Can we just talk about Simply Shady for a moment? A song literally describing cheating and it making his life a tad more difficult? 😂 I love George, but a part of me feels like he never really realized it was wrong to sleep around. Especially being so into karma and the laws of karma, it shocks me how nonchalant he was about it. Love your blog btw, great to find someone as obsessed with him as I am 💕
Simply Shady is what happens to naughty boys in the music business. I suppose I got the idea here, at home, and then I escaped to India after that, and I wrote it in Bombay - it was a funny sort of song to be writing in Bombay - especially the one about Karma!
I went on a bit of a bender to make up for all the years I’d been married. If you listen to “Simply Shady”, on Dark Horse, it’s all in there – my whole life at that time was a bit like Mrs. Dale’s Diary.
[George, Rolling Stone, 1979]
Simply Shady, not just about infidelity, but a whole load of other things to - drugs, booze, selfishness, not really being very good to those around you. Hedonism, in other words.
Simply Shady was written in Jan/Feb 1974 while George was in India, visiting Ravi Shankar. The song George is talking about in the I Me Mine quote is It Is ‘He’ (Jai Sri Krishna) which George had written directly before Simply Shady. It Is He is a song inspired by a sort of spiritual epiphany George experienced while he was in the holy city of Vrindavan, and Simply Shady is about George’s hedonistic lifestyle of the early 70s. Two completely opposing ideas and concepts. And you know, that’s George, isn’t it?
If you look at George’s lyrics which I’ve snapped from I Me Mine, the lyrics are perhaps revealingly different. The lines ‘Karma took a trip’ and
The moment I start drowningI’ll cling onto any strawIf it can/will get/keep me floatingStand me back up on the floor/I’ll come back up for more
And as I started drowningI clung onto a strawThat somehow kept me floatingWhile my madness craved for more
…in the final version. The present tense turning to the past tense. There’s a motif of liquid in the song and water and drowning which makes me think a little bit of Sour Milk Sea, and there’s often water in George’s songs, this idea of drowning and wanting to be saved. Although as you say, it’s also a song about cheating and it making life difficult (Oh! Poor you, George!) but I think it does - not quite directly in so many words - acknowledge that this life is not where George wants to be or where he should be.
The juxtaposition of It is He with Simply Shady paints a George struggling with what he wants to do with the rest of his life - does he dedicate himself to spirituality or does he continue live like a hedonistic 70s rock star? George has spoken about how he felt uncomfortable going to India (particularly at this time) or meeting with other spiritual people at this time because he knew he wasn’t living the life he should. (That would have made him a hypocrite. There’s that word again). I think he very nearly lost his faith at this point in his life, it’s something he came back to in song over and over again.
This was early 1974 and despite that epiphany, I don’t think he really started to climb back out of that hole he’d dug himself until directly after the Dark Horse Tour at the end of 1974. George is suffering from laryngitis when he recorded Simply Shady too - maybe that was a little dose of Karma.
As for whether he thought it was wrong to sleep around, no, I don’t think he did. Quite the opposite in fact, but that is perhaps a different matter. At the end of the day, George was human. He made mistakes, he was flawed and he could be wrong sometimes. He was also brilliant, unique, talented and loving. I wouldn’t have him any other way.
Thank you for your ask and kind comments! Sorry its took me ages to answer you. I’ve saved my favourite questions for last! ;)