I SAW WICKED FOR GOOD SPOILERS BENEATH THE CUT
okay when i saw part 1 and started thinking about how they'd do part 2, i felt like they'd put a buffer before thank goodness to get some more worldbuilding in, and they did, and i...kinda wish they hadn't?
don't get me wrong, the opening sequence? epic. it's so over the top superhero (elphaba skateboarding on her broom for no reason other than she can, she is in fact that girl) but it's so freaking good? give me rebel elphie! gimme that worldbuilding about how she's actually resisting the wizard! DAMN it was sick
but everything in the emerald city felt kinda clunky and i almost wish they had jumped straight to the engagement party after elphaba's attack on the yellow brick road
glinda flashback! listen i love baby glinda. i love her. in general, i love the added moments of reflection we get from glinda, even though i do think parts of this movie were rushed and deserved more time (looking at you, wicked witch of the east, but we'll get there)
but what i love the most about it is that baby glinda's wand showed her reflection, and adult glinda's wand absolutely does not. she can't see herself anymore, she doesn't know who she is anymore. and she certainly can't see her own smile (it also ties so well into the bubble symbolism. the bubble she's in as a little girl, the bubble bursting as an adult. idk SYMBOLISM man)
Elphaba's new song. i...didn't like it a whole lot, although i suspect i'll like it more on a rewatch/relisten (because tbh for so many of the things that were different than the musical i did have to fight through moments of 'but that's not--' and it's a kneejerk reaction and it's fine). BUT i love everything that the song represents. i love where it sits in the story. i love the interactions with the Animals. i LOVE dulcibear coming back, oh my god how good for elphaba in that moment (and how tragic, too
this, combined with actually showing her rebel acts, does a great job of actually doing justice to her cause. which is something that the stage show, understandably, fails to do. giving us tangible examples and actually taking the time to examine why and how elphaba fights puts so much more depth to everything she's fighting for
and and and! showing how morrible is sabotaging her at every turn! extremely well done and i loved it so much
okay. wicked witch of the east
first of all, i adored that first sequence where nessa is the last ruler to sign Animal rights away. i love her and boq speaking to each other like humans, like they still know each other. it's like the last dying breath of their friendship, and it shows that they were actually friends this was something i really loved about part 1, and they continued to do it justice here, and it just adds so much more tension to nessa's transformation
i also adore the little detail of nessa opposing Animal rights because she doesn't want to be seen as supporting Elphaba. gimme that political intrigue! gimme that commentary on politics vs morals and how personal motivation gets tangled up in all of it, ugh it's so good
the scene with boq at the train station? harrowing. brilliant. i so wished they touched on it again, showed more of oz being affected by the spreading oppression, but i understand why they didn't (once again, i am begging someone out there to make a dark wicked years miniseries oh my god)
i do like that they changed some of the dialogue between elphaba and nessa, because changing it to 'you never wanted my help' 'i do now' was necessary. i think they did a lot of brilliant buildup with nessa in part 1 and they did a good job of keeping all of it relevant in this scene
howeverrrr, it feels like they didn't quite stick the landing with the wicked witch of the east scene. the dialogue leading up to nessa's spell felt fumbled somehow. i don't even know if it was, or if it's just me being 'it's different' and getting needlessly grumpy over it. but i do wish they'd spent even just another minute or two in this scene
flashing back and forth between nessa singing, elphie casting, and boq transforming was brilliant
(in general, the way they depicted those super violent moments with boq and fiyero, by flashing back and forth to it and only showing glimpses, was brilliant. it's a great way to have that heaviness and those consequences while keeping the feel of the stage show where it all happens off-screen)
nessa: you just want to go to the city to see fiyero again
elphaba: goes to see glinda for literally no reason other than to just see her again
i know what you are elphie
actually that entire scene in glinda's room was so so beautiful and i loved every second of it
i actually liked glinda being part of wonderful. it feels right, it adds so much to the moment, it's great. but it also felt extremely scripted, like glinda and the wizard had planned every detail of it, and like, that makes sense, they could have so easily done that and it would've been great, but that's not what happened?
i liked wonderful! i really did! i think i have to watch it again though because something about it just didn't quite click the way i expected it to
maybe it felt a little open-ended too, since it's like. glinda runs off to go get married and the wizard disappears conveniently for a minute so elphaba can find the Animals and it's like. welp. show's over now. bye. on with the plot
but! elphaba finding the Animals
i was hoping Chistery would show her dillamond and i was not disappointed (side note i loved chistery, and the monkeys in general, they were so well done throughout, no notes, 10/10, added to every scene they were in)
the flip back and forth between glinda walking down the aisle and elphaba walking into the room with the cages. brilliant. perfect. no notes.
this might be nitpicky but i think my least favorite thing in the entire movie was how morrible was a weirdly comedic villain in the first half (glinda: it's okay, stay calm. morrible: she's going to kill us all!)
and like. it's a fair depiction when you think about stage morrible. but in part 1, most of morrible's comedic moments were given to miss coddle. idk man, i just don't think the woman standing in her tower and conjuring a cyclone while dramatic music plays can be the same woman who got knocked face-first into a big cake the scene before. it just doesn't work
also side note michelle yeoh? brilliant beautiful breathtaking. the outfits were 10/10 the sinister vibes were impeccable the fight with glinda after march of the witch hunters was everything i've ever wanted and i loved every second of her in this film even when the tone felt off so you know what, there are worse things to complain about
moving on because jonathan bailey and just the writing in general make movie fiyero so much more likable than stage fiyero. however. they still fall into the trap of fiyero and elphaba being simply unable to compare to the relationship that is so slowly and richly developed throughout the entire rest of the story. ALAYM was beautiful and they were both so good but it still felt kinda jarring that they're suddenly singing about being passionately in love when they've talked to each other like 3 times in their lives
(i feel like the movie almost got away with this too, but by cutting the friend group scenes at shiz and by keeping elphaba's line of 'we barely even know each other' at the train station, they really do undercut fiyero and elphie's relationship)
((although i did find it hilarious and adorable when elphaba was like 'oh no fiyero hates me too now' and she had a flashback to the poppy scene that was like 90% her and glinda being cute together. elphaba come on that's the wrong crush you're thinking of))
i loved elphaba's lil mangrove hideout so much i was kinda sad when she moved to kiamo ko
even though kiamo ko. holy helllllll it was so cool
anyway this is the point of the movie where everything was absolutely perfect, like from the cat fight scene on i was obsessed, relishing every single second, it was so good
the cat fight. precious. adorable. and maybe this is me being biased but as it went on and as they started teasing each other while trying to fist fight it really felt like they could make up. like they just had to get through this scrap and they would cry and hug and make up. and i think that adds something to the scene, and adds something to the fact that they're interrupted. they're going to be fine, but then the guards come and tear them apart, emotionally and physically
the monkeys swooping in with fiyero! like i said, they added so much to every scene they were in
even though i was begging them to stay with him. elphaba's flying to safety! she doesn't need protection! you do, fiyero! aw, dammit, he's done for
i think the end of the cat fight is my favorite glinda and fiyero moment, and oh my god jonathan bailey and ariana grande killed it
also right before elphaba flies off, when both fiyero and glinda tell her go. they both just love her so much and want her to be safe
no you don't understand, no good deed
easily the best moment in the film. my jaw was on the floor and i could hear other people in the theater reacting and just being in awe, it was everything
i mean we been knowing. we knew. of course we knew cynthia erivo would deliver but oh my god it was e v e r y t h i n g
the people in my theater genuinely cheered and they were right
march of the witch hunters was everything i have ever wanted. it being this sort of send-off for dorothy, seeing the emerald city turn dark and chaotic and violent, calling for blood. glinda and boq's little moment where they look at each other and both have to face what they've become. absolute perfection
(i actually have so many thoughts about boq in this. the way he embodied the tin man, the violence that stemmed from his character arc, the way he truly does feel like he lost his heart. nobody from the shiz group makes it out okay but he really does truly feel cursed, and it's so well done)
Glinda's song. i liked it more than elphaba's, but it did feel a little bit out of place pacing-wise. but i loved it, it's glinda's defying gravity, and of course her break free moment is quiet and tragic, of course it happens before she ever takes action. a careful plan rather than an emotional outburst. i think it represents glinda's journey so well, and once again, i love the little introspections we get with both her and elphaba throughout
also the song ending with her reflection in the bubble, it's time for the bubble to pop, yeah yeah symbolism BUT then glinda leaves the shot, and it's not her reflection in the bubble anymore, it's the emerald city's. symbolism.
i am physically in pain over the fact that they cut the scene that explains why glinda has elphaba's boots in her closet
but who cares about that because her taking feldspar and riding off in disguise, that moment when it clicks who was riding across the bridge at the beginning of part 1, OH MY GOD
it was. it was good. real good. i liked it a whole lot
i don't even know what to say. it was perfect. like genuinely flawless. like a technical masterpiece
it was always going to be, especially with these two. and just. them. and the torchlight in the background. and the tears in their eyes. them. it was perfect.
elphaba tells glinda to hide, and she leads her to the door, and and and
listen i was fine during for good. a lil teary-eyed but fine. stable. perfectly okay.
but then they had to go and say "i love you" to each other. and THEN elphaba closes they door and THEY BOTH BREAK DOWN. it's that moment we all imagine with the trapdoor, glinda crying and elphaba unable to reach out and comfort her
idk man. elphaba putting on a smile and telling glinda it'll be fine. lying because someone is looking to her for comfort. but glinda knows how this works, she's been in that position, she knows elphie is lying
and the way they both immediately break, both of them holding on through the door, their last moment together being them standing there, a wall between them, mourning each other already
man i haven't cried that hard in a movie theater since carrie fisher showed up at the end of rogue one
glinda returning to the palace with an army of Monkeys, AS SHE DESERVES
we got rebel elphaba and badass glinda in one movie, my resistance dreams are coming true
okay i lied my real least favorite thing in the movie was teh comedic camera pan back to glinda during NOMTW reprise. it's just uhh not for me personally. but the rest of that sequence was fantastic
i love that we got proof of glinda restoring the Animals. just like they actually showed us elphaba fighting for her cause they actually show us glinda starting to do good <3
i also absolutely adore the moment when she tells morrible she's not good, not yet. gosh. that's my girl <3
okay some closing thoughts:
all of elphaba's outfits were great. i love her cozy lil cardigan, her ragged capes, the dramatic af cloak the Monkeys put on her? brilliant.
i also loved glinda's dress, i loved the pink streaks in it, and i loved how it looked like she has little wings at her shoulders, but the fact that she re-wore it so many times feels illegal???
also glinda's sweater thing in the poppy scene flashbacks looked like a wedding veil when the hood was up like oh my god that's gay
i think fiyero's scarecrow design was. eh. i mean, idk, i don't think it was bad i just think something was off about it. the hair? the eyes? maybe just the fact that compared to boq's intense transformation and reveal, and even the lion getting an earlier appearance before he shows up with dorothy, fiyero's reveal felt very...fleeting? brushed past? i have no idea how you would fix that though, so maybe i shouldn't complain lol
glinda going to the defying gravity balcony and elphaba looking back at oz for their final duet. the way the grimmerie opened for glinda after they sang their goodbye, as if elphaba was sending her off with the magic. i'm so fragile rn (so is glinda)
in conclusion: i love them