped but he opted not to get any help. For him, dying with good memories is enough. It’s like the Snows of Kilimanjaro. But then again SoK is a different essay altogether.
Ash could’ve asked for help. But he didn’t. Because for him, Eiji going back home to Japan is enough of an ending. He didn’t have to be involved in Ash’s troubles ever again.
Sorry...I’m not good at getting my thoughts across. But meh.