First Impression: Ugh, your theme. I love it so much. Everything is neat, and you can clearly see what's going on. The darker red also hints at vampires (of course) which is definitely more than appropriate for the RP. I also love how your description isn't on the home page, where it would clutter everything up- though it is a little confusing not to have an introduction of some sort on the main page. Still, a great first impression! 4/5
Plotline: Ok, this is obviously not an original plot, which you've stated, but I still love your summary of it. For someone who's only maybe read a few chapters of the first book, I was very well informed of what was going on. And thank you, thank you, thank you for including a summary of the books! It's good to see that, because for someone who is new to the fandom, or for people who just need a reminder of what has happened, that is perfect. All in all, this is very well done. 5/5
Links/Navigation: Seriously, I don't know if I'm supposed to be giving you advice, here. You clearly know what you're doing! All of the links are working and easy to find, and I don't get lost. 5/5
Characters: From what I can see, you've got a great understanding of the characters, and there's a great balance of faceclaims for them as well. I honestly don't have any criticism here at all. Just... brilliant. 4/5
Would I Join? I would, yes! I mean, I'd probably have to read Vampire Academy properly, but this looks amazing and I'd love to be a part of it!
Anything Else: Ok, seriously? I have nothing to say. This RP is flawless.