So my bf and I think that the Wishgiver is the customer service rep and the guy working the register at the witch-y shop, and i think for the wishes that do "go wrong" he gets an enjoyment for seeing these bad people suffer the consequences of their wants. Him suggesting he ask Nikki what she wants over the phone and in person, him suggesting Bear kill himself both times, him fucking around and "guessing what he was gonna ask for" over the phone, and him telling him "woaaahh dont come in here with that energy, bucko" in the shop, are all the proof I need.












