If I control a Ria Ovor, Bane of Bladehold and a Gisela, Blade of Goldknight, and I go to combat and target Gisela with Ria Ivor, how many mite tokens will I make when Gisela hits? Since they're both replacement effects do I get to pick the order they apply? Does this change if a third player controls the Gisela and I hit the second player with a different creature targeted by Ria Ivor?
The controller of Gisela is irrelevant here beyond which of her abilities applies to the damage being dealt, so she could be yours or another opponent's and the result would be the same.
So what is the result here? Unfortunately, it's the worst case scenario for you, or at least it's likely to be. Both Gisela's ability and Ria's ability affect the combat damage that the creature would deal to your opponent. When multiple replacement or prevention effects want to modify the same combat damage event, then the player being damaged (or the controller of the creature or planeswalker being damaged) gets to choose which effect gets applied first. In this case, they'll almost certainly choose to prevent the damage with Ria's ability first, leaving nothing for Gisela to double.


















