How am i going to organize my Miraculous' remakes: Part 2/2 - Reworking on the Miraculouses' powers
When I was looking for reworks of Miraculous powers for inspiration, I stumbled upon this post. Literally spent the whole night processing the amount of information the text contained
So when I finally understood everything and organized my thoughts, I started writing, taking all the references in the post into account, but adapting everything to my personal tastes and current powers after all of them were finally revealed (OP's post is from 2019) since I don't want to leave a drastic change, because analyzing well, the canon powers match perfectly with each holder.
According to OP, following the Yin Yang, Wu Xing and Sheng Xiao symbolisms more accurately, the division of powers should look like this:
Ladybug and Cat Miraculouses - Five powers
Fox, Bee, Turtle, Peacock and Butterfly Miraculouses - Two powers
Mouse, Ox, Tiger, Rabbit, Dragon, Snake, Horse, Goat, Monkey, Rooster, Dog and Pig Miraculouses - Only one power
"Why?" You may ask. And here is the answer. The Ladybug and Cat Miraculouses are the most powerful Miraculouses of the most powerful Miracle Box; They represent the Yin and Yang, concepts of Taoism that expose the duality of everything that exists in the universe and describe the two opposing and complementary fundamental forces. It really made sense to me that they should've had more than one power.
Thing is, they already have. Ladybug explicitly has 2 powers (3 if you consider capturing akumas and amoks as a particular power) which are Lucky Charm and the Miraculous Ladybug's cure. The issue with Chat Noir and Cataclysm is something I will address further down.
Back to the explanation, now I need to talk about the Wu Xing so that things make sense later.
The 5 phases theory, which is a more correct translation, states that wood (木), fire (火), earth (土), metal (金) and water (水) are the basic elements that form the material world.
There would be an interaction and reciprocal control between them that would determine their state of constant movement and change. They also represent the passage of time, seasons, cardinal directions, organs of the human body, cosmic periods and are even linked with properties of medicine.
There are four cycles: the generating one, the weakening, insulting and controlling. This concept would be something cool to play with, with all the possibilities of combinations, but I admit that it would be something more complex than it already is.
Apparently, Thomas took inspiration not from the colors of each element, but from what they represent. Still following OP's logic, each power and animal chosen would be derived from what the element affects and express. Therefore, the pattern would be:
Wood -> Mind -> Fox (Illusion)
Fire -> Energy -> Bee (Subjection)
Earth -> Body -> Turtle (Protection)
Metal -> Soul -> Peacock (Emotion)
Water -> Heart -> Butterfly (Transmission)
And each element would have its Yin and Yang ability, as it encompasses the Wu Xing. Every Yin ability would be more defensive/supportive/passive/collective, while every Yang ability would be more offensive/agressive/active/individual, so i came to this conclusion:
• Wood/Mind (Yin): Defense - Mirage
• Wood/Mind (Yang): Offense - ?
• Fire/Energy (Yin): Defense - ?
• Fire/Energy (Yang): Offense - Venom
• Earth/Body (Yin): Defense - Shell-ter
• Earth/Body (Yang): Offense - ?
• Metal/Soul (Yin): Defense - Amokization
• Metal/Soul (Yang): Offense - ?
• Water/Heart (Yin): Defense - Akumatization
• Water/Heart (Yang): Offense - ?
Now that I've determined the mind, energy, body, mind and heart thing, we can go back to the Ladybug and Cat Miraculouses.
As I said, the Yin Yang encompasses the Wu Xing, so Ladybug and Chat Noir's powers most likely would work that way:
• Positive Mind: Inspiration - ?
• Positive Energy: Creation - Lucky Charm
• Positive Body: Strength - ?
• Positive Soul: Life - ?
• Positive Heart: Healing - Miraculous Ladybug cure
• Negative Mind: Insanity/Madness - ?
• Negative Energy: Destruction - Cataclysm
• Negative Body: Weakness - ?
• Negative Soul: Death - ?
• Negative Heart: Toxicity - ?
But do you guys remember the thing I said about Chat Noir and his only power being Cataclysm in canon, unlike Ladybug? So, reading some Thomas Astruc's replies on Twitter, I discovered something quite interesting.
He confirmed that the Cat Miraculous' power is not to destroy anything per say. It's actually making something bad, in general, happen to what he touches; this is why Sentimonsters totally lose control and go berserk when hit by a Cataclysm. "The bad thing" that happens is the connection between them and their owners being interrupted.
To make something disappear from existence is annihilation, which is different from destruction, the official Cat Miraculous concept. The very name "Cataclysm" means disaster or catastrophe, which is why there is an association with bad luck or jinx. So basically I'll just be putting each possible effect under 5 distinct names according to the related element. Easy.
Finally, moving on to the Sheng Xiao, the Chinese Zodiac. There are 12 animals in total, which I already mentioned above. Getting to this point, I would also like to mention that I even researched what animals represent the Yin Yang and Wu Xing, just to check the consistency of Thomas. At the end, I wanted to say that I totally understand why he put the animals we currently have in the box.
The animals that represent the Yin and Yang are, respectively, Tiger and Dragon. Two animals that we already got in the zodiac. Gets worse with Wu Xing: Wood and Earth are represented by two more dragons, a Azure one (Qing Long) and a Golden one (Huang Long), while Fire, Metal and Water are the Vermilion Bird (Zhu Que), White Tiger (Bai Hu) and Black Tortoise (Xuan Wu), the last two being just varieties of animals that we already got in the box.
Back to the original matter again, shall we? All the signs within the zodiac are only equivalent and defined by a single element out of all the five and just one side of the Yin Yang, and that's what I'm going to use as a base to change the powers or just improve them. The list goes:
• Water/Heart (Yang): Multitude
• Earth/Body (Yin): Resistance
• Wood/Mind (Yang): Clout
• Wood/Mind (Yin): Burrow
• Earth/Body (Yang): Elemental Storm Dragons or Wind, Lightning and Water Dragon
• Fire/Energy (Yin): Second Chance, honestly this is one that I might even have to change the name, maybe to something like Hypnosis – quite cliché I know
• Fire/Energy (Yang): Voyage
• Earth/Body (Yin): Genesis
• Metal/Soul (Yang): Uproar
• Metal/Soul (Yin): Sublimation
• Earth/Body (Yang): Fetch
• Water/Heart (Yin): Gift
I must say that I honestly don't intend to completely adapt, specifically the Sheng Xiao's animals powers, to the Yin Yang and Wu Xing molds, as it would completely change the powers, their symbolism, and their matchings with each canon holder, something I don't want because it would cause a mess in my head and I particularly appreciate the original content and stuff on the show. But I promise that I'll try my hardest to make at least some of them still contain precision.
Just like the other part of the posts about the remakes (the one that talks about how I am going to redesign the heroes' outfits), that end up in this one, I'll leave it to reveal the Miraculouses powers' changes in each individual post that addresses a particular hero.
Since this was a loooong text, I hope you enjoyed reading this far. Thanks for the attention!!!
And once again, credits to @loosescrewslefty