Some thoughts on being broke because you spent all your money on dumb bullshit and forgot to budget for the things you actually needed.
I have “spending all my money on dumb bullshit and then being broke” disease; not one but TWO DSM diagnoses that have the word “impulsivity” in the description, as well as what the more pop psychology inclined might call “addictive personality.” I quit drinking in 2018 and in the three years afterward I had shopping binges that fucked up my credit and my relationship. Broadly speaking, in my 20s, if I had $25 in my checking account with two days to payday and saw a $20 skirt I liked at the thrift store, I was buying it. Things are better now, but I still would never be accused of being “good with money.”
When I was at my brokest, it was an undeniable fact that my real problem was not making enough money. I entered the workforce making $9 an hour at the daycare before crawling up gradually to $16 answering the domestic violence hotline; then I finished grad school, moved to a place with higher salaries, and suddenly jumped up to professional wage employment. Even though my spending habits have only improved a little, it’s much easier to live a stable life in spite of this vice when I’m making a living wage.
However, it is also a huge problem for me that I live in an environment engineered in every possible way to make me buy crap constantly! Extremely smart people are getting paid a lot of money to convince me to pay to have whatever food I’m craving delivered to me at great cost, or to buy a new product to make my face look younger. They do not care if I can afford to pay my bills after buying all this crap.
I used to be extremely triggered by any discussion of “frugality,” as I saw “being frugal” as basically a moral virtue that I did not possess. I think a lot of people have the same knee-jerk reaction to discussions around overconsumption and trying to consume less or more intentionally. “No ethical consumption under capitalism” has become a thought-terminating cliche.
I think it’s fine and valid to say “being frugal isn’t a solution to poverty” and also “it is not a moral failing if you succumb to the many forces in your brain and environment pushing you to buy crap." Yes, poor people deserve nice things. Yes, sometimes a little treat is needed after a hard day. But… I also do not want to be a person who is always buying crap at the expense of her long-term financial health. I don't want to need to spend money in order to emotionally regulate. I don’t want to be lining the pockets of the people at DoorDash. I don’t want many pounds more plastic waste produced on my account. So what if Taylor Swift or the US Military pollutes much more? I don't control Taylor Swift or the US Military. I control me.
For me at least, getting better at delaying gratification is a valuable goal even though I may always struggle with it more than other people, and even though I arguably shouldn't need to always be practicing so much willpower just to not go broke. Maybe one day I won't have Instagram showing me a new dress that is exactly my style every 15 minutes. But until then I do need to find a way to self-manage.











