“Y’know, for all Katherine’s told me about you, I still don’t know where ya came from,” Jack says coolly. He meets David’s gaze head-on and unblinking, as if he’s waiting for David to do something that even David isn’t aware of yet. David tries to hide the shudder in his shoulders. “Whenever I see her at Medda’s now, it’s all David this and David that-” David can feel his ears turning red, can feel his stomach churning as he scrambles to think of what Katherine has been speaking about him. Jack only cocks his head and smiles challengingly. “Makes a fella wonder.”
David swallows, his head roaring with panic – a warm hand presses against his thigh, and all goes quiet as he zeroes in on the sensation.
“Don’t you listen to him,” Katherine says gently, shooting Jack a flinty glance. “Mister Kelly has a talent for re-shaping the truth.”
Jack tilts his head into his palm and smiles coyly.
“So you admit you talk about him,” he volleys, grinning as Katherine’s cheeks turn a humorous pink. Strangely, the sight puts David at ease – Katherine isn’t the sort to gossip about him to her friend. And she certainly isn’t the sort to keep bad company, no matter how much this Jack Kelly puts him on edge.
“Katherine was in need of a repairman.” He says, trying to keep his tone even. “She had a friend who spoke highly of me, and so she determined that I must be up to par.”
David stares at his grouse, feeling a remarkable kinship with the limp and roasted bird. He has always been aware of the differences between him and Katherine – how could he not? – but it has always tinged him with a bit of shame to know their friendship stemmed from a bought service. It was a ridiculous thing to feel stung over, but David never claimed to be a rational man, and he wasn’t immune to feeling cheap.
“Colour me impressed,” Jack shrugs, shooting Katherine a wry look. “Always rare to see Kitty ask for help.”
“Oh-!” Katherine slaps his shoulder. “Hush, slanderer! I am more than capable of admitting when I’m found lacking. Aren’t I, David?”
David blinks, suddenly off-kilter from the combined weight of their unfiltered gazes. He’d been sinking into his chair the more they spoke to one another, allowing himself to be absorbed into the backdrop of the evening – it was a skill he’d grown rather accustomed to. But now they had reeled him right back to the centre of attention, casting him into reality, and it was a sensation most – dizzying.
“Well,” he says stiltedly, the words bubbling anxiously from his lips, “you did insist I show you what I was doing so that you’d never have to call for me again.”
There’s a beat of silence, a seconds-worth of time for David to weigh the pros and cons of leaping from Katherine’s drawing room window – and then Jack splutters into his glass, sending a flurry of brandy spattering across Katherine’s tablecloth.
“Sorry!” David yelps. “That – I assure you, that was the last thing I hoped to elicit-!”
“My God, David!” Jack cackles, still choking flecks of brandy into his napkin. “Ya couldn’t’ve warned me he was a firecracker, Kitty?”
Katherine, David quickly realizes, is a mess of hysterics, practically buried in her own tablecloth as she wheezes.
“I couldn’t possibly,” Katherine giggles, a slight snort tinging the edge of her words, “do David such justice.”
David frowns, his frazzled nerves beginning to soothe. He glances between the two, still rather suspect he’s done something wrong – but no one seems terribly offended and Katherine hasn’t ordered him to leave her household, so perhaps the damage wasn’t too great.
“I only spoke the truth…” David says hesitantly. Katherine gasps and slaps his shoulder in scolding.
“You did not!” She cries, her voice dripping with faux-scandal. “It wasn’t my intention to just send you on your way! I only prefer being able to solve my own problems, you know that!”
“Your exact request was that I show you how it was done so that you need never have a man touch your pianoforte again.”
Jack slaps his hand on the table, howling into the cloth.