#rwde criticism

[thesheepwhocriedwolf]

So the whole thing with the tags isn't your fault because Tumblr automatically filters anything w "rwde" in it whether or not it has anything directly attached to it, and the only way to get block them is to block "anti rwde" or just "anti" in general, so people can't really get onto you for that.

But I do think it's an oversight to accuse all rwde bloggers as being the same since those partaking in rwde vary greatly, and some only use the rwde tag because they don't want to annoy people by posting their criticisms or comments in the main tags. I've looked at rwde for a while just cause I like to read other people's opinions(whether I agree or not) and honestly some of the opinions on there aren't actually RUDE but because they go against the usual positive opinions of the fndm they post it in rwde as to not step on each other's toes. Obviously there are exceptions with both rwde and fndm where people are a lot more hostile to each other in bad ways, but neither of these exceptions should be seen as the entirety of these communities.

"Not your fault Tumblr tag system works but I'm going to continue arguing semantics about something that I can't get the point of."

Yeah you bring up good points at the same time you're missing literally all of mine and it's hard not be super aggressive especially after getting anon bombed and hate asks that I've deleted already and won't even humor with a response. so like Jesus fucking Christ. Hang in here real quick.

ENOUGH of you have made such a huge shit stain on this fndm that you now have a specific corner to continue wiping shit all over so the rest of us can continue to play nice with those that wish to play nice and avoid the shit stained corner. ENOUGH of you still haven't got the point and keep flooding my asks with the same argument. "WeRe NoT aLl ThE sAmE"

Let me tell you how criticism of this show isn't actually criticism but some way to bully belittle and shit on something nice because of some sort of repressed bigotry or just spite because the show didn't end at vol 3.

ENOUGH of you have pushed fans out because of said bad faith in the show. ENOUGH OF YOU have KEPT NEW MEMBERS from entering.

You know how many I talk to that say "I saw RWBY once thought it was cool but anyone I talked to online about it hated it so much that I just didn't stay into it" or they go "yeah I didn't get into it because the fandom is really shitty" When you do the things you've done you push new people and the content creators away. This is like clockwork with RWDE and gets worse the closer a new season comes out. Shit even Kdin gets fucking transphobic hate.

The amount of times Monty's name gets brought up in your "criticism" is insane and this is a huge issue I personally have. There's receipts to this shit and doesn't take long to find them on your own. it took me my first week in the fndm to see "This wasn't Monty's vision" whining. While yes at first I was dumb enough to believe it but you know what else I accumulated while watching this show by myself?

My own fucking brain that I use for actual real comprehension and decide for myself to keep watching or not. Does this make me happy? yes. keep watching. No? well time to turn it off and go watch FMA.

Shit the only reason I still watch Wrestling is for the few story lines and gimmicks I personally care about or I'd turn that shit off in a heartbeat because it's terrible and half the talent doesn't have actual talent outside being a damn body builder. You know what I do during the matches I don't like? I skip them. I don't even humor them with watching the show live. I use that fast forward button and don't even bother trying to watch what is bad and skip right to the good stuff.

RWDE fndm could learn to just not cause that's a thing.

The show didn't go downhill it just wasn't the show you expected or wanted it to be and that's okay you are allowed to think that. You're also allowed to move on and watch something else like MHA if you don't like RWBY.

Toddlers understand this better. it's not hard.

That's cause of Yall and your shit "criticism" that isn't criticism at all. Neath has called you out for it, Miles and Kerry both state they don't want y'all as "fans" because you're not fans you just hate watch it and shit on it preventing anyone from truly being happy because we have to see such ridiculous claims and hate and bigotry sore from all over and unlike most fandoms the RWBY one is unfortunately imo the worst fandom there is. You attack them about their deceased best friend and brother insisting you knew this man better than those who grew up with him and knew him on a way more personal level.

RWBY is Monty's passion project and the fact you tarnish his name and put words in his mouth is fucking disgraceful and dishonest. It's scummy and there's no excising it. Stop it.

You want a reminder on who Monty is and what he would condone look at Neaths tweets. Read back on Monty's own conversations. Look to the message of RWBY. Maybe you'll learn a thing or two.

RWDE is pronounced RUDE for a reason and we keep arguing semantics like somehow you'll magically be right among the bullshit.

Don't like a show/content? Don't watch it. Don't comment about it. Don't attack people about it. It's not worth your time or energy. Do SOMETHING ELSE and leave people who enjoy that thing alone to enjoy it in peace with the others who also enjoy it.

If you truly have "criticism" like REAL criticism then fine use it. I'm not here to gatekeep like y'all assume I am. I'm tired of the bullshit where you act like innocent do no wrong angels and attack people because "Qrow and Clover aren't gay for each other" or "Sun and Blake never got together and CRWBY is just pandering to the gay Folx for no reason waaaaa" or "RT is going under waaaa" It's stale get something with meat on it then we'll talk.

Also to those anons attacking me earlier before I deleted your asks read this first part.

THE TAGS ARE FUCKED UP. is what is says.

NOT MY PROBLEM is also what it says.

Angry about it? BLOCK ME.

[rwdestuffs]

Ironwood had two seats on the council, brought an army to a historically peaceful event, and tried to keep the fact that Penny was an android with Aura a secret from literally everyone. He also knew full well that Winter, and by extension Weiss, Whitely, and Willow were all abused by Jacques and did… nothing. He also discourages individuality, if the way Atlas is run is anything to go by, and instilled Martial Law onto Mantle, arresting anyone who fights grimm without his say-so.

Outside of that Martial Law thing, we saw all of this well before Volume 7. How people didn’t see that he would go mad with power is beyond me, but whatever.

So to see people complain about “his character being ruined” is honestly baffling. To see that fucked up ironweiss shipper want comfort for his death is also really telling.

These people wanted Ironwood to be treated as an anti-hero, but without the necessary sacrifice to fulfill the “Hero” part. Oh yeah, sure. He sent Yang an arm.

Remember that Mr. “Your soul is a temper tantrum” was planning on calling in a favor? If Ironwood was doing anything, he wasn’t rewarding Yang, he was trying to stay in a favorable light with her because she’s Qrow’s niece. Ironwood only helps those that he wants on his side. As evidenced by the fact that he has locked up dissenters in Volume 7.

Give it up, Ironwood fans. This guy wasn’t going to be a hero. Admittedly, I wasn’t expecting him to be an arc villain, but expecting him to be a heroic character was naive at best, and military bootlicking at worst.

This guy also had a city drop on him, and then was caught in a flood. The fact that rwde tag is treating that whole cameo fiasco (the deal with Miles acting unprofessional to the ironweiss shipper being a different subject for a different time) as if they needed to “Confirm” his death is honestly something I don’t get. I personally thought that it was pretty obvious that he died. Admittedly, people thought that Pyrrha was merely “teleported” back in Volume 3, so maybe it was kinda necessary, but still. That’s more on the Ironwood stans than on the writers.

And I’d REALLY appreciate it if people were to stop making me defend Miles of all people. That asshole’s on my list of people that I’d love to tell off and point out to his face every problematic thing he did, so making me defend him makes me feel gross.

[rwdestuffs]

Y’know, I’m not going to say that Ironwood is irredeemable. I like Salem and Raven, and I think that they can also be redeemed, so that’d be hypocritical of me.

But guys… C’mon.

The dude brought in his army to a kingdom that his kingdom tried to conquer, to a festival celebrating individuality and unification, just so that he could have a dick-measuring contest with Ozpin.

He refuses to acknowledge that he was at fault for Vale’s fall despite the fact that it was mainly because he wanted to prove that he was stronger than Ozpin was.

The only likable thing he’s done so far was arrest jacques and call him out on his and the Atlas 1%’s bullshit. After that, he’s just another power-hungry military douchebag.

Would I have appreciated a more in-depth look into his downward spiral to this point?- Yes. Duh. I’m not an idiot.

But to think that this wasn’t inevitable is honestly kinda naive.

[rwdestuffs]

Can someone please get rwde-rwby to shut up, all that blog does is post other peoples shitty videos and like, post about how "blake doodled adam one time in her notebook so that's how we know she wasn't abused", like, they make all of us who are critical of rwby look bad because the stans keep pointing to their dominance in the rwde tag as evidence that we're all dumb. It's just bad take after bad take about adam or ships or women (even though he's long dead can we shut up about him now?)

I mean… I have them blocked because of those shitty Adam takes. So I can’t really tell them to shut up.

[thesheepwhocriedwolf]

The whole thing with Ruby's "dropped character trait" is that there are lines that could lead one to reasonably conclude her to be a bit of a weapon nerd.

Along with her whole "all signal students design their own weapons" she also said she went a bit overboard with hers because she's a dork when it comes to weapons.

There's also the part where she turns into a 2d chibi in vol 1 when she's watching people go by w Yang and pointing out all their different weapons, as well as her interest with jaunes weapon and what it does.

The last occurance of this if I remember correctly was that line in vol 5 where Havens being shown and she says "look at all the weapons".

So I guess I can kinda see how that could be a dropped character trait since it hasn't come up in 3 volumes, but tbh I really don't think it matters all that much. They're never in a situation where they need her to repair or upgrade someone's weapon(though a scene of her helping Jaune or someone upgrade their weapon in vol 7 would've been cool) so I don't really see it as an important criticism.

yes Ruby is a weapons buff that's been her thing since the start but it's not a dropped trait they can always mention it later. like you mentioned they haven't had the time to think about these things that's why I find it ridiculous that someone even felt the need to bitch about it.

Stories not over guys for all we know she could marry the ultimate almost weapon (Penny) after she gets revived one last time it doubt that's going to happen. Stop bitching about the things that could come into play later.

You're correct it's not an important "criticism" it's not even real criticism at all you know like the rest of the "group I'm not allowed to name" wants us to think.