Your demon lover paused the washing of their scalpel, seemingly to ponder your question. They could detect from your tone that you were not inquiring about their diet. After a short pause, the demon responded.
"I quite like eyes, despite not having any. They come in a variety of such pretty colors, and they're easy to read. I find it fascinating that you can sometimes tell what someone is thinking or feeling just from their eyes. Yours happen to be my favorite pair so far."
Their face turned slightly pink at their last statement.
AJ tilted their head curiously, providing you with their full attention as they answered, "Of course. What kind of favor?"
"Could I perhaps uh…see the inside of your mouth?"
Okay, that was definitely not what the half demon was expecting. Red and confused, they asked, "W—what? Why?"
"—It's just—I've never really seen your tongue and teeth before and I just wanted to look at them—!"
Looking perturbed as ever within their confusion, you panicked while trying to mediate for the unsavory reaction. Waving your arms back and forth, you spoke hurriedly. "I'm not making fun of you or anything! I promise!"
After that reassurance, AJ's expression changed to something less concerning, smiling softly with a flushed face. The half demon would always encourage you to satisfy your curiosity for anything involving anatomy. So as strange and…interesting as your request was, they were not going to turn down the opportunity to teach you something about themselves while getting some attention from you, even if it was from somewhere so–ahem–sensitive.
"AJ? Earth to AJ?"
"O—Of course, I dont mind." Perfect. What a smooth and timely mannered response, the demon chastised themselves.
Your smile had an immediate effect on your lover with those adorable curves to your cheeks, your curious self leaning oh so close to their face.
Following through with their statement, the demon opened their mouth, allowing for two black tentacle-like tongues to come out. They unfured like a carpet down a walkway. The tongues themselves were much longer than your own, hanging out at least five inches or so from your lover's mouth. Thick at the base from where they hung in AJ’s mouth, you followed along the length of them as they slimmed down towards their tips.
A top and bottom row of razor sharp teeth also greeted you. You were reminded of a shark when looking at them.
To say you were gobsmacked would be an understatement. You couldn't believe what you were seeing. "Wow—!"
The demon answered the best they could with flushed cheeks. A warbled “yeah” was their response, causing their tongues to writhe ever so slightly.
"May I touch?," you asked politely.
AJ paused briefly before nodding slowly.
"Please be careful." Their words were garbled, but you still understood.
Trying to be thoughtful, you offered to come back. "Let me just go wash my hands—"
AJ stopped you with a hand to your arm. Their other hand dove into their hoodie pocket and came out with a pair of rubber gloves. You stifled a laugh. Count on your lover to always be prepared. After slipping the gloves onto your hands, you reached for one of the demon's tongues.
The black appendage wrapped itself around your fingers. A black substance similar to the one leaking from the demon's eyes beaded onto your glove. It was fascinating. You retrieved your hand to stroke one of AJ's many teeth, causing them to shudder. This continued until you spoke again.
"Is this all sensitive? Are you okay?"
They nodded as an answer to both questions. Having satisfied your curiosity, you retracted your hand from the demon's mouth. Their tongues retreated as they closed their maw. It was during this that an idea came to you.
"What would you say about using your mouth on me in the bedroom?," you purred seductively, causing AJ's already flushed face to become even more red.
"I was told to come see you if I had any injuries."
The half-demon, who you noted was unmasked, nodded and then motioned to a chair in their room.
"That is correct. If you'll please have a seat and tell me of your injuries, I can patch you up."
They had a nice voice. It was soft, low and pleasant. The fusion's face was dotted with cute freckles across the bridge of their nose and cheeks. Striking blue irises stood out against two pitch black puddles. Their short hair was a nice blend of brown and honey.
The sound of faint footsteps approaching your chair broke you away from your staring.
"Are you alright, [creepypasta name]? You haven’t told me what you're injuries are."
Whoops. You forgot about that. They were too cute.
"Nothing, really. A few scratches here and there," you shrugged.
The half-demon looked down shyly before speaking. "May I...see them?" You extended your arms. Thin scratches decorated them in different areas.
A smooth, grey hand gently took hold of your wrist, turning it this way and that. The hooded fusion hummed.
"These don't look too bad. Nothing a few bandages can't fix."
Having said this, the half-demon went to reach into a drawer on their small counter and pulled out a box of bandages. They returned to you shortly with the box, already having an unwrapped bandage in hand. You held your arms out and watched them work. The fusion was exceedingly gentle while applying the band-aids.
They had sat on the floor during the process to relieve your arms. Their head was almost in your lap. The urge to run your fingers through their hair was mighty tempting.
"Thanks for patching me up, Eyeless."
The fusion did not look up when they answered. "Please, call me AJ." They then kissed both of your hands. After doing that, the half-demon looked up at you, embarrassed.
"I-I am so sorry! Was that too forward-? My sincerest apologies!"
To reassure and calm them, you cupped their cheek in your hand. The flustered fusion nuzzled into your palm. Their eyes looked at you pleadingly.
"AJ, it's okay," you reassured them. "I like you too. I was building up the courage to tell you."
AJ's eyes widened slightly at your admittance. Their gaze soon shifted shyly.
"Does that mean that- Would it be alright if I-Would you mind if I-?!" Their stuttering was cut off by your lips. AJ froze, then slowly melted into the kiss. You both no longer needed to breathe, but AJ wanted their first kiss with you to be short and sweet. Their forehead rested on yours when they withdrew.
"Is it too early to say 'I love you?'," they whispered.
Imagine playing the pocky game with Bittersweet AJ/BJ.
Their favorite flavors are milk chocolate, dark chocolate, cookies and cream, and strawberry.
AJ would either be frozen in place while you eat the pocky or take very small bites. If you kiss them, their face will be silver with their blush. AJ will shyly gesture for you to continue playing with them after. 💙🖤
Y/N's first meeting with Bittersweet AJ/BJ Headcanons
You would probably find her wind up box in an old store or have it gifted to you by someone you know.
The box itself is black with a dark blue ribbon. A slower and sadder version of Pop Goes The Weasel plays when you turn the crank. [The same version plays at her carnival.]
AJ would make her presence known to you in your dreams first. She would make you dream of her carnival, her home. It is very melancholy with all the blue and black accompanied by the sad music.
You would either find her failing to entertain an audience in the main tent, or see her munching on cotton candy while playing carnival games. [She's amazing at the 'throwing darts at balloons' game.]
If you go directly up to her to ask her what's going on or who she is, she'll swiftly disappear in a cloud of black smoke. I advise approaching her slowly.
AJ would shyly ask you your name before giving hers. She would tell you that you can call her AJ or BJ for convenience. The sad clown would then answer any questions you had.
After your few dreams of AJ and her carnival, she will appear in your house. It is like she is hardly there, however. She will remain silent and observant unless addressed directly. The more you talk to and spend time with her, she'll start to come out of her shell.
AJ is extremely careful with not leaving poisoned candy around the house for you to eat. If you do find a piece, she will swiftly take it from you in a panic. If you want candy, she'll either make some appear out of thin air or accompany you to the store to buy some. [Don't worry, no one can see her but you. You probably shouldn't talk to her a lot though unless you want to get some stares.]
What kissing Antly is like: You'll have to initiate any kisses between you two due to her anxiety about bothering you. She doesn't want to agitate you by being clingy, so she tends to leave you to your own devices unless summoned or she's craving affection/quality time. Note: Giving her a kiss is a good way to calm her down when she's feeling angry/possessive. Kiss her when she pokes her head out of your television or computer and she'll be a shy, flustered mess.
[All gifs belong to their creators]
[Antisepticeye belongs to Sean McLoughlin aka Jacksepticeye]
