please don't kill me, mr. ghostface!
ghostface!johnjae x fem!reader
summary: ghostface johnny and jaehyun might not want to kill you as much as you thought they did a/n: *this shit is like all dialogue ngl* dude i really wanted to get this one out because it's just SUCH a classic casting- i think jaehyun is SO billy loomis and johnny is SO stu macher! anyway i hope you enjoy this installment of my spooky fics! i tried to make it as unbelievable and fun as the actual scream movies <3 cw: (minors dni) smut, mentions of death, depictions of death/murder (not super detailed), yandere/stalker vibes, 3some, spitroasting, unprotected p in v (to be expected), creampie (by both johnny and jaehyun), reader gets turned on by the adrenaline of maybe dying?, LIGHT knifeplay, choking (sexy) pronouns: she/her wc: 4.1k
College life was supposed to be filled with crazy parties and one night stands that you might regret one day. Instead, you were dealing with murder.
“Hey- are you okay, sweets? I know you were friends with Wendy,” your boyfriend asks, walking up to you and Haechan after being released from interrogation.
“I wouldn't say friends, but still- it’s just crazy, like… how does this happen?” you ask, still in shock.
One of your sorority sisters, Wendy, was staying at her boyfriend's off-campus apartment and was found dead, both of them having been murdered. You aren’t sure about specific details or even what’s going on, but the cops came to the school and were interviewing everyone in the connected sorority and fraternity- the fraternity that your boyfriend happened to be a part of. You were both in shock at the news.
“Why the long faces?” Johnny jokes with a big smile, walking up with his arm wrapped around his girlfriend Jennie.
“God, Johnny, you dick. Wendy’s dead. You could at least pretend to be respectful-” Jennie chastised.
“Didn’t Wendy dump you for Joshua?” Haechan asks Johnny, sucking on a lollipop.
“What the fuck? I thought you dumped her for me,” Jennie screeches, slapping Johnny’s chest.
“I did, baby. I did- Haechan’s just talking shit-” he replies, glaring at Haechan.
“And did you tell the cops about your previous relations with the victim?” Haechan laughs, still trying to stir some shit up.
“If you have something to say, say it with your chest,” Johnny demands.
“Where were you last night?” Haechan smirks.
“He was with me,” Jennie says suggestively.
“All night?”
“All right. Haechan, fuck off- Johnny didn’t do it.” Jaehyun effectively stops the back and forth. Haechan shrugs and goes back to looking at all the commotion going on at both houses.
“What do we do now?” you mutter to yourself.
“The cops said we have to stick together, so that’s what we’ll do,” Jaehyun comforts.
Sticking together didn’t work very well, and you found yourself alone at the sorority house. Everyone was out studying or with their boyfriends. You’re scrolling on your phone when you get a call from an unknown number and against your better instinct, you answer.
“Hello?”
“Hello. Who is this?” you hear from the other end. It’s a male voice and one you don’t immediately recognize. It’s gruff and gravelly.
“Well, I was going to ask you that,” you say, sitting up in your bed, your mind running through all the possibilities on who it could be. It doesn’t make sense for Johnny to call because Jennie’s with him right now, and Jaehyun was still in class. It could be Haechan, but again, the voice doesn’t match.
“I’ll tell you my name if you tell me yours-”
“I’m not giving you my name- you called me,” you scoff.
“I guess that’s right. Maybe I just want to talk,” he offers.
“I’m sure you can find someone else to talk to. Have a good night,” you hang up and lay back down on your bed only to immediately get another call.
“Hello?”
“Why did you hang up on me?” he says, almost sounding kind of aggressive.
“Well, I don’t know who you are,” you respond, stating the obvious.
“What’s your favorite scary movie?”
“Oh- Ha ha, Haechan. How funny. I like the sexy thing you’re doing with your voice- it’s really turning me on,” you tease.
“I’m not Haechan- answer the question. What’s your favorite scary movie?”
“I don’t know, Haechan- you know I don’t watch that shit.”
“Why not? Too scared?”
“No, it’s just- they’re all the same. Some big breasted girl always goes out in the open to investigate a noise while this loser man is obviously trying to lure her out to kill her. It’s honestly insulting.”
“Oh yeah? How do you think you’ll fare? What’ll you do when I try to lure you out to kill you?”
“What-” you freeze, and then you hear a noise downstairs.
“You heard me-” he replies as you stick your head out your bedroom door.
“Hello?” you shakily yell out into the house to see who’s there.
“Why would you say hello, sweets? Don’t you know that’s what every ‘big breasted girl’ calls out before the killer gets her?”
You make your way downstairs trying to figure out what that noise was since no one is supposed to be home. You are also still working under the assumption that this is Haechan playing a prank on you.
“Haechan? Come out, come out wherever you are,” you say halfheartedly, still trying to joke despite the fact that you don’t want him to jump out and scare you.
“You’ll have to come and find me, sweets. And in case you haven’t realized it yet- this isn’t Haechan.”
You don’t see any movement, and no one has made themselves known, so none of your sorority sisters are here. You haven’t heard another noise, but just in case, you walk into the kitchen to grab a knife and find that they’re all gone. Now, you really start to panic, and the voice on the phone hasn’t said anything more but is still on the line.
You hear another noise coming from the bathroom at the end of the hallway and begin walking towards the noise as slowly as possible, tip-toeing to avoid making any noise.
“Hello?” you say in a voice just above a whisper. The killer jumps out from one of the bedroom doors behind you and tackles you to the floor. He tries to slam the knife into you but you grab a hold of his arms and try holding him off. He grabs your hair with his free hand and slams your head against the floor, making you feel disoriented for a second. You’re now vulnerable again, and he trails the knife across your cheek, nicking you slightly. He lifts his arms high to get as much momentum as possible to stab you when you suddenly kick him in the dick with all your might. He is obviously temporarily incapacitated and falls backwards, clutching his family jewels, giving you the opening to run up the stairs back to your room.
As you run up, you dial 911 and quickly give them your address.
“Please help me, he’s here- the killer’s here!” you go into the corner of your room and slide down the wall as the phone operator tries to make sure you’re okay. Ghostface bangs on the door and then suddenly, the banging stops. You stare at your door for what feels like hours, and then Jaehyun hops through your window. You, of course, scream bloody murder.
“Whoa, whoa, whoa. What's wrong? Are you okay? What happened? You look like you’ve seen a ghost, sweetie-” he says, almost smiling. You panic. It feels like you’re going to pass out because why would he say that? It has to be him. He has to be the killer. It's too much of a coincidence for him to have been here at the same time as the killer and not see him. Details about the killer haven’t even been released yet, and he decides to use that turn of phrase? You’d rather be safe than sorry.
“No. No, no, nonono,” you cry as you run back down the stairs, only to run into a police officer at the front door.
“It’s Jeong Jaehyun! He’s the killer! Please! Help!!” you scream at the cop as he tries to calm you down. He escorts you outside as two more cops go in to arrest Jaehyun. Haechan heard the sirens and immediately rushed over, already waiting outside the sorority house. He holds you as the police officers take your boyfriend away. Jaehyun’s calling out your name as they put him in the back of the police car, begging you to believe him and to tell them that he didn’t do it. You turn into Haechan’s chest and try but fail to hold back your tears.
To no one’s surprise, the frat immediately decides to throw a party to celebrate the capture of the killer, not caring that a member of their brotherhood was arrested. Any excuse to get absolutely obliterated on a school night. You, however, aren't in a party mood obviously, so you hang out with Haechan in his room instead.
“Oh my god, that psycho!” he yells, stomping around his room as you recount everything that just happened with Jaehyun. “I always knew he was a freak- I should’ve reported him when I was being interrogated-” He looks up to see that you’re still pretty shaken up and not interested in yelling about your boyfriend being arrested. He takes a seat next to you on the bed and pulls you into his arms. The action makes you start crying again, feeling so overwhelmed.
“It’s okay, sweets. It’ll all be okay-” he soothes and rubs your back softly. You look up at him, and before you know it, he’s kissing you. At first, you’re surprised, but it doesn’t take much time for you to give in and kiss him back. Then a smidgen of logic hits you and you pull back, but not very far, still letting your forehead rest against his.
“Don’t.. say anything just yet… okay?” Haechan pleads, “I’d like the chance to talk about my feelings for you when you don’t have a boyfriend who’s in jail.”
“Okay,” you whisper, giving him a kiss on the cheek.
The two of you get ready for bed, and you fall asleep cuddled up in Haechan’s arms while the party rages on downstairs.
And while Jennie’s getting murdered down the road.
You wake up somewhat early the next morning and walk back to the sorority house. You know when you arrive that everyone will still be asleep and/or hungover from the night before. Thoughts of what to cook for the girls before their classes swirl in your mind when you walk up and see Jennie hanging from a tree in the front yard. You scream louder than you ever have before and fall to the floor in tears. Her body is covered in blood and she has been completely gutted, her insides falling out of her.
Jaehyun gets released a few hours later because it’s obviously not him seeing as Jennie was killed while he was in custody. You’re so distraught and you feel so awful and simultaneously responsible. If you hadn’t said it was Jaehyun, the cops would have kept patrol cars in the area, the real killer could have been caught, and Jennie would still be alive.
You also feel so guilty for ever thinking it could possibly be your sweet boyfriend who has never given you any reason to doubt him. You’re beating yourself up over it in your head when he stops you in the hallway.
“Hey.”
“Hi,” you respond, unable to meet his eyes.
“Oh my- don’t tell me you still think it’s me-” he says in disbelief. That makes you look up at him immediately.
“No! No, I don’t. I just- I feel so bad that I’m the reason you were suspected. I’m so sorry-” you blink up at him desperate for forgiveness.
“Let’s talk about this later, yeah? Come over after my last class tonight and we can talk then.”
He kisses you softly before you two part ways.
You’re incredibly anxious, and you’ve been dreading this conversation since seeing Jaehyun earlier. Is he going to break up with you? You probably would if you were in his shoes. How do you date someone who so easily turns you into the police for a crime you didn’t commit?
As you walk up, you see him already waiting for you outside.
“Hey!”
“Hi.”
“Maybe we should move on from monosyllables,” he jokes, leading you inside, “No one’s home, so we can have our conversation without worrying about anyone else listening.”
Once you get to his room, you feel the words bubbling up out of you like word vomit.
“I’m so sorry. I was panicking! And you just happened to be there at the perfect time- and I guess I just got sort of scrambled? I don’t actually believe that you could do something like that,” you promise.
“I’m glad that you don’t think I could do that because I’m not sure that I’d like the idea you have of me in your little brain. You had me scared, baby. I thought that you didn’t trust me-” he says, wrapping his arms around your waist. He begins kissing you and slowly leads you over to the bed. He lays you down and starts kissing your neck, your body relaxing at his touch.
“You trust me, right, baby?” he asks, kissing the swell of your chest.
“You’re not gonna break up with me?” you ask through a sigh.
“Break up with you? No, pretty girl- I’m gonna keep you around,” he slides his hand under your shirt as he continues to kiss along your jaw and neck. Slowly, he peels your shirt off and ogles you as if it’s the first time he’s seen you.
“You’re so pretty for me, sweets.”
You squirm under his gaze and pull him back down so he can kiss you. He’s slow and deliberate and licks your bottom lip to ask for entry, which you immediately grant. His tongue massages yours as his hands move up to knead your breasts through your bra. He once again begins to trail down leaving kisses in his wake until he gets to your lower abdomen. His proximity to you means you can feel his breaths causing your back to involuntarily arch.
“Aw, baby, did you miss me?”
“Yes, Jae, please-” you whine, eyes closed. You’re already lost in subspace.
“Please what, sweets?”
“Please use me-”
He groans at your response and quickly rips your pants and undies off your body as you remove your bra, leaving you completely bare. The feeling of his breathing so close to your body continues to give you goosebumps. Despite your growing need, Jaehyun teases you and kisses your inner thighs getting closer to your heat, but he avoids it completely. He continues kissing just outside of the area where you need him, even leaving a wet kiss on your mound.
He can tell you’re feeling restless, and he doesn’t want to be that mean. Deciding to be slightly nicer, he gently licks at your bud, and it only amplifies your desperation. It’s not nearly enough pressure, but you know that he has every right to fuck with you and you do not want to be punished. Unfortunately, your body starts involuntarily grinding against his face. Realizing just how needy you must be, he gives in and gives you what you want, sloppily eating you out, stimulating you in all the best ways. You feel his tongue everywhere and the way he licks your bundle of nerves is delicious. It doesn’t take long before you feel the cord in your stomach snap. You moan and try to squirm, but Jaehyun holds you down as he licks you through it.
When you come back to earth, Jaehyun pulls back and looks at you with an unreadable look. He wipes his mouth with the back of his hand and asks, “Do you want me to fuck you, sweets?”,
You lazily nod.
“Words, baby,” Jaehyun says in a low voice.
“Yes, Jae- please fuck me,” you whine. That’s the confirmation he was looking for to line himself up with your entrance, and he slowly pushes in letting you adjust to him.
“Jaeeeee,” you whimper, and he knows it’s his cue to start moving. Your boyfriend’s dick fills you up so nicely, and you’re so sensitive- the feeling of him already has you approaching your second high. Your legs are wrapped around him as he pounds into you, hands gripping your hips so hard you’re sure you’ll feel the bruises tomorrow. He can feel from the way you clench around him that you’re close again.
“Wow, sweets- you really needed me-” he smirks, and he starts rubbing your clit with his thumb to get you there faster. You close your eyes relishing in the feeling, getting closer and closer. But then you feel him stop moving. When you open your eyes, you see Ghostface holding up a knife to Jaehyun’s throat, and you scream, feeling like you’ve walked into a nightmare.
“Please- please, please, please don’t hurt us” Jaehyun begs, face pale and dick still inside of you. You forget how to breathe watching the scene unfold, and there’s a brief pause before the killer begins to remove his mask to reveal-
“Johnny?!” you scream. “But… but you killed Jennie? Why would you do that?”
“Because I can-” he responds using the voice changer with a smile so wide you’d swear it was the best day of his life. His expression is so contradictory to the macabre topic at hand, and you’re confused, so confused. Your brows furrow as you look from Jaehyun to Johnny.
Suddenly, Johnny removes the knife from Jaehyun’s neck and your boyfriend’s fearful expression drops. As if the quick change in demeanor wasn’t shocking enough, he resumes fucking you again as if nothing had happened, leading you to feel even more disoriented. You can hear your heartbeat in your ears, and it actually feels like you might pass out. You’re also being fucked hard and you were already so close before Johnny came in, so that feeling is coming right back.
“I can’t believe you turned me in, baby- I thought we were stronger than that,” Jaehyun says, slamming into you, making your eyes roll to the back of your head. “Johnny was so gracious to help get me out, but- he didn’t do it out of the kindness in his heart. He wants something in return.” you stare up in horror at Jaehyun’s implication, rendered speechless.
“Don’t you wanna know what he wants?” Jaehyun grins.
“How about a hint?” Johnny says from his spot next to Jaehyun, “You know… I’ve always had a thing for you, Y/N-”
You involuntarily clench at the confession. Fuck- why did you do that.
“Oh? Dirty girl. You want Johnny, sweets? You squeezed me sooooo fucking tight just now,” Jaehyun teases.
You whine at his words and feel so conflicted. Turning your head away, you close your eyes and try to focus on anything but how good Jaehyun feels inside you right now. Johnny makes his way to your side and lightly drags the knife across your skin, tracing from your jaw down to your neck and chest.
“Do you want me, baby?” Johnny asks, knife pressed against the base of your throat. Yes. No. Fuck!
They're murderers! They killed your friend, and they might kill you when they’re done with you!
(But you’ve never felt so turned on in your life.)
You nod shyly, avoiding eye contact with Johnny.
“Say it baby. Say that you want my loser killer dick inside of you-” Johnny orders, using your previous words against you, grabbing your chin to force you to look at him. He really is so pretty even with that deranged look in his eyes.
“I want you inside of me, Johnny. Please!” you whimper, your face heating up at the embarrassment you feel at being turned on right now.
“That’s what I like to hear.”
The two deviants reposition you so you’re on your hands and knees as a naked Johnny gets situated against the headboard. He’s so big and thick, definitely bigger than Jaehyun, and your mouth waters as you gaze upon what you’re working with.
“Already cockdrunk, sweets?” Johnny smirks at your reaction to him, “I haven’t even touched you yet and you’re drooling-”
You lower yourself to a comfortable position and look up at Johnny as you lick a stripe from base to tip making him groan.
“Fuck, baby- don’t tease me,” he growls, his hand moving to your head to ground himself.
And so you don’t tease. You decide to give it your all, but his dick is way too big for you to suck him off the same way you do for Jaehyun. You start with the head, but the second that you put the tip in your mouth, Jaehyun starts fucking you again and much harder this time. You think he must be turned on by watching you suck off Johnny, and you tighten around him at the thought. You begin bobbing your head on Johnny’s cock (or at least what you can fit in your mouth), and you moan and whine as Jaehyun continues to brutally fuck into you.
“Fuck, look at you-” Johnny groans, “Your boyfriend and your boyfriend’s best friend killed people and you’re letting them fuck you.”
You’ve been holding back your orgasm for so long, and Johnny’s words are enough to launch you into it. You pull off of his cock and you feel your orgasm wash over you, your moans filling the room. It’s so intense and you’re gripping onto Jaehyun’s dick so tightly that you rip his orgasm out of him, forcing him to cum deep in your hole.
“Fuck- did you just cum because Johnny reminded you that we’re killers? Shit, sweets, you’re just as fucked up as we are,” Jaehyun says moaning and groaning as he keeps shooting cum deep into your pussy. He fucks you to the point of overstimulating the both of you until he genuinely can’t take it anymore. He stills but stays buried in you, trying to recover, throwing his head back and catching his breath. You then come to the realization that he has never fucked you unprotected before, and he has definitely never finished inside you.
“Fuck, baby- you can’t squeeze me like that,” he croaks, his eyes squeezing shut.
“Alright, get out of the way, Jeong- it’s my turn.”
“Alright, asshole, relax!” Jaehyun snaps, pulling out of you and hissing at the feeling.
Johnny slides into the empty space that Jaehyun leaves, flips you over, and says, “Alright, perfect. I want you to see who’s fucking you this good, okay, sweetie?”
He pushes into your entrance and stretches you out way more than Jaehyun’s dick did but he does not give you the same amount of time to adjust and instead immediately starts driving his cock into you hard and fast.
“Fuuuuuuck, sweets. This is everything I've dreamed of. Do you know how long I had to watch you from afar and deal with all these fucking bitches? I could give a shit about Jennie or Wendy or any of these other girls. Shit- how could I pay attention to any of them when this sweet pot of honey was right here waiting for me?”
Your pussy flutters at the compliment and Johnny chuckles.
“Damn, you got so tight around me, baby. Do you like hearing about how we killed for you? Got rid of Wendy and fuckass Joshua for you. I know Wendy was a huge bitch to you, and Joshua spread your nudes around so obviously we had to get rid of them.”
You’re shocked at the fact that they killed for you, shocked that they even know these things since it wasn’t very well known that Wendy was consistently trying to ruin your life. The Joshua thing is more public given the nature, but it happened years ago.
“And Jennie? You know, Jennie wouldn’t have had to die if it wasn’t for you telling the cops to arrest Jae and her being so easy to get rid of. Honestly, don’t feel so bad- we probably would have killed her anyway, but it wasn’t part of our grand plan,” he monologues over your moans while sharply bucking into you. All of it is too much- his words, the fact that Johnny is inside of you and Jaehyun is watching, how sensitive you are from the last 2 orgasms.
“Johnny- please. I’m gonna-”
He wraps a hand around your throat and pounds his length into you harder and faster than you thought was humanly possible. The combination of the pressure on your pulse and the strength with which Johnny is pounding into you sends you toppling over and you convulse under the large man. You feel the pleasure pulsing and radiating in a way you’ve never felt, experiencing absolute ecstasy. Johnny fucks you through your high and shoots his release into you, shuddering at the feeling of your gummy walls milking him for all he’s worth.
“Oh my god, angel-” Johnny starts.
“Johnny’s dick made you squirt-” Jaehyun finishes in awe.
You’re laying on Jaehyun’s bed absolutely spent, their words hardly registering in your brain. You feel someone cleaning you up and you shiver. It feels like you’ve been fucked within an inch of your life, but you suppose the fear of being killed in the middle of sex will do that to you. You begin drifting off to sleep when you hear-
“I can’t believe you fuckers started without me-”
“We’re changing the ending, Haechan. That pussy is too good to waste.”
divider^ by @/strangergraphics (perfect for this fic thx so much!!!)
read ghostface!nomin here!
