And I realized John Darnielle was just like me. Normies don’t make this shit up, and when they try, like non-alcoholics who try to write about alcoholism, they get it wrong. Because they might know what it looks like on the outside, they might know the clichés and the Lifetime movie versions, but they don’t know. Not really. Not how it feels.
Darnielle knew. I could tell.
He knew why I drove too fast to escape the step-family house of pain. He knew about getting wasted and playing video games for hours, punching things, finding a girl, just one girl to grab onto who would make it okay and not ask stupid questions about why I was never anything but angry or sad.
And the chorus—I’m gonna make it through this year if it kills me—in the context of living with an angry stepfather, was not just a rock anthem. It was a prayer. I knew if I could make it out of town, make it to college, I would survive. But I wasn’t sure I would.
Albums of Our Lives: The Mountain Goats’ The Sunset Tree by Ray Shea.













