Heyy!! I loved your peter x gwen!reader fic...I wonder if you could also do a long NWH one shot with the same gwen!reader ... Where when peter 3 enters the portal for the first time he sees reader and get's flashbacks of his gwen and gets a little sad but reader is really suspicious of him at that time and throws bread like mj and wants to confirm that he's Spiderman and all .After this when peter 3 tells peter 1 tells about his gwen . The fall part where reader falls instead of mj but gets saved by peter 3 . Finally the last part where peter 1 tells ned , mj and reader that they're gonna forget about him... Ikkk it's long but pretty pleaseee 😭😭😭😭❤️ I really wanted to see peter 1 with his gwen and you wrote your fic (which I loved) which gave me this story's motivation .
in another life | peter parker
pairing: mcu!peter x gwen!reader, tasm!peter x gwen!reader (platonic)
word count: 3,5k
summary: where two peters protect their gwen
a/n: i absolutely LOVE this idea!! tasm peter and his gwen always make me cry so i hope you like this <3 don't forget to reblog, it means the world
warnings: angst, mentions of blood, mentions of injuries, mentions of death
universe: marvel
“I just wish we could see Peter”, Ned says with his eyes closed, moving his hands the way you’ve all seen Doctor Strange do. To MJ’s and your – as well as Ned’s grandmother’s – surprise, however, one of those magical portals actually opens right in front of you in the middle of the kitchen. Ned’s grandmother slowly emerges from her hiding place and speaks to Ned in Filipino and MJ whispers something in amazement, but your gaze is solely focused on the dark alleyway the portal now leads to.
Wide-eyed, you notice the silhouette at the end of the alley slowly approaching you, which causes you to take a careful step back. MJ and Ned, however, don’t seem too frightened by the sight, and they call out to the silhouette, who, as he approaches, reveals himself to be Spiderman.
But you immediately notice that something is wrong, because this isn’t Peter’s normal suit – something about it is different you just can’t quite pin-point what it is.
Ned’s grandmother is the only one sharing your fear considering that when Peter suddenly jumps through the portal, she immediately throws a pillow at him.
“No, no, no! It’s okay, it’s okay! I’m a nice guy!”, Spiderman calls to you with his hands raised in the air. When he pulls off his mask the next second, your breath catches in your throat. The boy in the suit isn’t Peter. Ned explicitly asked for Peter Parker when he summoned the portal and this boy isn’t him. He can’t possibly be Peter; the suit must have been stolen. Or the magic didn’t work after all. Either way, the stranger seems just as confused as you, his hands still raised in surrender to show that he poses no threat to any of you.
“Who the hell are you?” It’s MJ who breaks the silence first, her body in a fighting stance right next to you. When he tells you that he is, in fact, Peter Parker, you stare at him in utter disbelief.
“That’s not possible”, you say, giving him a once-over. When your eyes meet, you feel the lump in your throat tighten.
“I am Spiderman. In my world”, he starts explaining, looking at each of you. “But then yesterday I was- I was just here.. Wow!”
You and MJ exchange a confused look and you mouth the word ‘crazy’ while this Spiderman imposter continues to throw around some physics terms, which only Ned understands.
“So, magic’s real here too?”, he asks Ned, who in his naivety immediately starts talking about sorcerers and magicians before MJ can finally silence him.
“Prove it”, you speak up, throwing a stern look at ‘Peter’.
“Prove what?”
“That you are Peter Parker.”
“I don’t carry an ID with me, you know? Kind of defeats the whole anonymous superhero–.”
He can’t even finish his sentence before you quickly grab a piece of bread from the dining table and throw it against his chest. His face is completely bewildered as he asks you, shrugging: “Why’d you do that?”
“I was trying to see if you have the tingle thing”, you tell him in all honesty. MJ and Ned also look at you in surprise, but they don’t actually seem averse to your idea.
“I have the tingle thing, just not for bread”, ‘Peter’ says in a voice that sounds as if he’s sorry for what he just witnessed. Since his answers do not convince you in the slightest, you arm yourself with the next piece of bread.
“I see. You are a deeply mistrusting person and I respect that”, he tells you and before you know it, he attaches himself to the ceiling with his fingertips.
“Crawl around”, MJ orders him, pointing to the other end of the room.
“Crawl around?”
“Yes.”
“Why do I need to crawl around?”
“This.. is not enough”, MJ gestures to what he is doing right in front of you – hanging from the ceiling.
“It’s plenty”, he answers, but when MJ still does not give in and Ned’s grandma asks him to clean up the spider webs while he’s already up there, he finally complies. With his mask in his mouth to prevent it from falling, he crawls along the ceiling. Just like your Peter. How is that possible?
“We’re good?”, he asks when he jumps down right in front of you, studying your face as if something in there interests him and he can’t quite understand what it is.
“For now”, MJ answers, still feeling a bit defensive about the whole situation. “Gwen, what was Peter’s.. our Peter’s last known location again?”
The second MJ says your name, something changes in Peter’s face and he abruptly takes a step back, as if someone had shot him. You watch in surprise as his eyes glaze over and you answer MJ, not sure how to interpret his strange behaviour.
“You’re... You’re Gwen Stacy?”, he stutters, taking a tiny step closer to you as if you intrigue him in some way. Which, to be fair, makes you feel a bit uncomfortable.
“I am. And apparently you are Peter Parker”, you tell him, still not fully convinced of what happened in the last few minutes. “Why? What happened to the Gwen in your universe?”
This question seems to struck a nerve, because once again he looks as if someone had inflicted serious harm on him. All of a sudden, you’re not sure you even want to know.
“It’s.. it’s not important. So, where do we find your Peter Parker?”
════════════
Your heart shatters when you spot Peter sitting on the roof, completely devastated, his cheeks damp from all the tears he’s shed because of his aunt. When you see him like this, tears threaten to well up in your eyes, but you know you have to be strong for him now, for the both of you. So, without a word, you go to him and take him in your arms, which he gratefully accepts, his bloodied hands wrapping around your arm. You place a gentle kiss on his temple, causing a gasp to escape his lips, rocking his entire body and yours with it. He continues to let his tears flow freely in your arms – the only place he can feel safe now –, the loss of his beloved aunt too heavy to bear. You adored and loved her dearly too – she had always been so kind and sincere.
‘If I can no longer be there for Peter one day, I know you’ll be there for him in my place.’ Those were her words to you just a short while ago, and you simply cannot comprehend the fact that she’s now forever gone.
“I’m sorry. I’m so sorry, my love”, you softly whisper in his ear, his violent sobs tearing your heart to pieces. You stay in this position for a while, holding each other or rather Peter holding on to you. You don’t know how much time passed when Peter’s spider senses kick in and he lifts his head to look around for the source.
“There’s.. There’s some people here”, you tell him, cupping his cheek in your hand. Since you don’t want to force him to do anything, you leave it up to him whether he wants to get up or continue to curl up in your arms. However, his senses seem to be telling him that there might be a potential danger, so he quickly jumps up, pushes you behind him, and looks up at the tower, where two silhouettes are now illuminated by the moonlight.
When they come jumping down and reveal themselves, Peter is completely taken aback and one of his hands gestures for you to stay close behind him. He doesn’t know yet that you have not only accumulated one, but two Spidermans from other universes. It doesn’t take him long, however, to recognize them for who they are.
When they try to express their condolences, your Peter immediately interrupts them.
“Please don’t tell me that you know what I’m going through”, his weak voice says, quivering. “She’s gone. It’s all my fault. She died for nothing.”
You listen to him trying to get rid of them while talking himself down for what he did or didn’t do. You’d love nothing more than to hold him tightly in your arms again and protect him from all the evil in this world, but at this moment, you’re not the superhero he needs. The only thing you can do is wrap your hand around one of his.
“I lost- I lost Gwen. M-My Gwen”, one of them now says, his gaze switching between yours and Peters and suddenly it all makes sense. Why he acted so weirdly once he found out your name. Why it felt like he was seeing something or someone in you. Why his heart shattered upon seeing you.
Peter immediately squeezes your hand tightly.
“I couldn’t save her. I’m never going to be able to forgive myself for that”, he continues his story, tears pricking not only his eyes, but your own as well. “But I carried on, tried to uhm.. tried to keep going, tried to keep being the friendly neighborhood Spiderman. Because I know that’s what she would have wanted, but at some point.. I just.. I stopped pulling my punches. I got rageful. I got bitter. I just don’t want you to end up like.. like me.”
A tear runs down your cheek and you quickly wipe it away with the sleeve of your free hand, feeling like you have no right to cry in this situation. This Peter lost his Gwen because he wasn’t able to save her in time. You, on the other hand, are still standing here, alive and well. But the thought that you could face the same fate as your twin from another universe terrifies you. And your Peter seems to feel the same way, because he takes a step forward, losing your hand from his grip.
In this moment, both of you realize that just because you are a superhero, doesn’t always mean being able to save the ones you love.
“I want to kill him. I want to kill him so he can’t hurt the last people I have left. I want to tear him apart”, he says with so much anger and hatred in his voice that you almost do not recognize him. But, somehow, you understand. You feel for him. You feel with him.
Because he is your Peter Parker and you are his Gwen Stacy.
════════════
Everything happened so fast: one second you were standing on the scaffolding with MJ and Ned, surrounded by villains from different universes, the next second a bomb explodes, almost tearing the entire scaffolding apart, and you lost your balance. You fall down, not being able to hold onto anything as the solid ground comes closer and closer. An earth-shattering scream escapes you, your mind not able to form any clear thoughts – no last memories or words, nothing.
Helplessly, you wag your arms in the air, even though you know it’s utterly useless. Your free fall into certain death could hardly be stopped now. But then you suddenly see your Peter throw himself after you, coming much closer much faster. His hand reaches out for you. Your fingertips touch lightly before he’s suddenly pushed aside by one of Green Goblin’s gliders.
As if time slows down, you watch as all hope of rescue fades right in front of your eyes. However, you didn’t expect Peter 3, as you’ve started calling him so you can distinguish them, to also swing after you to save you, and suddenly you’re overcome by a strange feeling, as if you’ve experienced this situation before, perhaps in a previous life.
Or in another life.
When he finally reaches you, he pulls you into his arms, turns both of you around in the air, and breaks your fall with a spider web, smoothly landing on the ground, loose parts from the scaffolding hitting the ground around you. It’s hard for you to breathe as you look up and see the long distance you’ve fallen.
“Are you okay?”, Peter 3 asks you, still carrying your entire body in his arms as he looks at you with tears in his eyes. Your vocal cords fail, so you can only nod several times in rapid succession to tell him that you are, in fact, alright. But even though you’ve been saved, your heart feels incredibly heavy.
“A-Are you okay?”, you ask him now, watching a tear run down his cheek. He has to think about the answer to that question for a moment, examining your face before finally nodding as well. As he lowers you to the ground, you throw your arms around his neck, holding him tightly because you feel like that’s exactly what he needs right now.
“I couldn’t.. I couldn’t let it happen again”, he sobs into the crook of your neck, hugging you back.
“I know, I know”, you try to soothe him, running your hand over his back. “Your Gwen would be so proud of you.”
════════════
You run into Peter’s arms as soon as he lands in front of you. He catches you with a groan, and even though everything must be aching like hell, he doesn’t let it show. His hands gently wrap around your waist and tightly press your body against his.
“Oh, you’re okay!”, MJ breathes a sigh of relief behind you and before you know it, her and Ned join the hug. The relief you all feel is immeasurable and yet you can sense a little reluctance on Peter’s part, his body stiff.
After several seconds, his grip on you loosens a little so he can get a better look at all of you.
“Are you okay?”, he asks, looking at each of you in more detail.
“Yeah, we’re okay”, Ned tells him with a smile, nodding. Peter smiles back, but when he looks at you more closely, really looks at you, fear fills his eyes all of a sudden, and he takes your face between his hands. Worry is etched all across his torn but handsome face.
“Oh my god, you’re bleeding!”, he exclaims, his thumb softly brushing over the spot on your cheek. It doesn’t even hurt when he touches it and you place your hand on top of his.
“I’m fine, I’m okay.”
“You sure?”
“I’m fine. I promise”, you genuinely smile at him, the worry in his eyes slowly making way for something else. If you didn’t know better, he looks sad. Defeated. He looks at you with so much intensity now, as if he were memorizing your face, every tiny detail, every little part he loves so much, so he would never forget it.
“We should go, right?”, MJ now says, looking up at the sky where Doctor Strange is still hovering over the Statue of Liberty. Her words finally pull Peter out of his trance, and he shakes his head, swallowing a lump. He looks back and forth between the three of you, then up at the magician, before looking you straight in the eyes when he says: “You- You’re gonna forget who I am.”
“What?”, Ned immediately asks, confused. You can’t interpret his words either. Forget Peter? As if you ever could. However, something in his face tells you that you will, no matter how much you resist.
“Forget who you are? What are you even talking about?”, MJ asks, stepping closer while you take an almost imperceptible step back.
“It’s okay”, Peter starts, taking a tentative step towards you, but you can only shake your head in disbelief, retreating even more.
“None of this is okay! I won’t forget you!”, you tell him, making clear where you stand.
“I’m gonna come and find you, and I’ll explain everything”, his voice breaks at the end, seeing how a tear slips down your cheek and you immediately wipe it away with your sleeve.
“No, no, no. No!”, you yell at him now, knowing only that one word. How can he expect something like that from you? How can he expect you to agree to all of this? You don’t want to forget him. You can’t forget him.
Within seconds, Peter grabs your hand and pulls you towards him, but you resist with all your might. You pound your fists against his chest, and he lets you, only for that one word to leave your mouth over and over again. No, no, no, no, no.
“I’ll make you remember me”, he softly whispers. Even though you hit him and push him and take out all your anger on him, he remains calm and eventually holds you so tightly in his arms that you give up, sobbing, your body shaking.
“Please, love. Please stop. I don’t want to let you go like this. I don’t want you to hate me in our last moments”, he pleads with you, running one hand over your back soothingly. “I promise I’ll make you remember me. And it’ll be like none of this ever happened. Okay?”
“B-But what if that doesn’t work? What if that doesn’t work?”, you cry into his chest, listening to his heart hammering against his chest, trying to memorize the rhythm.
“I-”
“What if we can’t remember you? I don’t want that”, you tell him as he gently lifts your chin, forcing you to look up at him. His eyes search yours, but you can only scan his face, all the injuries, all the scars, all the little details that make him him. You only have so much time to memorize his face.
How is it possible that you’ll forget this face, his eyes that always greeted you with so much love and affection?
“I know, I know”, he sadly smiles, his hand running through your hair.
“And there’s nothing we can do?”, MJ asks now, her eyes teary as well. “We can’t come up with a plan? There’s always something we can do.”
“I fear there’s nothing we can do. But it’ll be okay”, Peter answers, directing the last words at you.
“You promise?”, your voice comes out weak, tears staining your cheeks.
“I promise”, he smiles, but you can clearly see the pain in his eyes. How much all of this hurts him, especially considering that he just recently lost one of the most important people in his life. Now he’ll lose all of you, too. You can’t imagine how he could ever handle that.
Peter slowly lets go of you, which you don’t want at first, but MJ and Ned also have the right to say goodbye to their best friend. MJ hugs Peter tightly and does his trademark fist bump with Ned, the one they always did in school, before hugging him too.
When he finally turns back to you, you want to burst into tears and never stop. It feels like your heart is shattering into a thousand pieces and can never, ever be mended. How are you supposed to go on without your Peter?
You can’t help but briefly think of Peter 3 and how he must have felt at that moment, losing his Gwen forever. You know this is a different situation, but who’s to say your Peter won’t lose you forever, too? That he’ll be able to make you remember him? As if reading your mind, he takes your hands in his, squeezing them, before saying: “I’ll come find you.”
“You better”, you sob, pulling him closer by your intertwined hands and placing them on your waist. “If you don’t, I’ll just figure it out. I’ve done it before, I can do it again.”
Your words actually make him laugh a little, and you too have to smile when you think back to the moment you found out he was Spiderman. It seems like so long ago now.
“I promise I’ll fix this”, he says with determination in his voice.
“I really hate magic.”
“Me too”, he chuckles, taking in your beautiful face one last time.
“I love you”, you say and you want to say it over and over and over again so all of New York knows. So that all of New York won’t forget and neither will you. Or him.
“I love-”
“Just wait”, you interrupt him, smiling sadly as you see the confusion on his face. “Wait and tell me when you see me again.”
A tear finds its way down his cheek now too as he softly nods. The energy around you crackles, the magic in the air sizzling and it feels like the whole world explodes the moment his lips meet yours. It’s a desperate kiss, but also full of love and promises. He doesn’t need to tell you how much he’ll miss you. You don’t need words to understand each other, you never did.
“I love you”, you whisper against his lips, but when you open your eyes, he’s gone.
Your Peter Parker is gone. And he took your heart with him.












