The Supernatural Character's Favourite Ice Cream Flavors
26 Characters: Dean Winchester, Sam Winchester, Castiel, Bobby Singer, Crowley MacLeod, Charlie Bradbury, Claire Novak, Lucifer, Gabriel, Chuck, Rowena MacLeod, Arthur Ketch, Balthazar, Kevin Tran, Jody Mills, Donna Hanscum, Jo Harvelle, Ellen Harvell, Ash, Cain, Gadreel, Metatron, Rufus Turner, Pamela Barnes, Benny Lafitte & Garth Fitzgerald IV
Summary: Headcanons for 26 Supernatural character's favourite ice cream flavors.
Warnings: swearing, light ship references, comedy, fluff, sweetness
Word Count: 1.6k
A/n: I spent far too much time on something this silly but I loved this so much. I covered a fair few characters but feel free to send in an ask if you'd like anyone else! Please just keep in mind that I'm only halfway through season 12 so I won't write for characters that haven't appeared yet. If you have an idea for similar headcanons to these, please let me know! I really enjoyed these and I hope you will too!
Dean Winchester
⊹✿🍨 Insane chocolate brownie triple chip anything
⊹✿🍨 He hides it in the back of the freezer behind the peas
⊹✿🍨 Charlie finds it and takes it but only has a little and puts it back perfectly, driving Dean insane because he keeps thinking that he ate more than he remembered eating
⊹✿🍨 He puts ALL of the toppings imaginable on there, except nuts. Health does not belong here
⊹✿🍨 Seriously, chocolate sauce, fudge, caramel sauce, chocolate chips, it's diabetes city and Dean's always first on the bus
⊹✿🍨 When he finds out about bacon ice cream it blows his mind and he sits in shock for a moment
Sam Winchester
⊹✿🍨 Some vegan crap fest, that's the nicest way I can put it
⊹✿🍨 He buys those low cal dairy free keto nightmares and Dean goes off at him for ever calling that ice cream
⊹✿🍨 Once when Kevin was having a shitty day, he took out what he thought was caramel ice cream but the second he had a spoonful he felt sick. He went off his nut at Sam and told "that over-grown keto diet puppy-dog pansy" to buy some real ice cream for once. Everyone was surprised that Kevin was the one to say it, but they all agreed
⊹✿🍨 Eventually he moves on to sorbets and everyone is happier, his favourite is lemon
⊹✿🍨 He will occasionally have boysenberry swirl ice cream, very rarely
Castiel
⊹✿🍨 Vanilla all the way.
⊹✿🍨 He doesn't really eat ice cream because he doesn't really eat but he likes to join in with the others and he remembers from his time as a human that he liked vanilla the most. It's also the least offense since he can taste the molecules in everything
⊹✿🍨 Occasionally he'll borrow one of Dean's toppings but he prefers it plain
⊹✿🍨 Sometimes he'll add some fresh fruit, his favourite has to be strawberries and raspberries. Everyone thinks he'd love blueberries but they're kinda eh to him
⊹✿🍨 Every six months he'll have a spoonful of Dean's ice cream and say in that familiar monotone "Still far too sweet" as he puts it back. Somehow, he's the only one Dean doesn't get mad at. Hm….
⊹✿🍨 He'll sometimes get mint choc chip. When he told Dean he got ice cream with chocolate chips in it Dean finally thought he had brought him over to the chocolate side before seeing the green ice cream and stating "Mint? Seriously?! That's not even ice cream, 's practically toothpaste!"
⊹✿🍨He thoroughly enjoys honey on vanilla ice cream
Bobby Singer
⊹✿🍨 Rum 'n' Raisin
⊹✿🍨 Nothing else
⊹✿🍨 Just Rum 'n' Raisin
Crowley MacLeod
⊹✿🍨 He honestly doesn't like ice cream
⊹✿🍨 But he will steal everyone else's
⊹✿🍨 Doesn't mind gelato, often opting for a coffee flavor
⊹✿🍨 But he prefers stealing it just to piss everyone else off
Charlie Bradbury
⊹✿🍨Eats anything
⊹✿🍨But has a soft spot for chocolate, specifically Dean's chocolate
⊹✿🍨 Her favourite is a bit of Sam's raspberry or strawberry sorbet and some of Dean's choc abomination
⊹✿🍨 Bit of a wild card but I think she like butter pecan ice cream. And pronounces it pee-can, as it should be pronounced
Claire Novak
⊹✿🍨 She's a perfect mix of Dean and Cas (obviously)
⊹✿🍨 She loves vanilla ice cream with an absurd amount of toppings
⊹✿🍨 Seriously, slathering on the fudge sauce with a trowel
⊹✿🍨 She also thinks mint ice cream is an affront to all that is good about ice cream
Lucifer
⊹✿🍨 Anything decadent or fancy, like those blended flavors and the one's you'd never think of like passion fruit pavlova
⊹✿🍨 His favourite of all has to be strawberries and cream because it's pink and he doesn't give a fuck (if you get the reference you're fucking awesome)
⊹✿🍨 He will absolutely steal Dean's ice cream and eat the entire thing in one sitting just to spite him - while using his magic to keep Dean back, wearing a shit-eating grin the entire time
⊹✿🍨 He once put a lemon sorbet in the freezer without saying a word, a form of silent peace offering to Sam
Gabriel
⊹✿🍨 Salted caramel. Nothing can beat salted caramel, nothing
⊹✿🍨 Sometimes he gets salted caramel macadamia, a close second
⊹✿🍨 Really anything sickeningly sweet but caramel and butterscotch flavors are his go to's
⊹✿🍨 He and Garth go to town whenever they're together, always getting the richest flavors and toppings to match
Chuck
⊹✿🍨 Bacon ice cream forever
⊹✿🍨 One of his favourite human creations
⊹✿🍨 Seriously, proud dad moment when they came up with that
⊹✿🍨He and Dean silently bond over it, it's quite sweet
Rowena MacLeod
⊹✿🍨 Not an ice cream person
⊹✿🍨 She's never really liked it
⊹✿🍨 But she will take the ice cream of others, just to annoy them, and never eat it
⊹✿🍨 Sometimes she gets Sam a sorbet. Sometimes
Arthur Ketch
⊹✿🍨 Vanilla for sure
⊹✿🍨 Often topped with nuts just to piss Dean off
⊹✿🍨 He's also a big fan of liqueurs on ice cream, something he introduces Dean to in a moment of kindness. Which he heavily regrets
⊹✿🍨 He doesn't mind a nice nut flavor, usually something with macadamias
Balthazar
⊹✿🍨 Same as Luci and Gabe, luxury all the way
⊹✿🍨 Though sometimes he'll enjoy a gelato with Crowley, but Balthazar prefers the fruity flavors
⊹✿🍨 Dean makes a joke
⊹✿🍨 He ends up stuck in a tree
⊹✿🍨 All is well in the world
Kevin Tran
⊹✿🍨 Kevin's an anything goes kind of fella but bubblegum is a personal favourite
⊹✿🍨 He'll steal from anyone, it doesn't matter who
⊹✿🍨 But he will NEVER get his own ice cream. Ever
⊹✿🍨 He especially likes to steal from Crowley on the rare occasion Crowley isn't stealing from someone else. It keeps the cycle going
Jody Mills
⊹✿🍨 Loves something fruity
⊹✿🍨 Mango has to be her favourite
⊹✿🍨 Sorbets are great, she and Sam pick them out together and whenever she comes by she brings him a lemon one, he brings her a mango one in turn
Donna Hanscum
⊹✿🍨 Strawberries and cream is top tier for her
⊹✿🍨 She loves Dean's monstrosity of chocolate though
⊹✿🍨 She'll eat most ice creams but she likes nut and coffee flavors the least (girl after my own heart)
⊹✿🍨But she'll always steal Jody's sorbets with a cute little smile, avoiding any chance of Jody getting mad at her
Jo Harvelle
⊹✿🍨 Jo is Dean coded all the way
⊹✿🍨 She steals his chocolate
⊹✿🍨 He steals her chocolate
⊹✿🍨 Ellen and Bobby think they're idiots and buy a spare tub
Ellen Harvell
⊹✿🍨 Either Vanilla or Rum 'n' Raisin
⊹✿🍨 Vanilla is classic and sometimes she'll have one scoop of each
⊹✿🍨 She and Bobby sit in silence while they eat their ice cream together, both very happy despite the looks on their faces
⊹✿🍨 On occasion, like when she's feeling a little sad but never says anything, she'll get some rocky road
Ash
⊹✿🍨Anything goes
⊹✿🍨Chocolate, fruit, caramel, nuts, the whole bag
⊹✿🍨 He likes those crazy candy flavors like banana lollies with actual candy in it
⊹✿🍨 He never shares, except with Kevin, on occasion
Cain
⊹✿🍨 Vanilla, nut flavors or liqueurs
⊹✿🍨 But sometimes he had very odd combinations
⊹✿🍨 He's very happy to sit by himself and enjoy his ice cream while people look at him strangely for combining mint choc chip with macadamias, caramel sauce and Bailey's
⊹✿🍨 But he's just a happy camper
⊹✿🍨 He very randomly sits with Cas and they have honey on their ice cream together
⊹✿🍨 Until Cain makes another strange combination and weirds him out. Cas' of all people, that's saying something
Gadreel
⊹✿🍨 Matcha and Ube
⊹✿🍨 He's into the more, specific flavors
⊹✿🍨 He's an acquired taste and so is his ice cream
⊹✿🍨 One of the turning points for him and Sam was when Sam asked to try some of his Matcha ice cream. It was small, but a start
Metatron
⊹✿🍨 Who gives a fuck?
⊹✿🍨 No literally
⊹✿🍨 He's mentioned it many times but whenever there's a grocery store run, somehow his ice cream gets left off the list
⊹✿🍨 And whenever he gets it himself, everyone eats it before he gets a change to
⊹✿🍨 Even Cas. Who will look him in the eyes while he does it. Baby's petty, it's one of the things I love most about him
Rufus Turner
⊹✿🍨 Pistachio
⊹✿🍨 Bit of a wild card, but so is Rufus
⊹✿🍨 No one, and I mean NO ONE, gets near his ice cream
⊹✿🍨 Sometimes he'll steal Bobby's Rum 'n' Raisin
⊹✿🍨 Who are we kidding? He always steals Bobby's Rum 'n' Raisin
Pamela Barnes
⊹✿🍨 Cookies and Cream
⊹✿🍨 I will say this until the day that I die
⊹✿🍨 No reason, she's just a cookies and cream lady, and I love her for that
⊹✿🍨 She will also steal Dean's chocolate, but she only ever has a small scoop with her cookies and cream because its too sweet, even for her
Benny Lafitte
⊹✿🍨 Does NOT like it at all
⊹✿🍨 Absolutely hates it
⊹✿🍨 His teeth are too sensitive
⊹✿🍨But back in his human days, he liked vanilla topped with pecans or peanuts
Garth Fitzgerald IV
⊹✿🍨 Big butterscotch fan
⊹✿🍨 Caramel too but butterscotch is the front runner
⊹✿🍨 Reminds him of his nana
⊹✿🍨 He always sits around and tells stories about her while sharing the ice cream with the kids (Claire, Alex and Kevin) whether they like it or not. Cas' always sits in too and sometimes Dean leans in the doorway and pretends not to care but he always loves hearing Garth's old stories
⊹✿🍨 Garth is the king of milkshakes along with Benny even thought he doesn't like ice cream and the two of them make the kids milkshakes whenever they like. Dean and Charlie line up every time
Taglists
General Supernatural
@dianawinchester03 @fmlariel @lipstickandlifts @i-dont-have-ideas @fanficreader476 @flintn0tf0und
@foggygentlemenprincess @perhaps-just-june @luvv4j4ybe11 @fmdijdjcyhdjcidbsjsv @deafult-f0x
@soullessambs @suchybadyl @jusbear @cantchooseafav @russopalette
@fury-under-night @whydosnakesnotdance @solomontheslime @lullabybug @imnotwarofthegod
@supernatural-love4ever @stringonaworm @l0ca1ax010t1 @cannibalcaiman @lurasbc
@florafauna-and-fae @rulesareshadesofgrey @eleniblue @kye-co @fluffydevilgaypanic
@r4nd0mf4nd0mqueen @celestialhaven @nourangul @ablondehoe @grav3yardbb92
@bbuckysbeardd @sandwichesthings @nenet-t @luckygirl1013 @kelsaackles
@polina66 @saltnburnbaby @cantchooseafav @b3oo @ryanxblank
Dean Winchester
@kaiboone @tiannamortis @book-nerd-fan-girl @dilfish-daydreams @sebbymylove16
@finnneedshelpp @govindasamykalayvani @talila819 @scamander-the-salamander @riddlers-titties
@wandrmoon @moonyardz @khadin18 @harleycao @biancalinkas
@waywardfillorian @yumekowhynot @rpri @halsteadwinchester @maddyjareauxo
@love4madii @autumnalbeing @ir87h @igotissues2009
Sam Winchester
@book-nerd-fan-girl @dilfish-daydreams @sebbymylove16 @harleycao @j5hannah
@hotchnerwife @disturbingbirds @yumekowhynot @rpri @halsteadwinchester
@maddyjareauxo @igotissues2009
Castiel
@dilfish-daydreams @inluvwleah @sebbymylove16 @cyberghost1009 @vickyburgonxoxo
@hollywritesinstardust @soggy-sailor @lenidaslenchen @blackcatonaladder @kye-co
@perfumella @fangirl2002 @yumekowhynot @rpri @absentsstuff @maddyjareauxo
@bothlovinglyandhatingly @theyoongieverse @halsteadwinchester @igotissues2009 @staygoldsquatchling02
@manibolly
Crowley
@kaiboone @yumekowhynot @rpri @igotissues2009
Bobby Singer
@kaiboone @book-nerd-fan-girl @igotissues2009
Lucifer
@disturbingbirds @rpri
Gabriel
@harleycao @disturbingbirds @yumekowhynot @rpri
Claire Novak
@disturbingbirds
Chuck
@rpri
Everything
@pinkthick @craftytacopiecash @meryuniverse @aliljaybird @macbaetwo
@castielshunterwife @scarletluvsdanno @twentyonetornmyheart @neospacedoctor @destiel-1967-sammy
@yigashimei @something0193 @ursamajor17 @colorfulavenuecollection @fairytailnerd1024-blog
@daithideolishmer18 @am-i-the-villain-co @mameeta @bblessed @maximum-uwu
@bbywonu @eatlembasbread @lightningdth @tzumanithewave @waywardbeardetective
@t-bird510 @luchios666 @kmystery @fandomwriter013 @dafidiblogwriter
@hysoneandonlylover @whitemelanin @ta1itha @ghost-is-unknown @meganwright91
@mortluvr @dean-winchester06 @ghost-is-unknown @wendichester
Fill out this form to be added to my taglists!
For more imagines, headcanons, fake texts, fics and drabbles check out my Masterlists!
