tbh i do not agree with people saying melissa is a butch lesbian. she's futch if anything because my girl did love to dabble in her feminine side
seen from Canada

seen from India
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from Türkiye
seen from Lithuania
seen from United States
seen from Germany

seen from United States
seen from Yemen
seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom
seen from Germany
seen from Germany
seen from Spain

seen from Malaysia
seen from United States
seen from United States
seen from Canada
tbh i do not agree with people saying melissa is a butch lesbian. she's futch if anything because my girl did love to dabble in her feminine side
i love her so much and she is definitely not the reason van palmer is dead
My dearest Mel,
Birthdays have always seemed strangely backwards to me.
Everyone spends the day celebrating the person who was born. They bring candles, flowers, cakes with your name carefully written across them. They gather around you with smiles that say, I’m so glad you’re here.
And every year I find myself thinking the same thing.
The people who are truly lucky are the ones standing around you.
Today is supposed to be about celebrating your life.
I keep catching myself celebrating the day our lives happened to find each other.
I’ve rewritten that sentence so many times.
Not because it isn’t true.
Because it somehow still doesn’t feel true enough.
I don’t think I’ve ever struggled with a page like this before.
Usually words arrive before I even realize I’m looking for them. They gather quietly somewhere in the back of my mind until I sit down with a pen, and then they come all at once, almost impatiently, as though they’ve been waiting for me to catch up.
You have ruined that.
Entirely.
I can write about grief.
I can write about loneliness.
I can write about people who have never existed and somehow convince strangers that they did.
But the moment I try to write about you…
Everything I’ve ever believed about language quietly falls apart.
It feels almost unfair.
I’ve spent years believing words could hold anything.
Entire lives.
Entire wars.
Entire hearts.
Then I met you.
Now I’m not entirely convinced the English language was designed for this.
How do you describe someone who has become one of the safest places you’ve ever known?
How do you explain that someone you’ve loved for only two months already feels woven into your ordinary days so naturally that your heart has stopped questioning their place there?
If I told anyone that, they’d probably laugh.
They’d tell me two months isn’t enough time.
That certainty should arrive slower.
That people should be more careful with their hearts.
Maybe they’re right.
I’ve never been particularly interested in what love is supposed to do.
Only in what it has quietly done to me.
I don’t think I fell in love with you all at once.
I think I fell in love with you in fragments.
In moments so small that I almost missed them while they were happening.
It wasn’t one conversation.
Or one kiss.
Or one perfect afternoon that divided my life into a before and an after.
It was quieter than that.
Far quieter.
It was realizing that whenever something happened, whether it was wonderful or completely ordinary, you were the first person I wanted to tell.
Not because I made myself think of you.
Because I simply… did.
I’ll read a sentence that makes me stop halfway through a page and wonder whether you’d underline it too.
I’ll pass a little bookstore tucked between buildings and instinctively slow down because I know you’d want to disappear inside for hours.
I’ll hear someone laugh across campus, and for the briefest second my heart will convince itself it’s you before my head has the chance to disagree.
It’s become almost embarrassing.
You’ve made yourself wonderfully unavoidable.
The strange part is…
I don’t remember giving you permission to occupy so much of my mind.
You simply arrived.
Quietly.
Politely.
As though my heart had opened the door before the rest of me even realized someone was knocking.
Sometimes I wonder if love is less like falling and more like learning another language.
At first you think carefully about every word.
Every sentence feels uncertain.
You hesitate.
You wonder whether you’ve said too much.
Or not enough.
And then, one day, without noticing exactly when it happened…
You stop translating.
It simply becomes the way your heart speaks.
That’s what loving you has felt like.
Natural enough to surprise me.
I know people like to talk about certainty as though it’s something loud.
As though it arrives with fireworks or orchestras or impossible coincidences.
Mine didn’t.
Mine arrived on an ordinary afternoon.
We’d been talking for hours.
After we said goodbye, I found myself replaying the conversation instead of letting it end.
Not the important parts.
The little ones.
The way you paused before answering one of my questions.
The way you laughed at your own joke halfway through telling it.
The way you said my name without realizing how carefully I’d remember it.
I remember sitting there thinking,
This is either the beginning of something wonderful…
…or I’m already in much deeper than I meant to be.
I laughed at myself.
Not because the thought was ridiculous.
Because, somehow, it felt quietly inevitable.
You have this remarkable ability to make me feel wonderfully understood.
Not because you always know exactly what I’m thinking.
But because you’ve never made me feel strange for thinking it.
That is a rarer gift than people realize.
I’ve spent so much of my life carefully editing myself before speaking.
Choosing the version of a thought that sounded the least complicated.
The least emotional.
The least… me.
And then you came along.
Somehow you’ve convinced me, without ever asking, that the unedited version deserves to be heard too.
I don’t know if I’ve ever thanked you for that.
I’m not even sure you realize you’ve been doing it.
Maybe that’s why it means so much.
The best parts of you never seem rehearsed.
They happen in the spaces between moments.
In the kindness you don’t think anyone notices.
In the softness you’ve never tried to perform.
In the way you make people feel seen simply by deciding they deserve your attention.
And I think…
I’ve quietly fallen in love with every single one of those moments.
There is something I’ve never told you.
I notice everything.
Not in the frightening way people joke about.
Not because I’m keeping score.
Simply because my heart has developed an incurable habit of paying attention whenever you’re near.
I notice the tiny pause before you answer a question that matters.
As though you’re carefully choosing the kindest version of the truth.
I notice that when you’re excited about something, your hands begin speaking before you do.
You don’t seem to realize it.
I hope you never do.
It’s one of my favorite things.
I notice the way your smile arrives in stages.
First your eyes.
Always your eyes.
The rest of the world catches up a heartbeat later.
I’ve become rather fond of that heartbeat.
I’ve begun measuring time by it.
I notice that when someone else is talking, you never listen simply to reply.
You listen as though every person deserves to be understood before they’re answered.
It’s such a gentle thing.
The sort of thing most people overlook.
I don’t think I’ll ever be able to.
I notice the way your voice changes when you’re speaking about something you love.
It becomes lighter.
Almost hopeful.
As though the words themselves are happy to belong to you.
Sometimes I stop listening to what you’re saying.
Not because I’m uninterested.
Because I become distracted by the sound of someone I love being completely herself.
I always make myself pay attention again.
You deserve to be heard properly.
I notice that you apologize far too often.
For taking up space.
For asking questions.
For speaking your mind.
For things that have never required an apology.
I wish you could see yourself through my eyes just once.
You’d realize you’ve never once been too much.
If anything…
You’ve made the world around you feel a little larger.
A little kinder.
A little easier to breathe inside.
I’ve wondered whether you know what you leave behind when you walk away from a room.
I don’t think you do.
People smile more.
They speak a little softer.
Something about your kindness lingers after you’ve gone, the way the scent of rain lingers long after the storm has already passed.
I don’t believe people are meant to be compared to miracles.
Miracles feel distant.
Untouchable.
You’re not.
You’re wonderfully, beautifully human.
You get tired.
You overthink.
You laugh at yourself.
You have bad days.
You doubt yourself far more than you should.
And somehow…
Those things have never made you less extraordinary to me.
They’ve only made loving you feel more honest.
Sometimes I catch myself looking at you and thinking something so simple that it almost embarrasses me.
There you are.
Not there’s the most beautiful girl I’ve ever seen.
Not there’s the love of my life.
Just…
There you are.
As though my heart has been searching every room for yours without bothering to tell the rest of me.
I don’t think it ever stopped.
Perhaps that’s what peace feels like.
Not excitement.
Not certainty.
Just the quiet relief of finding the person your soul has been hoping to see all day.
And every time it happens…
Every single time…
I find myself silently thanking whatever improbable sequence of moments brought us into each other’s lives.
Because two months ago…
You were someone I hoped to know better.
Today…
You’re someone I already can’t imagine not knowing.
Birthdays have always made me think about ordinary miracles.
Not the loud ones.
The quiet ones.
The kind that nobody notices while they’re happening.
Because somewhere, years ago, today was simply another day to almost everyone.
The sun came up.
People went to work.
Someone was probably late for an appointment.
Someone else was wondering what to make for dinner.
The world continued exactly as it always had.
Completely unaware that it had just become home to you.
I don’t know why that thought moves me as much as it does.
Maybe because none of us get to choose the day we arrive here.
None of us know whose lives we’ll wander into.
Whose heart we’ll slowly become a part of.
Who we’ll accidentally change simply by existing.
I wonder what the world looked like on the day you were born.
I wonder if it rained.
If the sky was clear.
If somebody opened a window.
If somewhere a song was playing on a radio while your mother held you for the first time.
You, of course, wouldn’t remember any of it.
How could you?
You had no way of knowing what your life would become.
You didn’t know the people you would love.
Or the people who would one day love you.
You didn’t know there would be a girl who would sit awake far later than she should, trying to find words worthy of wishing you a happy birthday.
And somehow…
I think that’s my favorite thing about life.
None of us arrive here knowing who we’re about to become.
Or who we’re about to become to someone else.
I don’t think you realize what you’ve become to me.
Not because you couldn’t.
Because you’ve never once asked to occupy that kind of space.
You simply did.
With your kindness.
Your patience.
Your laugh.
Your remarkable habit of making people feel as though they’re the only person in the room when they’re speaking.
You never demanded to be important.
You simply loved people honestly.
And somehow…
That honesty found its way into me.
Sometimes I wonder how many versions of myself existed before I met you.
The girl who thought too much.
Who hid behind books.
Who found it easier to write feelings than to say them.
She’s still here.
She always will be.
But she’s softer now.
She laughs more easily.
She looks forward instead of over her shoulder.
She catches herself smiling for reasons that would’ve confused her a few months ago.
You didn’t rescue me.
I don’t think love is supposed to rescue anyone.
But you reminded me that life could be gentler than I’d allowed myself to believe.
I don’t know if there’s a greater gift one person can give another than that.
So today…
While everyone else is wishing you happiness…
I find myself wanting to thank you instead.
Thank you for every conversation that somehow became too short.
Thank you for every laugh you’ve unknowingly left echoing around in my head.
Thank you for every ordinary moment you’ve transformed into something I keep returning to long after it’s over.
And thank you…
For being born.
Because I genuinely cannot imagine this year without you in it.
And I don’t think I’d ever want to try.
There’s one last thing I’d like to tell you before I finally stop pretending I know how to end this letter.
I’ve always believed that people spend too much time looking for extraordinary love.
The kind people write books about.
The kind people remember for centuries.
The kind that feels larger than life.
But if these last two months have taught me anything…
It’s that extraordinary love is almost always disguised as something wonderfully ordinary.
It’s asking how your day was and genuinely wanting to hear every answer.
It’s walking a little slower because you unconsciously matched the other person’s pace.
It’s remembering something they mentioned weeks ago because, to you, it was never a small thing.
It’s reaching the end of a good day and realizing your favorite part wasn’t where you were.
It was who you were with.
I think that’s what you’ve quietly become.
Not just someone I love spending time with.
Someone who has changed the way I experience time itself.
Days seem shorter.
Goodbyes seem longer.
And ordinary moments have developed this astonishing habit of becoming memories before they’ve even ended.
I don’t know what the future looks like.
Truthfully…
I don’t think anyone does.
Maybe that’s part of what makes loving another person such a remarkable act.
You’re choosing them without ever being promised tomorrow.
You’re saying,
“If tomorrow comes… I’d like to meet it beside you.”
I think that’s one of the bravest things a heart can do.
And mine…
Well.
Mine has become incredibly brave since meeting you.
So, on your birthday, I don’t want to promise you forever.
Forever is a word far too large for any letter.
Instead, I’ll promise you something I know I can keep.
I’ll keep noticing.
I’ll notice when your smile reaches your eyes before the rest of your face.
I’ll notice the stories you tell more than once because they’re worth hearing every time.
I’ll notice when you’re pretending you’re fine, and I’ll sit beside you until pretending doesn’t feel necessary anymore.
I’ll notice every reason you forget to give yourself credit.
And, if you’ll let me…
I’ll spend as long as I possibly can reminding you of them.
Because you deserve to be loved in all the quiet ways you love everyone else.
You deserve someone who pays attention.
You deserve someone who chooses you on ordinary Tuesdays just as enthusiastically as birthdays.
You deserve to be reminded, over and over again, that your existence has made at least one life undeniably brighter.
Mine.
Thank you…
For the last two months.
For every conversation that somehow lasted longer than either of us expected.
For every laugh that found a permanent home inside my memory.
For every moment you’ve looked at me in a way that made me believe I could stop hiding pieces of myself.
Thank you for trusting me with your heart.
I hope I continue earning that trust every single day.
And finally…
Happy birthday.
I hope this year is gentle with you.
I hope it surprises you in all the best ways.
I hope it gives you reasons to laugh until your stomach hurts.
I hope it gives you quiet mornings, favorite songs, well-loved books, unexpected joys, and people who never make you question how deeply you’re cared for.
Most selfishly…
I hope it lets me stay close enough to watch you become every beautiful version of yourself that’s still waiting to be discovered.
Because I’d like very much to meet every one of them.
And maybe…
One day, years from now, we’ll both look back at this letter and laugh at how impossible it was for me to fit everything I wanted to tell you onto a few pages.
I already know this much, though.
If I had to choose my favorite thing that’s happened to me this year…
It would be meeting you.
Without hesitation.
Without revision.
Without crossing the sentence out and trying again.
Some truths arrive exactly as they’re meant to.
You are one of them.
Happy birthday, Mellie.
And…
I love you.
🤍
Wow, babe... That was beautiful. I honestly don't know what else to say. That was just beautiful
melissa lowkey like doctor frankestein because she continuously eggs shauna on and urges her to accept the dark parts of herself, but then when she gets what she wished for it’s all of a sudden “why can’t you just be a nice person?” ;(
I saw someone say that if Jackie and Shauna had a falling out in New Jersey, Shauna would be the stalker unable to move on, and now I’m wondering if you guys inversed the dynamics on purpose because stalking the other after a falling out has Jackie Taylor written all over the front and back.
If anything, after a falling out, Shauna is ditching the state and never talking to or about Jackie ever again. She would repress the entire situation and invest herself in college and work. It would take Jackie being hit by a bus and being in life threatening surgery for Shauna to come back to her.
Jackie is the one who would follow her around and stalk her and be unable to move on. I explained this in a much longer post in more detail but Jackie was clearly much more possessive of Shauna than Shauna was.
Which is what makes me feel confused when people make Shauna out to be the territorial one in the relationship. Despite the fact that Jackie was the one who felt betrayed when Shauna went to sleep with Tai.
Shauna showcases possessive and territorial behavior towards her baby and even Melissa more than she does with Jackie, I feel like you mistake jealousy for possessive behavior, because Shauna never saw Jackie as something that belonged to her and more like something that she couldn’t have.
Given the fact that Shauna allowed Natalie to take Jackie’s corpse away, unlike how she reburied her baby in a secret place only she could find, I’m pretty sure Shauna doesn’t feel ownership over Jackie the way she does over her baby
If you still aren’t convinced, look at the difference between her arguments with Jackie and with Melissa
“You tell me what to do, what to wear, I don’t even like soccer!”
“No one gave a shit about you until me!”
ShaunaHat Scene Analysis: s3ep5, part 1
(for the shaunahat scene analysis masterpost, click here)
Before going to the major shaunahat scenes in this episode, there is a brief yet important moment between Shauna and Melissa I’d also like to analyse first. It’s when the group are discussing what they will do with Coach Scott, given he was voted as guilty in the previous episode. They have to decide on his sentence. More specifically, how they will execute him.
Then Shauna proposes death by burning, given how he was accused of burning down the cabin. Mari compared this to the witches who were burned at the stake, while Nat objects to the suggestion, calling it torture due to being a very painful way to die.
But then, Melissa chimed in, quickly agreeing with Shauna as soon as she was facing pushback. She claims Shauna’s idea is fair because it’s what Ben would have wanted for them, when he allegedly burned down the cabin. I can’t tell if this is how Melissa truly feels or if she’s just willing to say and agree with anything if it means Shauna would notice her. It’s worth noting that Melissa only said that once Nat rejected Shauna’s idea, then immediately looked at Shauna afterward. So it’s fair to assume this statement was mostly done to show support to Shauna rather than how Melissa truly felt. But at the same time, it is very telling that she’s willing to condone burning a man to death simply to increase her chances of getting with her crush.
Right at the same time that Melissa is looking at Shauna, Shauna also looks at her. Melissa softly smiled at her, then looked away, maybe she got shy when she realized Shauna was looking at her, or maybe because Shauna didn’t smile back, so she got nervous. Unlike their last interaction post-trial, they aren’t in that same thrill anymore. Melissa isn’t as bold here, and Shauna is back to being distant.
Shauna’s expression isn’t super clear to me, but I don’t think she was “annoyed”, I’d say she looks more perplexed. I think Shauna might have been put off by Melissa’s enthusiasm and how easily she agrees with her. I think part of Shauna is still in disbelief that someone might actually like her. Shauna struggles with a lot of guilt and self-loathing, so the idea that someone might actually like her despite how “unlikable” she feels she has become within the group might be jarring for her. And with her growing paranoia, I can see her starting to be a bit suspicious of Melissa’s intentions, and being uncertain if she is truthful about her feelings for her or simply deceiving her.
Then, once Shauna focused her attention back on Natalie, Melissa is seen staring at her when she isn’t looking. I think Melissa is also perplexed here, because of Shauna’s apparent coldness. Shauna didn’t reciprocate the same way she did, after the trial. After they shared that handholding, Melissa probably assumed they were getting closer, only for Shauna to go back to looking indifferent to her. She was hopeful, but now she’s back to being unsure of where she stands with Shauna, which worries her. She might be thinking of what she should do next to get back in Shauna’s good graces. This is something we will see later in the same episode, which I will elaborate on in a future scene analysis.
As I said, this was a brief moment where they essentially only exchanged a glance, but it carried a lot of meaning regarding their relationship and individual characters. For Melissa, she is putting her own interest over the well-being of another person (here Ben) for the sake of furthering her relationship with Shauna. And this isn’t the first time she prioritizes her feelings for Shauna over other people. She did so when she insulted Mari behind her back, stepped on Akilah’s gift for Shauna, and pressured Gen to vote guilty. But this time, there is an escalation, where it isn’t just causing harm to someone, but going as far as condoning killing someone (by burning him alive, no less). This is a continuation of the darker turn her crush for Shauna took during the trial, and this is only the beginning. It will get even darker later.
As for Shauna, this short moment showcases that even though she has started to open up to Melissa, she still doesn't fully trust her, due to her own insecurities and self-loathing. Even after everything Melissa has done for her so far, it is still not enough for her to earn Shauna’s truth. And it’s both because of Shauna’s low self-esteem and her growing paranoid tendencies. Melissa will have to prove to her that her feelings are sincere and that she is loyal to her. Which will happen later in this episode and I’ll elaborate on that once I reach those scenes specifically.
(If you are interested in more of my commentary on this ship, feel free to check out my extensive shaunahat analysis.)
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works
Chapters: 1/1 Fandom: Yellowjackets (TV) Rating: Mature Warnings: Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings Relationships: Melissa/Shauna Shipman, Gen & Melissa (Yellowjackets), Jeff Sadecki/Shauna Shipman Characters: Melissa (Yellowjackets), Shauna Shipman, Gen (Yellowjackets) Additional Tags: Alternate Universe - Canon Divergence, Teen Timeline (Yellowjackets), Post-Rescue from Wilderness (Yellowjackets), Love Triangles, Jealousy, Unhealthy Relationships, Cheating, Period-Typical Homophobia, Homophobic Language, Drunk Sex, Dubious Consent, Vaginal Fingering, Cunnilingus, Gen lives, Angry Sex, Hate Sex Summary:
Melissa is with Gen now. Or rather, she wished to be. Turns out that Shauna doesn't take it well and decides to come back into her life, despite being with Jeff now. This gives Melissa some hope, but also makes everything so much more complicated for her.
or
Shauna/Melissa/Gen love triangle, post-rescue, in a "Gen lives" AU.
Soccer time!