How would it be if Noa was a caitiff? Would her family accept her? Would she still take pride in her heritage? Would she have more interest in learning from other Kindred? Would it change her dynamic with Nyth? (They'd both be "failed" Embraces, in a way)
Hi hi! Sorry this took a bit - I wanted to be sure I had the time to answer properly!
An excellent question... so to start let me do a basic rundown of her Embrace story. She was going to be Embraced by her Father - be a pride of the Hidalgos - but then the Sabbat interrupted the event and she escaped to America with Nyth as just a ghoul. Noa then had to convince Don Rothstein of Vegas and his peers of her worth and pulled some dramatic stunts and got the backing of a Giovanni main branch Auntie named Gianna. She wasn't Embraced until her 30th birthday, one of the reasons she panicked and tried so hard and did the things she did to convince them to turn her. Gianna Giovanni is her sire, so if she was Embraced CAITIFF that would cause a massive stir I think.
I wrote Gianna to be kind of the feminist fire-starter within the clan - they're already old-school and it's the 80s/90s here in Vegas so you know things aren't amazing for women in-clan - so to have her have a Caitiff childe would probably be a blow to her credibility. IF it gets out Noa is Caitiff.
Granted I have not played Caitiff before so I don't know mechanically the extent of how obvious it is! If Noa can still learn necromancy and etc, I think she could be "hidden" for a long time. How obvious is it to someone when you're "born wrong?" I suppose Noa would be learning Necromancy but it would be an uphill climb because it would technically be "out of clan" for her at that point?
Noa is extremely prideful and hardly self-doubts unless she is at a LOW, LOW point, so I think she would at first be upset if she knows, but then pull herself up by the boot straps and use this as proof that she is worthy of her necromancer title because she has to work extra hard AND still succeeds. I think her and Nyth in that sense would be even more bonded because they're both underdogs at that point who can support the other - though it may be a little harder for them to get access to resources depending on how much the Family is aware of her being different.
I think - if she can remain hidden - the part that would change the most is her ability to experience intimacy with others. She wouldn't have the Lamia bite, so if she figures that out, she'd possibly be able to connect with mortals a bit easier? Perhaps she'd actually get close to her ghoul, Julian, maybe Joaquin would've had a chance if she got her teeth in him? One of the reasons she loses her tolerance of Joaquin is that he wanted so many physical things but refused to be Embraced, so she could not experience the same levels of intimacy as a Kindred that he could. In her current Giovanni state, she is very pro-VAMPIRE and barely thinks of mortals aside from vessels of blood and ghouls because she can't really connect with them (or at least choses not to due to how she was raised) so I think being allowed to do the Kiss on them may change her outlook a bit! Noa is blood Giovanni so even if she were Caitiff, she'd be proud of HERSELF. Especially with Nyth at her side, I think she would eventually selfgrandize enough that she and him are the coming of a new Hecata that is more accepting of other bloodlines while still being under the big umbrella so to speak. They're the Hecata that may not be GIOVANNI but they embody the connection between the living and dead. These two really love themselves haha.
God it really is cool to think about, thank you for asking me to dive deeper on it!! I hope I answered well enough!
(nyth belongs to @thesixthplaneteer 💘)







