An Archive of Our Own, a project of the
Organization for Transformative Works
I can’t even tell you how much I love this. Edmund Pevensie and his redemption story has always been important to me, just like Sam Winchester. I just...I can’t even describe the love I have for this.
Also on AO3
Rated: General Audiences
Fandom: Narnia
Susan was the smart one, the sensible one, the rational one. So how could she forget?
As a child, Susan remembered. It was one of her talents, the one she was most proud of. All her tests were returned to her with perfect marks and kind comments, her mother could always count on her to remember which groceries they had to buy and her father was always grateful when Susan found the item he had lost, for she always remembered where he put it. As a Queen, Susan also remembered. She remembered the faces of her subjects, the reasons they had come before her, the solutions she had given them. When she met them years later, she would enquire if the problem had indeed been permanently fixed, and they would praise and love her for remembering them. Peter always wondered how she did that, how she managed to figure out who this specific bunny was, as they all looked alike. Susan would sigh and point out the little spot of white on the left ear, or the spot on the nose, or the way the eyes looked. Peter then proclaimed that he could never remember small details such as that, and Susan just smiled. She could remember, that was her talent.
Susan’s memory was not limited to schoolwork, or grocery lists, or locations of things, or faces and problems. Susan remembered everything. The things around her always left a permanent imprint on her brain, and sometimes, sometimes it was too much. The bright colours and busy activity in Narnia overwhelmed her, the many new people and animals she saw daily tired her, and she was plagued by memories of the many battles she had fought. On those days, she wished she was back home, in England. For Susan, even if her siblings didn’t, remembered the land she came from. She remembered the quiet neighbourhood where nothing ever changed, she remembered school where her classroom was always the same, she remembered her house, her garden, her parents. The endless unchanging routine without political debates, grand festivities, council meetings and partitioning strangers. And Susan missed it.
At first, the missing was small. It only popped up after a particularly busy day, when her brain felt overwhelmed with all the sights, sounds, smells and tastes. But as Queen Susan of the Radiant Southern Sun grew up, the missing grew too. Now, she didn’t just miss the routine, the safe and the known – for her queenly duties had become a new routine of its own – but she missed the praise. Sure, she was praised in Narnia, but not for her remembering anymore. She was praised for her beauty, her grace, her long hair, kind eyes, her dancing and her smile. But not for her memory. Nobody was surprised when she remembered them after many years, for they were too enamoured with the Queen’s beautiful dress. Nobody praised her when she recalled the exact details of a peace treaty signed many winters ago, for they were looking at her figure. But Queen Susan did not care for long hair, for red lips, for fair skin and big eyes. To her, they were worthless. How far could one go with beauty, if one did not have the brains to back them up? But it seemed like the more she grew, the prettier she became. And the prettier she became, the littler they cared about her opinions, her ideas, her wisdom. She looked with envy at Lucy, who had also grown into a beautiful young woman, but who, permanently stuck in the ‘youngest sibling’-position, was not seen by anyone as just a pretty face. They loved her for her kindness, not for her hair shone in the sun. They adored her for her fierceness, not the way her dressed hugged her hips in just the right way. They listened to her war strategies, without complimenting her delicate wrists and long fingers. So, Susan closed her eyes and remembered. Remembered how it used to be.
She had had a particularly busy week when the White Stag was spotted. When Edmund came, barging into her room early in the morning, Susan was staring out her window, not seeing anything. She was remembering her parents, her life in England, where the colours were dull and the people unchanging. She had not slept all night, flashes of memories of the celebrations that had been keeping her up. She tried to sort them, face by face and event by event, but it was too busy in her mind. There were too many faces stored, too many events bouncing around, too many colours confusing her. And, for the first time in her life, Susan wished she did not remember. This thought had come a little after midnight, and it had shocked her so that she had not been able to fall asleep even if the memories did calm down. So, she hid in the calmest memory she had: walking through the rain to the grocer on the corner to buy two eggs for her mother, so she could make Lucy’s birthday cake. It had been completely quiet on the streets, and she was the only one in the store. Everything was dull and grey and so beautifully calm. Until Edmund’s wild story of the spotted stag dragged her from her mental walk through the neighbourhood back to her royal chambers in Narnia.
They all went hunting for it, of course. Edmund and Peter had insisted they wanted to try to catch the creature, and Lucy and Susan would not be outdone. The horses were saddled in no-time, and before the Beavers with their long list of planned events for today could protest, the siblings were out, riding into the meadows, across the stream, towards the forest. And for a little while, Susan was able to hide her worries away. Only for a little while, though. They found the stag and chased it through the forest until they had cornered him near a river. The animal was about to cross into the streaming water when it froze. Susan’s horse had stepped into a beam of sunlight shining through the trees, lighting up the Queen’s hair and turning it a gorgeous blonde. Lucy had whispered to the rest that the white stag must be enamoured with Susan’s hair, and with those words her worries came back, all at once piling on top of each other. And Susan wished, hoped, dreamed, yearned that she could go home, that she could forget this all happened, and just live her life like any other girl her age – she was not even sure which age, she was twelve when she left England but now she was twenty-eight – would. The stag blinked, jumped into the river and was gone. Edmund complained that they hadn’t made a wish, and thus the hunt continued. But Susan remembered she had made a wish, and she hoped desperately that it didn’t count, that it didn’t come true, that them cornering the animal hadn’t counted as them catching it. But of course, it did.
The Pevensie siblings arrived home. They stumbled out of the wardrobe in bodies too small for their minds and a time too close to the one they left. The following days, Susan saw the memories of her brothers and sister slowly return. Where she immediately picked up a new routine, they had to relearn how to turn on the radio, how to spend their free time, how to navigate in the bodies they had outgrown. Susan remembered how happy they used to be, but their smiles were gone now. She did not exactly remember why her siblings were so happy. They had had a lovely childhood, but her vague memories seemed to show a happiness bigger, brighter, more extensive than that. Oh well, it was probably their worries about the war, about their father fighting it, about being away from home that painted everything in a different light. Their talk of their fantasyland named Narnia where everything is good and beautiful was probably a psychological coping mechanism, Susan concluded. There was, after all, no way a land could be hidden in a wardrobe, or beavers could talk, or lions could rise from the dead. And if there was, Susan would have remembered it. After all, remembering things was one of her talents, the one she was most proud of.
You tell me I am Lucy -
I take you through the Wardrobe to a land far from your own
filled with wonders and possibilities - but all I hear
is that you are Susan
so much prettier
kinder
more beloved than I
You tell me I am Valliant -
I inspire you to do great things, to make friends
and hold on (hold on for dear life) when things go wrong - but all I hear
is that you are Gentle
surrounded by people that love and adore
and feel safe with you whilst I?
I wield my dagger, stab, and run
You tell me I am the Glistening Eastern Sea -
warm waters, the door to adventure
and new (endlessly new) worlds - but all I hear
is that you are the Radiant Southern Sun,
giver of beautiful days and light and life that I
(throwing my angry waves over the edge of the world)
take with me to the darkened depths
You are beauty incarnate, kindness itself, ruler of the heavens and I -
I am plain and small, a hunter ready for the kill
and I, oh, I just wish
(oh, how I wish)
that I - if only for a single afternoon - could be you
Also on AO3
Rated: General Audiences
Fandom: Narnia
Summary: Philip was a loyal horse, and King Edmund had told him to wait. So, when the four royal siblings disappeared in the woods behind the strange tree that lit the forest around him, that was exactly what he did.
He was waiting. He was old, and his legs hurt, and it was getting dark, but he kept waiting. And waiting. And waiting. For he knew for sure, for sure, that his King would return.
They had gone out for a hunt, to find the White Stag, the one rumoured to grant wishes when one caught it. Edmund had cancelled his meetings, he had told him, to ride out with his siblings. And, as ever, he had chosen him, chosen Philip to carry him into the unknown. It was an honour he thanked Aslan for every day of his life, to serve one of the True Kings of Narnia, and to call him his friend. So, Philip waited. And waited. And waited.
They had gone into the forest none of them knew. Not that they worried, for the nymphs in the trees would be able to lead their way back if they ever got lost. They feared no danger, all threats were eliminated from the great kingdom a long time ago, when his Kings and Queens were still young, when he was much more agile. And indeed, they had gotten lost, the White Stag had disappeared somewhere between the green, lush trees. That is when his fellow riders had spotted the weird tree, the one on fire. The one illuminating the now rapidly approaching dark, dark night whilst Philip waited. His Kings and Queens had looked in awe at the wonder of nature, the strange, overgrown thing the youngest Queen, after some consideration, had quietly called a ‘lamp post’. Edmund had told him to rest, promised that he would return. So Philip waited. And waited. And waited. Darkness came and went, but his King had not returned.
He had found a small stream of water he and his fellow horses – Non-speaking ones, but all good steeds – could drink from. He had used it to clean his hooves from the mud, to cool his ankles after the warm summer night. They had found some leaves to eat, some grass to graze, some sweet berries they carefully picked from the thorny bush with their lips. It was truly a delicious treat, but he had not enjoyed it as much as the others, carefree and without worries. He wondered where King Edmund had gone, why he hadn’t returned, where the other King and Queens went. If they were in danger. He shook his head, banishing that thought from his head. There was no danger in Narnia anymore. The witch had been defeated, the giants were on the other side of Narnia, and the peace treaty between them and the Calormen had been upheld so far. There was no danger in Narnia, and his Kings and Queens would return. Darkness came and went, and Philip still waited.
He could not sleep that night, and instead watched the stars. The little twinkles of light that usually seemed so bright when they were camping in the woods now only looked like faded dots compared to the light coming from the strange tree. That, combined with the bright full moon had almost made it seem like it was day rather than night. If he looked very carefully he could find the constellations that had always pointed Edmund’s way during their adventures, made sure they could always find their way back to the warm stables in Cair Paravel. The sunrise that morning coloured the entire forest in a soft golden hue, a gorgeous sight promising a deliciously warm day. The bright light slowly rose, marking the passing of time, but King Edmund, or any of his siblings, did not return that day. Darkness came and went, and Philip still waited.
That morning a robin landed on the lamp post, slightly out of breath. ‘Good morning, Robert.’ Philip greeted. ‘Good morning!’ the creature, who lived in the stables’ rafters, replied. ‘I have been looking all over for you. Where are our Kings and Queens? The dwarves are getting quite upset that their meeting with King Peter keeps being delayed, and I fear the fauns were very disappointed that Queen Lucy did not show up for their play. The children worked so hard on it!’ Philip sighed and told the red-breasted bird an abbreviated version of his travels so far. Everything had gone great from the beginning. Queen Susan had heard that the White Stag was spotted, and once she had told her siblings they had wasted no time riding out in search of the mythical creature. It had been a long time since they had gone on an adventure, just the four of them, and they had laughed and reminisced and told stories of the trouble they had gotten into during trips one or more of the others had not been on. They had followed the rumours to the Lantern Wastes, and there… Oh, there it had all gone wrong. Philip had gotten tired and fallen behind, Queen Lucy had found the strange tree and then all four of them had gone through the pinewood and were yet to return. ‘So the Kings and Queens have been gone for four days now?’ the bird asked, astonished. Philip simply nodded. ‘I will go get help,’ Robert replied. ‘Wait here.’ So Philip waited. Darkness came and went, and still no crown to be seen.
He startled awake by the rough voice of a fox, demanding answers to his questions. Once he had opened his eyes he saw that there was not only a fox, but also a stag – not a White one – a couple of rabbits, some squirrels and even two centaurs had gathered around him and the three other horses. He must have been well and truly tired to sleep through all that. ‘Shut it, Rupert,’ one of the centaurs chastised the energetic brown creature that had so rudely awoken Philip. ‘We are all concerned about the whereabouts of our royalty, no need to be rude about it.’ The fox calmed down, and after some further reprimanding and organising the entire crew of creatures was silent long enough to hear Philip’s story again. It had been five days now, and although the siblings had often gone out on unannounced adventures it was never that they disappeared for this long without notice. And especially not on foot and without any supplies, for those still weighed heavily on the four horses’ shoulders. Before long, however, the two centaurs helped him remove the heavy saddle and the gathered creatures had spread out through the forest, running, jumping, flying, crawling over trees to find their lost Royal family. And so, Philip found himself alone again. But this time he could not wait, not anymore. With careful steps, he walked towards the trees he had seen his King disappear in and wrestled himself through the needles.
He had not walked very far, although he had been struggling through the thick trees and long branches for a long time, when he came upon a clearing. A flash of light shone into his eyes, and when he tried to step forward he felt something under his hoof. A sword. Not just any sword, but Rhindon, the sword of High King Peter himself. Philip felt his heart skip a beat, for he knew the King would never leave this treasure behind. ‘He is not here.’ A soft voice spoke, startling the old horse. He looked up, right into the eyes of a Lion. Not a lion, but The Lion. ‘Aslan-’ he whispered, and, slowly, he kneeled on the grass before the King of Beasts. The Lion smiled and shook his head. ‘There is no need for that, Philip.’ ‘You – You remember me?’ Philip had once met Him, once fought beside Him when the nasty witch still ruled the land-that-wasn’t-hers. ‘I know all the creatures in Narnia,’ replied the Lion, ‘and I know that you have been very loyal indeed.’ ‘Do you know where King Edmund is? And High King Peter, and the Queens Susan and Lucy?’ As he looked around he saw the shields, the bow and arrow, the dagger and the cordial the Royal Siblings always carried with them. ‘Do not be alarmed, you are looking for your Kings and Queens, who ruled Narnia. But they are not here. Go tell the other creatures of Narnia that My Children have returned to their own world. They are needed there.’ ‘Their – their own world?’ Philip repeated. ‘The world I have called them from when Narnia needed them. But now that the witch has been defeated and order restored their own world needs them again. Do not worry, one day, when Narnia needs them again, they will return to Cair Paravel.’ Before the horse could say another word, the Big Lion was gone and Philip was alone. Well and truly alone.
The trip back to the castle was a silent and sober one. The empty saddle on his back felt heavier than it had when it still carried a rider, and where the way there had been filled with laughter and chatter Philip spent the road back quietly crying. He was not the only one mourning, as the news of the disappearance of the Sons of Adam and Daughters of Eve spread. Corin, the rash boxing prince of Archenland and a close friend of those that were once seated on the now-empty thrones in Paravel took over as King, advised by Mr Tumnus, Mr and Mrs Beaver and all the other creatures that had helped the previous royals rule Narnia. But Philip was not there to see it. Once the new King was crowned he had left the peninsula and travelled westward towards the Lantern Waste to rest and wait. Wait for King Edmund to return, just like he promised.
Also on AO3
Rated: General Audiences
Fandom: Narnia
Summary: It was not just their time in Narnia that changed the Pevensie siblings. It was life without Narnia that changed them too.
Lucy avoided mirrors after she had come back from her last trip to Narnia. She avoided Susan too, although she hated herself for it. Susan had come home from America with stories of skyscrapers, bars and dates with pretty boys, but when she asked Edmund and Lucy how their time in the Scrubb household was, she did not believe them. She didn’t remember Aslan, or Reepicheep, or Caspian. She didn’t remember Narnia at all. She had only laughed and said it was very nice of them to include Eustace in their play, before regaling another colourful account of a date gone wrong. It was, however, not just Susan’s contempt for Narnia and their adventures there that caused Lucy to avoid her older sister. The true reason was that every time Lucy looked at her sister's brown, curling hair and gorgeous tanned face she was reminded of the Gentle and desired Queen she once knew. And every time she saw Edmund and Peter laugh at another one of Susan's escapades, she was reminded of that horrid, horrid spell she had cast, of that awful visit to that awful world where she, Lucy Pevensie, did not exist.
One day, during the wedding of one of her mother's younger friends, a photographer took a picture of the three oldest siblings whilst Lucy was congratulating the bride. When she turned around to join her siblings again, Lucy saw the flash of the camera and almost burst into tears. She managed to contain herself, but once they got home she claimed the picture, joking how it was her right to own a picture of the siblings she was not on. But now, sitting alone in Primrose Park, one of her favourite places in London, Lucy let her tears flow freely. The picture in her hands showed three happy adolescents, free of worries and care. Susan, with her clear skin and stunning smile, Peter, with his golden hair and cheerful laugh and Edmund, who had jumped in at the last second, with a jawline that could cut through rock, slightly squinting in the sunlight. The perfect Royal trio, and any stranger that would look at the picture had no reason to suspect there to be a fourth sibling. And why would they?
Lucy Pevensie had become Queen at age eight. Her royal duties didn't pertain much, just the occasional ‘smile and wave’, so she spent most of her time outside. Talking to Mr Tumnus, or drinking tea with Mr and Mrs Beaver, or playing with the nymphs or swimming with the merpeople. She had grown up carefree, and she left the serious business to her brothers and sister. Peter had a knack for law, and Susan was ever the great diplomat. Edmund had proven himself to be quite the man for maths and economy, taking over the responsibility of the Royal treasury. So when Lucy grew up for the first time, and came of an age that she desired more responsibility, there were no tasks for her left. The three oldest monarchs of Narnia had managed wonderfully without her for the first few years, so why would they have any need her now? Thus, Queen Lucy the Valiant continued to spend her time with her subjects, playing, talking, gardening and celebrating. She helped where she could, but if there was ever an issue of even marginal importance, even her closest friends would rather confide in the older Kings and Queen than in her.
When they all grew up, it was Susan that was approached by suitors from abroad. At first, Lucy hadn't minded. She was too young, too free, too busy with the Narnians to look at other human men, and the ridiculous attempts at wooing the oldest sister had entertained all four siblings. But time passed, and Lucy, too, grew up. Yet still, no suitor came for her hand. Of course, she had some that had approached her, but all had tried and failed to court her older sister first. No one had ever come for her, just her, for it was only about the beauty of Queen Susan that tales were spread. Lucy was only an afterthought, a post scriptum, an ‘oh, the beautiful Queen Susan the Gentle of Narnia, she has a younger sister too’. Lucy didn't blame her sister for her beauty, nor did she fault her for revelling in the attention that it brought her. But more often than not, Lucy would leave the parties and big celebrations early in order to walk through the woods, or along the coast, and, she soon discovered, no one noticed her absence.
This, by now, was something she had gotten used to. Sitting on Primrose Hill with London spread out in front of her, she doubted anyone would miss her too. Her mother and Susan were out shopping for a new dress for Easter Sunday, Peter was studying and Edmund and Eustace were catching up after a long semester spent at separate schools. Her father, as always, was working, so Lucy was alone. And this time, she had no beavers, no fauns, no trees or merpeople or talking mice to keep her company. It was just her, a picture of her older siblings and a view of the grey and dirty city of London. With her thumb, Lucy traced the outline of her older sister's face. It truly was flawless, and shaping just like it had before, the first time they grew up. Lucy found it such a shame her sister kept her hair shorter, and she missed the moments she had spent braiding the Queen’s endlessly long hair, decorating it with flowers or shells or leaves. Now, Susan kept it either loose around her face, or occasionally up with a simple bow. Lucy used to braid it for her, here, in London, but every time Susan thought Lucy didn’t see, she untied her hair. It wasn’t ‘in’ to have your hair braided, so soon Lucy stopped offering. The eyes of her older brother looked bright into the camera, the deep wisdom glowing from it hinting that he had lived longer than the photographer could ever suspect. Edmund’s curly hair was immortalised in a blurry smudge as the camera had caught it in movement. His smile was bright, for winter was over and spring had begun, and all was good again.
None of the siblings noticed Lucy’s quiet demeanour. Why would they? Their busy lives left little time to speak with each other extensively. Helen Pevensie had noticed, but she noticed that all of her children had changed after the war. She talked about it with her husband, and he had blamed the War. The War had changed everyone, not just the soldiers fighting in it. Helen had nodded, and gone back to sleep. Her children were growing up, after all, so it made sense that their characters changed. She didn’t notice the sadness in her youngest daughter’s eyes, the longing for a world far from here, the unexplained absences or the longing looks to the trees she passed. How could she? She did not know of Narnia, of her children’s rule, or of the people in the trees. She did know Aslan, as did her husband, but they did not know Him by the same name their children did. She knew him as God, as the Almighty Father, as the Saviour of all people, as the One, she believed more rightly than she could ever guess, that had kept her family safe when the war devastated the rest of the world.
So, Lucy sat on top of Primrose Hill, looking down at a sight so far removed from Narnia that her adventures almost felt like a fever dream. Almost. But there was no way Lucy would, could ever forget the friends she made or the places she had seen or the things she had experienced. And as she looked down upon the picture, the picture of three royal siblings laughing and celebrating Lucy felt just as terrible as she had when she was Susan, as when she had seen the Pevensie’s life without Narnia. And right before her eyes, the picture seemed to change. Instead of an awful reminder of her insecurities, of her shortcomings, of her sister’s superior beauty and her brothers’ wisdom she saw something else. She saw three children, playing in the snow, ignorant of what would happen. She saw three children, fleeing from an evil which. She saw three warriors, she saw three rulers. And she saw what Narnia had brought to each of them: courage, patience, kindness, hope. And suddenly, in the background, Lucy noticed something else. A seagull, flying in the distance. At that moment, Lucy could have sworn she heard the silent whisper of Aslan, speaking the words He had spoken to her before: Courage, dear heart.
Lucy did not avoid mirrors anymore after she came back from Primrose Hill. She didn’t avoid Susan, either. She laughed at her sister’s stories about the ridiculous behaviour of American boys, marvelled at the pictures of the skyscrapers and even went out clubbing with her sister once. Instead of hiding the picture out of sight, she put it up above her desk, and instead of tearing up, a smile crossed her face each time her eyes fell on her siblings' happy faces. It was not just life in Narnia that had changed them all, it was living without Narnia that had changed them more. And although Susan turned her back on Narnia, Lucy knew that Narnia had not turned its back on the Gentle Queen. After the train crashed, after they had arrived in New Narnia, Queen Lucy the Valiant treasured this knowledge, for she knew that one day, Queen Susan the Gentle would return to Cair Paravel once again.
Summary
“I am [in your world].’ said Aslan. ‘But there I have another name. You must learn to know me by that name. This was the very reason why you were brought to Narnia, that by knowing me here for a little, you may know me better there.”
Lucy was the first to discover. Of course she was, she had always been the first. The first to discover Narnia, the first to discover Aslan, the first to keep faith, constantly and steadfast. She found His name when she attended a church service. She was still mourning the loss of Narnia, mourning the knowledge that she would not return when she heard the pastor speak of sacrifice, of love, of Jesus' death and resurrection. She heard him read about the darkness that fell over Isreal when Jesus was hanging on the cross and she remembered her adventures in Narnia. She remembered the sadness, the intense and overwhelming pain when she had seen Aslan, his mane cut and his body lifeless on the stone table. But she also remembered the light and the joy when He returned, and she remembered His soft voice, the words He had spoken before she left Narnia for good: “I have another name. You must learn to know me by that name.” Lucy had discovered that name, and she treasured it inside her heart.
Edmund had been second. He had never truly felt at home in his world, missing Narnia each day. He dreamt about the gardens of Cair Paravel, banks of the Great River, the Mountains of the North and all the creatures living in the Great Western Woods. And occasionally, he dreamt about the White Witch. Those days, he rose early and could be found wandering around in the forest surrounding his school, looking for life that wasn't there. One morning, after a particularly realistic nightmare in which the White Witch rose again, with him by her side, he woke up to find his dormmate up as well, reading a heavy book. They talked, and Edmund heard the story of forgiveness. He felt a warm glow in his heart, but he did not fully understand why until later, when he picked up the old Bible his father had given him. The glow in his heart had been the feeling of home.
Peter discovered last. His calm mind and sturdy heart had not forgotten Narnia, he never could, but life forced the memories in the back of his mind. It was during the wedding of one of his closest friends when he discovered Aslan's name. His youngest siblings had told him of their adventures with Caspian, and Lucy had told him of Aslan's last words to her. When the officiator spoke of loyalty and bravery, of God's everlasting love, Peter realised who Aslan was. It was only weeks before the ghost of a dethroned King appeared in the living room, and only weeks before the train crashed and he saw Aslan again.
Susan did not discover it at all. She grieved for her siblings, locked herself up from the world until she met her consolation in the form of a lovely young and caring man. Susan grew up, again, but she did not remember the first time she did. She got married and raised her children. She went to church each Sunday but she never linked the words she heard there to the Lion the once knew, but had forgotten. Narnia had lost a friend, and one throne in Cair Paravel stayed empty. Aslan and the Kings and Queens of Narnia waited, patiently. Even though she might have forgotten Narnia, and even though she guarded her heart, she was after all Queen Susan the Gentle of the radiant Southern Sun. And once a King or Queen of Narnia, always a King or Queen of Narnia. One day, the lost Pevensie sister would return home, where she belonged.
Summary
“I am [in your world].’ said Aslan. ‘But there I have another name. You must learn to know me by that name. This was the very reason why you were brought to Narnia, that by knowing me here for a little, you may know me better there.”
Lucy was the first to discover. Of course, she had always been the first. The first to discover Narnia, the first to see Aslan. She discovered it when she wandered inside a church during a service. It had spoken of sacrifice and love and Lucy had remembered the words Aslan had said: “I have another name. You must learn to know me by that name.”
Lucy had discovered that name, and she treasured it inside her heart.
Edmund had been second. He had never truly felt at home in his world, missing Narnia each day. But one day, during a conversation with his Christian friend,he felt his heart glow. He did not fully understand why until later, at home, when he finally picked up the old bible his father had given him.
The glow in his heart had been the feeling of home.
Peter discovered last. His calm mind and sturdy heart had not forgotten Narnia, he never could, but life forced the memories in the back of his mind. It was during the wedding of one of is closest friends he realised. It was but weeks before the ghost of a dethroned king appeared in the living room, but weeks before the train crashed.
Susan did not discover it at all. She grieved for her siblings, locked herself up from the world until she met her consolation in the form of a lovely young man. Susan grew up, again, but she did not remember the first time she did. She got married and raised her children. She went to church each Sunday, but she never linked the words she heard there to the Lion the once knew but had forgotten.
Narnia lost a friend, one chair in Paravel stayed empty. Aslan and the Kings and Queens of Narnia waited, patiently, for the arrival of Queen Susan the Gentle. But once a king or queen of Narnia, always a king or queen of Narnia. One day, their lost sister would return home.
in which susan pevensie is happy with her life and spends her days gardening and traveling the world, and her nights dancing and eating good food, and eventually dies with lots of friends around her who see her as the wonderful woman that she is (so, just a little blurb I came up with)
Everyone always assumed Susan was proper, delicate, elegant: the epitome of the perfect woman. They saw how she floated on the ground, her skirts swishing around her ankles in circles and her laugh dissipating into the crowd. When she smiled, her pale skin would turn rosy pink and she would bite her lip out of habit and bring attention to her red lipstick. Other women (in Narnia and England) envied and loved her, wanting to be her and kill her.
The reality was somewhat different. In the mornings, the young queen would descend to the gardens. She would take out a watering can, a shovel, a rake. Her fingers deep into the earth, dirt would cake under her fingernails and the crevices in her hands. Pieces of hair would come out of her braid, and as the sun rose higher in the sky, the tendrils would frizz up and stick to the back of her neck with sweat. When she knelt, brown stains were left behind on her skirt, and the hem of her dress would be damp with dew. While her sister knew how to heal soldiers, stitch up wounds and make tourniquets, Susan knew how to heal the regular people. She tended to the daisies when they grew up amongst the other weeds, then cut up the flowers to make hot herbal tea when her brothers would get sick with a cold. Her aloe vera plants were often used to treat basic burns, while her sister would take a tonic of lavender when she couldn’t sleep after a long day of meetings. When dignitaries would come to visit, they would marvel at the beauty of the rose bushes or the cherry blossoms in spring, but few noticed the carefully laid plots of land that held blooming onions, carrots, and dill.
In England, although she didn’t have the space or the resources to have the same garden she did before, she still grew basic herbs and flowers in the backyard, spending hours under the sun. Although she didn’t excel at school like her siblings, she found her intelligence among the plants, where she could differentiate between the different grasses and stalks and pinpoint their uses. Certainly, Susan was praised for her beauty, but that was not her defining virtue: it was her patience to wait for results. If anything, she was more misunderstood than her brothers and sister, who shone under the gaze of professors, classmates, and parents. Peter had his leadership, while Edmund had his intelligence and Lucy her passion. But Susan? She was more than beautiful; she was radiant inside and out.
When she became alone, Susan sold her family’s belongings and took up traveling. She recalled her trip to America, long long ago, and knew that England was not the place for her and never would be. She sat in the red leather seats on the train to mainland Europe and watched the passing landscape: green hills with cows grazing turned to the churning navy waters of the channel to the sandy beaches of France. From there, she grabbed her few belongings and took up shop in a small village, where only the baker knew English. She got a job as assistant, and she spent half her days her hands coated in white flour and the other half her hands wet and blistered from spending hours holding the small shovel. In the mornings, she would read the paper despite it being in French and chew on bread and butter, before she headed out for the day working on Main Street. Locals would come in, asking for scones and ointments in the same breath, before waving goodbye. Here, she no longer wore her red lipstick, and she was called lovely not beautiful by the older women that would drink coffee in the seats by the window.
She headed south to Spain to a city that hugged the coast. This time, Susan worked in a market that looked over the bright blue ocean, except she was told not to talk to anyone. Instead, she laid out the day’s merchandise, from the oranges and melons to almonds and cashews to tomatoes and eggplant. Eventually, she began to sell her own herbs to neighbors. However, while in France her days were marked by mornings, in Spain her days were marked by her nights. She would go out dancing in the streets to the lilting guitar melodies. Her skirts did not spin in circles around her ankles and her laugh did not dissipate into the crowd; instead, she was breathing heavy as she tried to keep up with the fast-paced music. She would fall onto the rickety wooden chairs, and her friends would laugh, only to pour her some more wine and pull her back into the crowd. Susan was neither beautiful nor lovely; she was passionate. Here, she felt imbued with her younger sister’s spirit, who would have enjoyed the almost dryad-like dancing in the streets.
She spent years doing this. She travelled to Venice and Rome and then dipped into the cool waters of Greece. She slept on boats bobbing on the canals in Amsterdam and crunched her way through snow in Switzerland. Eventually, when she tired of Europe, she took a boat to America, passing her way from New York to San Francisco. Susan found love in Mexico, and again in Bolivia. She was all of her siblings, wise and passionate and brave, and yet at the same time, none of them. For once, she left behind the previous preconceptions that she was beautiful and found herself in the alfajores of Argentina and the Italian gelatos. While she indulged, she discovered more herbs, more plants: olive leaves in Greece and ginseng in China. The smell of nature—growth and decay—tantalized each of her senses, reminding her of a past she had lost. Although at first Susan traveled to run away, now she traveled to run towards something, snatches of a past that were as fleeting as they were important.
When she sat in Paris drinking black tea, Susan thought of her siblings, imagined Ed reading a paper in front of her with Lucy chattering away of a Monet exhibition and Peter sipping coffee. But, she also thought of her other friends, like Charlotte who had a grandmother living in the 12eme arrondissement, Isabel who would be sketching Susan, and Amalia who would be begging to visit Moulin Rouge. She would pass by parishes and churches, and recalled a time when she too had been pious; but now, she had reconciled her faith, and decided to believe in herself.
In this post-war, post-death world, Susan was alive. In another post-war, post-death world, she had been alive too, amongst the lush hills and mountains, where the sun always shone and magic was in front of one’s eyes. Here, though, although the sun did not always shine, magic was still present, in the clicking of her heels on cobblestones while dancing, the aroma of baking bread, the feel of crumbling dirt between her fingers, and the bitter after taste her tea left in her mouth. The world was not something to be conquered and dreaded, but a dear old friend.
She never did marry or have children, but Susan did die with friends around her bed, toasting her 82nd birthday with Italian wine and scones. A bouquet of flowers was at her head, a mixture of daisies and lavender and cherry blossoms.
When she woke up, she was laying under an ash tree, a spade in her hand. A freshly turned plot was at her feet, and as if she had merely nodded off in the warm summer air, Susan returned back to planting aloe vera for the castle infirmary and basil for the local markets.