Playing Footsie
The first time I felt something slide against the inside of my ankle and up my calf partway, I thought it was an accident. I didn’t react, figuring whoever had done it was embarrassed, having thought it was a table leg or something. I simply nodded and remained engrossed in the story Louise was telling next to me, loud over the din of the restaurant. I didn’t even look around the table to see if anyone had reacted.
The second time the foot came, this time pausing against my ankle for a moment before sliding upward, the toe catching the edge of my skinny jeans and hiking them up a bit before snapping back down, I looked up in surprise. Dan was across from me and the most likely culprit, but he was staring intently at PJ sat next to him, the new storyteller.
The third time, my head snapped up to Dan the instant I felt a brush against my ankle. He still didn’t respond, but looking around it didn’t seem as if anyone else could have been doing it. I frowned, pulling my legs back and hooking my ankles under my chair. My suspicions of it being Dan were confirmed when he coughed and casually slid down a bit in his chair. To anyone else it would seem he was just trying to get more comfortable, but when I felt his foot back on my ankle, his leg stretched under the table to reach me, I raised my eyebrows. Still he didn’t look back or acknowledge me, instead slowly running his foot up the inside of my calf, then back down, bumping my foot playfully.
I kicked my foot lightly, trying to ward him off, but Dan must have seen this as an acceptance of the game, and only fought back harder. I could see the smile he was trying to hide, now, his lips in a tight line to try to act normal as we warred under the table. I was grinning, ignoring the conversation at the table and staring at Dan, trying my best to take control of the invisible war down below.
We fought and fought, and eventually it was becoming hard to keep it subtle. I was holding onto the table’s edge to keep myself upright, biting my lower lip in concentration with a challenging grin on my face. Dan still hadn’t looked at me but I could see him shifting in his seat each time he tried a new move.
Finally, in some incredible maneuver, I ended up with both his feet between my ankles, trapping them tightly. He finally looked at me and glared, while I let my lip release from my teeth and smiled, eyes sparkling with my victory. It wasn’t until several moments after that that I realized the conversation had ceased at our table, strangely silent in the middle of the bustling restaurant, and Louise and PJ were staring at us with raised eyebrows.
“What?” I giggled, still a bit high off my victory.
“You two need to get a room.” PJ mumbled, not looking at us as he spun his fork around on his plate.
“Honestly. Either you’ve been lying to us all this time, or you two really are just torturing yourselves waiting this long to admit it.” Louise added, sending us both pointed looks.
I frowned and opened my mouth to protest, letting Dan’s feet go.
“Guys, we’re just friends.” Dan grumbled and I nodded, looking to him to show him my support in the statement. We always leaned on each other whenever people doubted our friendship.
“Friends who can’t keep their eyes, hands, or apparently feet off each other.” PJ mumbled once again.
After this the subject was dropped, and through the end of the meal Dan and I’s feet didn’t touch again.
It wasn’t until we returned home and plopped on the couch, Dan sitting against one side as I sat on the other, facing each other as our feet came up and we pressed against each other, warring and using the armrests as backrests, that Dan suddenly stopped. My feet flew forward, not having expected the sudden halt in resistance, and I fell flat on the couch, my legs splaying around Dan.
I scrambled up to a seated position and raised my eyebrows.
“What happened?” I asked, my forehead crinkling in a frown.
“Nothing.... I just...” Dan trailed off, looking down at his toes which he wiggled in his socks absently, seemingly trying to think of how to word what he wanted to say. “I guess... Phil? Do you think maybe they were right?”
“Right about what?” I asked, not following his train of thought.
“Right about... you know. Us making things harder for ourselves... not being as happy as we could be... just because we’re too scared to actually say or do anything to change... us?” Dan mumbled. He still wasn’t looking at me, his toes spreading and curling with nerves.
I frowned, staring at him in confusion for a few moments, until finally his meaning hit me.
What?
What?
WHAT?
My mouth dropped open. I tried to shut it a few times, but it just kept opening back up, making me look I’m sure like a fish floundering for air. My eyebrows must have been up to my hairline as I tried to process what Dan was saying, my entire world flipped upside down.
Did he mean it? Was Dan, my best friend, the man I shared my life with, the most important person in my world, the man who gave me flutters each time he smiled at me... Was he really saying that after all these years of letting me think he could never love me... that he actually could?
Wouldn’t he have said something sooner? With all the talk of us being together from our fans... if he’d wanted that it surely would have come up sooner... right?
Though I suppose I’d known my feelings years ago, and I’d been too afraid. Why should it be different for him?
I snapped back into reality suddenly, mouth snapping shut as I realized Dan was now finally looking at me, bottom lip between his teeth as he worried it, clearly upset that I was taking so long to respond to such a huge question.
“Dan, I...”
“Sorry. Sorry, that was stupid. Can we just pretend I never said anything?” Dan stammered, putting his face in his hands and curling his knees tight to his chest.
“No... Dan...”
“I’m sorry. I can give you some space if you need it. I didn’t mean to- I don’t want to- I really value your friendship, Phil, I never want to lose that.”
“Dan...”
“If I ruined everything I understand... but just... please know that I never had any ulterior motives... I really meant everything I did, and I just did it because I love spending time with you...”
“Dan...”
“I’m not saying I love you! I mean... of course I love you... but I’m not in love with you. God... I’m so sorry.”
“DAN!” I finally shouted, grabbing his wrists and forcing him to look at me, his eyes slightly watery as he breathed heavy, fear clear in his expression.
Slowly, so slowly I almost felt as if I wasn’t moving, I brought Dan’s hands up to my cheeks and let them rest there, moving mine down to his shoulders. Dan gulped as he looked between my eyes, seemingly searching for answers as his lips parted in shock and suspense.
I didn’t make him wait there long, leaning in slowly to connect our lips. They only stayed that way for a minute before I pulled back, and now I was the one to flit my gaze between his eyes, biting my lip.
“Well that’s too bad.” I whispered and he frowned, eyebrows pulling together.
“What?”
“It’s too bad that you’re not in love with me.”
“Why?” Dan whispered, and I smiled gently, the corner of my mouth just slightly twitching up.
“Because unrequited love sucks.”
It took a moment for my meaning to sink in, and I relished in every minute, the smile that broke out across Dan’s face as he finally understood making me smile, and we were kissing, but it was more like laughing.
I did manage to make out the mumbled words between our lips and through our laughter, though, as he said the words that made my heart pitter-patter so hard I thought I might faint.
“Well I lied. I’m in love with you too.”













