shadowmeowth replied to your post “Do you think Kokichi could have the Ultimate Strategist talent, thus...”
I feel like Kokichi's "official" title is a lie in itself, as he is merely the leader of DICE. It is the fact tha he sells it so well which could have earned him the title. Kodaka did mention that Kokichi would be properly the Ultimate Liar, and I personally find it fitting that his title being a lie is rather the point. At the same time, it hides a hint of truth, just like Kokichi says that there is always a shred of truth in a lie. :)
I’m sorry to say, but there is very little chance that Kokichi’s given title, “Ultimate Supreme Leader,” is a lie.
Aside from the “Everything is fiction... maybe” plot twist, no other characters are hinted at or show to have Ultimate Titles that aren’t their given titles, aside from Maki, and Maki’s official title is the title Monokuma addresses her as in her motive video. Otherwise, Ryoma would not have been able to blackmail Maki in case #2.
We already have a case of a false given title, so if we use that as a frame of reference, it becomes clear that Kokichi does not follow the same exception. Because Maki’s given title was initially false, with her motive video revealing her true title, Kokichi’s would have to follow the same principles if he were to have a fake given title.
Kokichi’s given title, “Ultimate Supreme Leader,” is what Monokuma refers to him as in his motive video and his research lab reflects this title more so than any other.
I also want to say something about my views towards Kodaka: Do not take his word at face value.
This is the same man who apparently intended to write Kokichi to be a trickster character who genuinely enjoyed the class trials and killing game while also writing his entire character arc to be about his anti-violence and him sacrificing his own life to break the killing game. Sorry, Kodaka, that’s not how writing works.
He’s also insisted that Kaede needed the help of her friends while Makoto and Hajime were independent. As if Maoto didn’t need Kyoko to hold his hand through the whole game. Take that as you will about his... morals.
Kodaka either A: Lies about his intentions for characters, or B: Is so bad at conveying his intentions via writing that his words and narrative don’t match up.
Kodaka also wrote Kokichi to be neglected, abused and ignored for no good reason due to personal beliefs rather than giving the cast or narrative any good reason to punish Kokichi until Chapter 4, when Kokichi’s already endured a lot of abuse from the narrative and his classmates.
I’m going to say this now, I ignore the intention of the writers. Especially here. The intention of the writers cloud theorizing and even analytical posts, so don’t expect me to use Kodaka’s words as a frame of reference or as “proof” of something since he’s an unreliable source of information to begin with.
I’ll also say that it’s... really bad to call Kokichi the “Ultimate Liar” for several reasons. The major big one is that its borderline ableist and degrading, since Kokichi’s lying is very clearly compulsive lying. Which is a disorder.
A more in-canon reason why Kokichi is very unlikely to be the ultimate liar is because... he’s not actually good at lying at all.
The point of lying is to make people believe the lie. Kokichi doesn’t use lying to obscure the truth, nor does he even lie convincingly. Kokichi lies as a method of controlling the truth in regards to himself and the information he has. He lies as a defense mechanism to protect the truth he knows, and he has a say in when it is revealed or not. This sort of ties in with the compulsive lying and may be the reason why he does compulsively lie.
To clarify further with an example: The Ultimate Writer can’t just be a writer who writes a lot of books. They have to be able to write amazing novels at all times, quality over quantity.
With this logic, you can see why it’s very unlikely Kokichi is the Ultimate Liar as his true title.
The issue that Kokichi is “only the leader of D.I.C.E.” follows the same principle. Kokichi’s quality leadership triumphs over the quantity of people he leads. We are also unaware of how Kokichi got his title to begin with, so it’s very possible that he was forced into a situation where he had to use his leadership skills to get out of trouble or lead others to the best possible solution. That’s headcanon territory though.
Sorry this is harsh and blunt (and maybe a bit salty) but I figured it’d be best to get my stance on this out of the way since it came up.