This wasn't easy. Every time I listen to something it all shifts around. But this is probably as close to perfect as I'll ever get it. Both lists experience a significant drop in quality around the 2/3 mark, but everything here's at least "good".
Long
Memory Map - The Sky as Well as Space
Protomartyr - Under Color of Official Right
Weatherbox - Flies in all Directions
The Hotelier - Home, Like Noplace is There
Cymbals Eat Guitars - LOSE
Kite Party - Come on Wandering
Hard Girls - A Thousand Surfaces
Hallelujah The Hills - Have You Ever Done Something Evil?
The City on Film - La Vella
Dads - I'll Be The Tornado
Johnny Foreigner - You Can Do Better
We Were Promised Jetpacks - Unravelling
Tokyo Police Club - Forcefield
Prawn - Kingfisher (Deluxe)
Hey Rosetta! - Second Sight
Margot & the Nuclear So and So's - Slingshot to Heaven
Little Big League - Tropical Jinx
Port Manteau - To Far Away Friends
Crooks - Crooks in Paradise
Flashlights - Bummer Summer
The Menzingers - Rented World
Monument - Bros Canoeing!
Against Me! - Transgender Dysphoria Blues
The Gaslight Anthem - Get Hurt
Andrew Jackson Jihad - Christmas Island
The Library is on Fire - Halcyon and Surrounding Areas
Manchester Orchestra - Cope
The Spirit of the Beehive - The Spirit of the Beehive
Big Lonely - Close Your Eyes, Keep Talking
Three Man Cannon - Pretty Many People
Ought - More Than Any Other Day
Dreamtigers - Wishing Well
Rise Against - The Black Market
Roll The Tanks - Broke Til Midnight
Young Statues - The Flatlands are Your Friend
Conor Oberst - Upside Down Mountain
The Rural Alberta Advantage - Mended With Gold
Modern Baseball - You're Gonna Miss it All
The Xcerts - There is Only You
Deleted Scenes - Lithium Burn
Passenger Peru - Passenger Peru
The Pains of Being Pure at Heart - Days of Abandon
Chuck Ragan - Till Midnight
Spoon - They Want My Soul
Morgan Herrell - Open the Door
Kind Of Like Spitting - Professional Results
Stepfriends - All We've Got
You Blew It! - Keep Doing What You're Doing
Cloud Nothings - Here and Nowhere Else
Have Mercy - A Place of our Own
Weezer - Everything Will be Alright in the End
Late Bloomer - Things Change
Pianos Become the Teeth - Keep You
Radiator Hospital - Torch Song
Elder Brother - Heavy Head
Sorority Noise - Forgettable
Circa Survive - Descensus
Hostage Calm - Die on Stage
Taking Back Sunday - Happiness Is
Trophy Scars - Holy Vacants
Liam Betson - The Cover of Hunter
The Twilight Sad - Nobody Wants to be Here and Nobody Wants to Leave
Stephen Malkmus and the Jicks - Wig Out at Jagbags
The Lawrence Arms - Metropole
Brightside - Now and Loud
Joyce Manor - Never Hungover Again
It Looks Sad. - It Looks Sad.
Caddywhompus - Feathering a Nest
Tiny Empires - Weird Headspace
Men Working in Trees - Progress
Nana Grizol - NIGHTLIGHTS I-III + TACOMA CENTER 1600
Antarctigo Vespucci - Soulmate Stuff + I'm So Tethered
Lifted Bells - Lights Out
Prawn - Split with Joie de Vivre + 4-Way Split
Donovan Wolfington - Scary Stories You Tell in the Dark
Nai Harvest - Hold Open My Head + Split with Playlounge
Good Thoughts - Here You Are Now
The Burlies - The Burlies
Special Explosion - The Art of Mothering
Idiot Kid - Stick Your Head in the Water
Krill - Steve Hears Pile in Malden and Bursts into Tears
The World Is - Between Bodies + The Distance
Little Big League/Ovlov - Split
Pile - Special Snowflakes/Mama's Lipstick
Great Apes - Playland At The Beach
Runaway Brother - Summer/Autumn
Sunny Day Real Estate/Circa Survive - Split
Dogs on Acid - Dogs on Acid
RVIVR - Bicker and Breathe
Brave Bird - T-Minus Grand Gesture
Annabel - Split With Dowsing
The Weaks - The World Is A Terrible Place & I Hate Myself And Want To Die
Radiator Hospital - Total Request
Foreign Tongues - Sweet Empathy Leaving Me