Out of the 2017 commander what is the best in your opinion Nya
Hi there, thanks for your question!
I’ve reviewed a few of the Commander preconstructed deck series in the past, notably doing video reviews for the 2013 and 2015 editions with help from my friend @mtg-realm. While the opportunity to do a video set for the 2017 editions didn’t come up, I’ve had the chance to play with and against the four decks in the most recent batch and I can definitely give some thought on them.
The four decks are balanced very well for play against each other, and Wizards seems to have taken steps to avoid one of the set being the “chase deck” as they used to do with cards like True-Name Nemesis. The Dragon deck is a bit more sought after currently because of the popularity of the tribe and the novelty of a five-color list, but in terms of card value they’re pretty close to the same across the set. As far as performance goes, I find that the Cat deck is a bit more stable to play, owing likely to it being a two-color deck whereas the others are all three-plus. That said, the other decks’ wider color identities offer them a bit more flexibility in their playstyles, whereas the Cat deck tends to stick to a similar strategy with each passing game. Stability isn’t a bad thing though, and the Cat deck is probably the best at doing what it needs to progress in the game.
In terms of overall potential, I think that the Vampire deck probably has the most capacity to perform well in a vacuum. Edgar Markov is a monster of a Commander and the deck is well-suited towards him at the head. The Wizard deck is the one I have the least overall experience with, but it’s got its share of great cards as well. Kess, Dissident Mage is specifically getting a lot of attention in the community right now. In terms of overall performance, though, the four are pretty equal in actual gameplay and are well matched to each other.
As jumping-off points to build your own deck, any of the four is a decent skeleton to get started. As with the previous decks in the series, the biggest hurdle to overcome is that the mana bases aren’t the best out of the package and you’ll likely want to improve them quickly. The recent reprint of the rare Checklands in Ixalan are a definite help in this regard. Any of the four lists are an excellent skeleton to begin with, so if your plan is to rebuild the deck into your own creation, you can’t go wrong with any of them.
Thanks again for your question! I hope I was able to help. Have fun!
