Which Edition of D&D had the best design/artwork of a Hydroloth?
First Edition
Second Edition
Fourth Edition
Fifth Edition

seen from Australia
seen from United States

seen from South Africa
seen from United Arab Emirates
seen from South Korea
seen from Netherlands
seen from United States
seen from China
seen from China
seen from United States
seen from Australia
seen from United States

seen from Russia
seen from Germany
seen from Australia
seen from United States
seen from United Kingdom

seen from United Kingdom
seen from Bangladesh
seen from China
Which Edition of D&D had the best design/artwork of a Hydroloth?
First Edition
Second Edition
Fourth Edition
Fifth Edition
WHICH IS MORE SMASHABLE?
Dolphin Delighter
Hydroloth
On the left is the Dolphin Delighter, as in it is a magical talking fey "dolphin" that delights others. It likes to telepathically sing sea shanties and cause dazzling bursts of healing light. It also can teleport as it leaps, and is around 5-6 ft (1.5-1.8 m) long. As @valvadis pointed out, it seems likely that it's based on the Boto Cor De Rosa of Brazilian folklore. Shapeshifters that show up to parties, play music/dance/drink/fuck, and disappear into the night. Which does fit with the the "Fey" designation of the D&D version.
On the right, Hydroloth are 10 ft (3 m) tall frog fiends from the River Styx. They can turn invisible, cause madness, walk on water, cause magical fear, and are telepathic! They're also pretty chill, and are known for thier trading skills! Thier horrible trading skills, they're great at finding things but not at knowing thier value, so they often get scammed. They spend most of thier time trading, fighting, and just swimming around enjoying life.
Man I love yugoloths. Got a few converted from older editions’ daemons in here too, some redrawn from old designs way back on the blog.
WHICH WOULD YOU SMASH?
Hydroloth
Dhergoloth
On the left, Hydroloth are 10 ft (3 m) tall frog fiends from the River Styx. They can turn invisible, cause madness, walk on water, cause magical fear, and are telepathic! They're also pretty chill, and are known for thier trading skills! Thier horrible trading skills, they're great at finding things but not at knowing thier value, so they often get scammed. They spend most of thier time trading, fighting, and just swimming around enjoying life.
On the right is the dhergoloth, which looks like a d20 is halfway through evolving into a bug! They're 8‒10 ft (2.4‒3 m) insectoid soldiers whose legs and body can spin in any direction, even opposite ones! They're telepathic, can cast Darkness and Fear, and teleport. Complex commands or ones that take too long will cause them to forget what they're doing or just ignore what you said. But that's the cost of flirting with the beyblade bug I guess.
QUALIFIERS: Hydroloth
SMASH
PASS
Hyrdoloth are 10 ft (3 m) tall frog fiends from the River Styx. They can turn invisible, cause madness, walk on water, cause magical fear, and are telepathic! They're also pretty chill, and are known for thier trading skills! Thier horrible trading skills, they're great at finding things but not at knowing thier value, so they often get scammed. They spend most of thier time trading, fighting, and just swimming around enjoying life.