In an alternate universe where Supergirl landed on HBO instead of the CW, they’re allowed one (1) threesome scene. Who’s in it?
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Sam Arias
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Andrea Rojas
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Lucy Lane
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Red Daughter
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Imra Ardeen
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Nia Nal
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Kate Kane
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Metallo Lena
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, James Olsen
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Roulette
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Reign (requested by a mutual 😉)
Lena Luthor, Sam Arias, Andrea Rojas
Voting ended onJun 29, 2024
Supercorp and other couples, respectively, could (but are not required to) have multiple love scenes throughout the course of the show. This is a one off and it does not become a throuple situation.
because of this lucy lane news coming out, let me just post this superluthorlane draft I’ve had since like 2016
1. Who is the early bird/ Who is the night owl? - Lena and Lucy both get up a ridiculous hours of the morning. Lena stays up until ridiculous hours of the night as well. Lucy has an incredible internal clock and she almost always falls asleep at the same time every night and can wake up without an alarm. Kara thinks they’re crazy. Her sleep schedule is always wonky because of Supergirl calls.
2. Who is the big spoon/ Who is the little spoon? - Kara is big spoon for both of them. Lucy tries to the be the big spoon but it never lasts. Lena takes her turn every now and again.
3. Who hogs the cover/ Who loves to cuddle? - Kara and Lucy fight over the covers in their sleep. Kara could cuddle for years.
4. Who wakes the other one up with kisses? - This is Lena’s favorite thing.
5. Who usually has nightmares? - Kara has the worst ones. Lena comes second. Lucy isn’t really plagued with them; she’s the comfort.
6. Who would have really deep emotional thoughts at the middle of the night/ Who would have them in the middle of the day? - Lena but only because she stays up later than either of the other two.
7. Who sweats the small stuff? - Kara and Lena are a mess of nerves whenever anything happens. Lucy just shakes her head and takes care of it.
8. Who sleeps in their underwear (or naked)/ Who sleeps in their pajamas? - Lena sleeps in a shirt and underwear. Kara always has matching pajamas. Lucy could go to bed with anything on and it wouldn’t make a difference but the less the better. Kara’s a space heater anyway and a lot of times she has to shed whatever she’s wearing. Lena and Kara are never upset by waking up to that in the morning.
9. Who makes the coffee (or tea)? - If Lucy lets Lena make it, its bitter. If she let’s Kara make it it’s either full of sugar or from Noonan’s.
10. Who likes sweet/ Who likes sour? - Kara is full on sweet. The other two vary.
11. Who likes horror movies/ Who likes romance movies? - Lucy is all about the horror movie. Kara hides her face in a pillow for all but the first five minutes. Most of the time she coerces Lucy into switching movies. She’s all about the romance. Lena’s content with any movie as long as she’s laying between them.
12. Who is smol/ Who is tol? - Lucy is a smol with two tol girlfriends.
13. Who is considered the scaredy cat? - Lucy be damned if anything scares her.
14. Who kills the spiders? - Kara hates them. If there’s one on the floor, she leaps up, “Lucy! Get in here!” Lucy comes in to find her girlfriend hovering in midair, staring at a tiny, unmoving spider on the ground, with absolute terror in her eyes. Lena looks on amused, “You fight aliens everyday and -” Kara just shushes her and makes Lucy catch it and take it outside.
15. Who is scared of the dark? - They all find it pretty comforting.
16. Who is scared of thunderstorms? - None of them are very fond of them. Lucy’s seen one too many bombs go off to be fond of anything as loud. They sound much too like explosions for Kara as well. Lena’s not scared of them but she hates the way they make her girlfriends feel.
17. Who works/ Who stays at home? - They all workin’ ladies.
18. Who is a cat person/ Who is a dog person? - They pretty much all go for dogs but Lena wouldn’t mind a cat.
19. Who loves to call the other one cute names? - Lucy sometimes will use “babe” but other than that she just calls them by name. Kara uses their names. Lena is the one with a constant stream of endearments.
20. Who is dominant/ Who is submissive? - They all tend to go back and forth depending on the situation. Kara is the most likely to be dominant at the start.
21. Who has an obsession (over anything)? - Lucy and Lena have come to terms with being the second and third loves of Kara’s life. Food is first.
22. Who goes all out for Valentine’s Day? - Lena’s love language is very much gift giving so she tends to be the one to buy them things on any holiday actually. Kara likes the romance of it. Lucy couldn’t care less about Valentine’s Day but goes along with it because she adores her girlfriends.
23. Who asks who out on the first date? - Kara is oblivious to any form of flirting until someone points it out to her. Lena is too hesitant and thinks she’s overthinking relationship too often to take that step. Lucy wants to strangle them both.
24. Who is the talker/ Who is the listener? - Aside from Kara’s rambling, there is very open and healthy communication between the three of them.
25. Who wears the other one's clothes? - Lena and Lucy steal Kara’s shirts all the time. Sometimes Kara runs out of clothes so fast because there are three people wearing them.
26. Who likes to eat healthy/ Who loves junk food? - Lena is the healthiest of all of them but caves to anything Kara wants. Kara would just eat fried food and junk food if she could. Lucy tries to moderate both of them.
27. Who takes a long shower/ Who sings in the shower? - Kara sings...loudly. Lena hums sometimes and Kara and Lucy just look at each other and smile. She also takes forever. Lucy’s all about that 5 minute shower...unless someone decides to join her and then she has to be dragged out.
28. Who is the bookworm? - If Lena doesn’t go into work on a Saturday or Sunday and they didn’t make plans, she curls up in a chair and reads for hours.
29. Who is the better cook? - None of them can cook but at least Lucy can boil water without catching anything on fire.
30. Who likes long walks on the beach? - Kara. It reminds her of when she first came to Earth and lived with the Danvers. They had the beach right next to them.
31. Who is more affectionate? - Kara is very tactile.
32. Who likes to have really long (deep) conversation? - Surprisingly Lucy. Being raised by her father, though not all great or not all horrible, didn’t leave room for much talk about emotions. She was taught to just skirt around the rough bits. So being with two women who are extremely conscious of their own hearts and minds was new and they got past her walls until she wanted to tell them everything she ever feels. So she does.
33. Who would wear “not guilty” t-shirt/ Who would wear “sin” t-shirt? - Kara doesn’t get either. She gets one that says “Guilty” because Lucy has had to ask one too many times, “Hey, where did my leftovers go?” Lucy said Lena should wear the “not guilty” one because of that time that Lena went to prison. Lena glared at her and Lucy never brought it up again.
34. Who would wear “if lost return to…” t-shirt/ Who would wear “I am…” t-shirt? - Lena gets Kara and Lucy the “if lost return to...” shirts. Sometimes they act like children and she has to keep track of them somehow.
35. Who goes overboard on the holidays? - It’s like Kara sets off a holiday bomb in their apartment/house. With gift giving though, Lena because it’s her love language.
36. Who is the social media addict? - None of them are into it. (That’s specifically show universe. In my head, they’re all really annoying on Instagram.)
37. Height difference or age difference? - It’s sizeable. Kara picks Lucy up to kiss her just because she knows it annoys Lucy.
38. Who likes to stargaze? - Kara but ever since they started dating, Lucy and Lena join her.
39. Who buys cereal for the prize inside? - Lucy buys it. Kara gets the prize.
40. Who is the fun parent/ Who is the responsible parent? - Kara and Lena are so strung out about safety that it’s unbearable. Lucy plans motorcycle jaunts, “Obviously not until they’re out of booster seats and can sit on the bike themselves, I’m not crazy,” and Kara and Lena about lose their minds.
41. Who cries during sad movies? - They all do but Lucy would never admit it.
42. Who is the neat freak? - Lena isn’t necessarily a neat freak but Lucy and Kara have heard, “Orderly isn’t bad,” one too many times.
43. Who wins the stuffed animals at the carnival for the other one? - Kara tried once...she broke things. Lucy took over.
44. Who is active/ Who is lazy? - Not one of these women is lazy but Lena grumbles jealously about how Kara can lounge on the couch for days, stuffing her face with junk.
45. Who is more likely to get drunk? - Lena only because she drinks more than the other two combined. But with alien alcohol, it takes two seconds to get Kara tipsy.
46. Who has the longer food order? - There’s not even a question. Kara.
47. Who has the more complex coffee order? - Kara. Lena likes it black. Lucy likes it a little less black. And Kara puts so much cream and sugar in it that Lena doesn’t think it can be classified as coffee anymore.
48. Who loses stuff? - Lucy at work is on top of thing. Lucy at home can be holding a spoon and think all of the spoons in the house have disappeared.
49. Who is the driver/ Who is the passenger? - Lucy drives. Lena would rather have a driver. And as for Kara, “Why would anyone take a car if they could fly?”
50. Who is the hopeless romantic? - Kara. Lucy tried to explain that romcoms are not real life but that doesn’t mean Kara has stopped showing up with bouquets as big as herself. Lena has a vase set aside.
So do you think you could be convinced to do more Kara/Lena/Lucy headcannons? Pretty please? :)
Love you!! You never need to convince me to write for the ot3!! I always want to. the big reason I don’t is lack of inspiration so you can always ask for headcanons for a specific thing and that’d be great. For now I’m just gonna do headcanons about their dates I guess
So they have an official date night every Friday
Lena always has a new 5-star gourmet restaurant for them to try
Lucy’s kind of a shit and she always says they should go to this one restaurant she likes that puts a lot of spice and/or alcohol in all of their dishes (half because it makes Lena roll her eyes and its so cute)
And Lena is both amused and so done, like we can’t eat at the same place every week Lucy it’s good to expand horizons there’s more than one good restaurant in the world
In the end they’ll try Lena’s restaurant and then every few months go to Lucy’s, and none of them really mind
Kara is satisfied just to be with her girls and have food
But of course, Lena is the CEO of a billion dollar company, Kara is a superhero, and Lucy has a high position in a secret government agency, so their date plan falls through every other week
When that happens, they can still usually be home by 10 or 11 (usually), so they order a pizza or Chinese food or Italian (Lena’s absolute favorite) and curl up on the couch and make it their own restaurant
Its really sweet
Literally one time Alex wanted to check in after Kara stopped like 4 robberies in a row, and when she walked in, Lucy, Lena, and Kara were all asleep curled up together on the couch with the TV still on and food on the coffee table
(Alex got like ten pictures just because it was so adorable and also now she can tease Lucy about it at work)
Other than their weekly (but not really) date, they spend a lot of time together during the week
Lucy and Lena spend a lot of time at Kara’s place considering they both have apartments of their own
They’ll watch comedies together on Tuesday nights when Lena’s already having a rough week and watch the recaps of Kara’s saves on the news when Snapper’s being a dick and watch the trashy TV shows Lucy secretly loves for after particularly stressful close calls at the DEO
Or they’ll sit at the sparsely-used counter and talk for hours on any day their schedules permit
Kara is convinced that living room dance parties are good for the soul and, well, Lena and Lucy can’t argue
Basically they’ll take any chance to spend the night together, or any time together at all
-Prefers gummy vitamins over pill ones: Kara once didn’t realize they were vitamins and ate a whole jar as a snack
-Prefers pizza without the tomato sauce: Lena asked once and Kara stopped working for a whole ten minutes so she never asked again
-Cries at romantic comedies: Kara mostly. Lena tears up sometimes and Lucy sniffles and blames it on allergies that she doesn’t have
-Says “me” at literally everything: It’s more of Lucy and Kara pointing at different things, mostly dogs, and saying, “you,” to each other
-Is the most likely to have a weird knick knack hobby: Lena fucking Luthor
-Dips their fries in mayonnaise: According to Kara, Lucy is a monster
-Obsessively touches things: Kara but it’s only because she developed the habit when she was younger. Everything felt different when she first landed and it’s something that just stuck with her.
-Hoards books, 75% of which they’ve never even read: Lena “i’ll get to them eventually” Luthor as she adds to the pile of unread books. Eventually Lucy puts a stop to it and Lena’s excuse is “they make good table decorations”
-Likes flavored water over plain: None of them like it but Lucy always somehow buys it by accident thinking its regular water so Kara takes care of it...meaning she fills up water balloons with it and chucks them at Winn’s head when he’s least expecting it. There was recently a memo sent out to all DEO staff advising them that water balloons have been added to the list of banned items. Kara stomps in, “J’onn, we can carry around alien weapons the size of me but a water balloon is contraband?”
-Has to plan the next day’s outfit the night before: Lucy wears the same DEO uniform to work everyday. It takes Kara less than a minute in the morning thanks to superspeed. Lena on the other hand plans what she’s wearing for an entire week ahead of time.
-Matches their pillows, bedsheets, blankets, carpets, and drapes: Lena until Kara says it doesn’t look fun and Lena realizes it’s only because she’s never actually had a reason to decorate anything before so she just shrugs and let’s Kara go wild at Bed, Bath, and Beyond
-Color codes everything: There is no color coding when Kara’s around
-Takes punch buggy waaay too seriously: Kara. They changed the rules after she almost broke Lucy’s arm. But then she broke a hole in the roof of the car and they banned it altogether.
-Is more likely to get into a fist fight at Subway at 9:50pm: Lucy. “I don’t care that it’s almost closing time. I want my wheat bread.” Kara once had to catch her because she tried to jump over the counter, saying that she’d go make it herself. She may have been a little drunk that time.
-Has an embarrassing college story they’re way too proud of: Lucy and Lena give each other a knowing look and Kara decides she doesn’t want to hear either of them
-Would get a tattoo on a dare: Both Lena and Lucy but Lucy would be the one to always make that the dare
-Celebrates Halloween for all of October: Kara except she likes to make the joke that she celebrates Halloween all year round: “Get it guys, I wear a costume every day.”
-Has ended a friendship over Mario Kart: None of them but Winn stopped talking to Lucy for a few weeks when she owned his ass in front of everyone. “You said you’d never played before.” Lucy smirks, “I’m not sure those were my exact words.”
-Likes getting lost in the woods: Kara does it for solitude because that’s what she did in high school to calm down, but she never actually gets lost
-Is a horrific cook but denies it completely: None of them are great but unless Kara’s making pancakes, she stays away from the kitchen entirely
-Likes to prank their friends: Lucy. But Kara is usually the one getting pranked by their friends.
-Unironically loves Nickleback AND Smash Mouth: Kara listened to the Smash Mouth/Chainsmokers mashup for 13 hours one day
-Watches YouTube videos until 3am at least once a week: Kara watching animal videos
-Cries over viral animal videos: Kara at 2am when she can’t sleep. One time, Lucy threw her phone out the window
-Would kill a man over petty things: Lucy. She threatened the Subway employees over their bread selection
-Has seen the same movie over a dozen times: Kara and now Lucy and Lena because Kara makes them watch The Wizard of Oz at least once a week
-Can come up with amazing one-liners on the spot: It’s Lucy. Kara laughs, Lena groans because there are too many
-Is dangerously clumsy: Lucy and Lena are like, “You’re literally Supergirl???”
-Is surprisingly flexible: Lucy. She’s pretty sure Kara and Lena both drooled the first time they saw her doing yoga in the living room.
-Would propose first: Kara on accident
Hi! I was wondering, if you have time, could you do an headcannon for the ot3 about what its like when one of them get's hurt/is in danger?
hell yeah i can!!! so headcanons for being hurt (maybe ill do in danger another time, but i can do a lot on injuries)
Lena has a large, public company and a large, public presence too, so she gets attacked more often than she should. way more often
the only good part about this is whenever anything happens at L Corp or to Lena its all over the news and Kara and Lucy are down there in two minutes
When Lena get’s hurt it’s wild bc both Lucy and Kara are protective and worried for her but also they’re angry and want to fight whoever hurt her
They stay at Lena’s side to make sure she’s okay, but Lucy has the DEO searching for whoever attacked her and she looks like she’s gonna murder someone. By the next day new stations have gotten word that Supergirl lost it on the would-be assassin of Lena Luthor
and it’s bad for Kara’s reputation that they have to wait for the attacker to wake up from a coma to prosecute him, but she thinks its so worth it
Lucy will get hurt at DEO business sometimes. It’s battle wounds, nothing she hasn’t seen before
Lena gets scary in the ER, like even the one at the DEO she walks in and is completely in command asking the doctors what her status was even with rather limited medical experience. As if the doctors needed another reason not to screw up
Kara always feels really guilty, she works with the DEO so obviously she should have been on whatever mission it was to protect Lucy. Never mind that she has another job, or that Lucy can usually look out for herself.
They probably would go after the attacker but for the most part the DEO gets whatever hurt Lucy. One time Lucy shot something after it threw her ten feet it was amazing
but then Lucy trys to go back to work wayyyyy too early though. Like one time she got shot in the chest and she kept whining that Kara and Lena were smothering her and she was fine. Of course, when she tried to get up, she almost fainted
they lie on the bed and watch a lot of trashy shows with her while Lucy’s healing
Lastly, when Kara gets hurt its so scary
She’s an indestructible alien, so everybody freaks out when she’s hurt
Lena goes incredibly pale but she still glares at anyone who looks like they might be the slightest bit incompetent to the point where Hank sends her out of the room
Lucy paces a lot. Once the doctors are done, Lena holds Kara’s hand until she wakes up. Actually, both her and Lucy fall asleep at her bed side
Also, Lucy freaks out, she’s so angry. Alex and Hank have to talk her down from going out to kill the alien with nothing but her gun.
Honestly, Kara getting hurt is so exhausting for all of them, the worry the anger. It doesn’t happen often, so its so shocking
But whenever any of them get hurt there’s lots of cuddling afterwards, the silver lining!
ot3 please 4 the bug prompt !! (also i would die 4 u)
(i would die for you too big love xoxo)
Germaphobe wasn’t the right word for Lena. She was neat, she was tidy. Anybody who had grown up in her household would be (exhibit A: her. exhibit B: Lex). But she wasn’t a germaphobe. She was a professional. Lena just didn’t want to get sick. And yes, that meant she was aware of germs, cautious of germs. Still, not a germaphobe.
“Lena, I’m done puking, you don’t have to stand in the kitchen all day,” Lucy wasn’t one to get sick either. Yet, nothing lasts forever, especially health. She had spent the last 12 hours throwing up, and Kara and her alien immunity had been sitting besides her. Lena, on the other hand, had blown a kiss and left for work early, and had been standing fifteen feet away for the twenty minutes she’d been home. “I’m fine, I won’t get you sick.”
As if the universe was laughing at her words, Lucy burst into a coughing fit, gagging a little while Kara rubbed her back.
“Well, you’re absolutely right,” Lena let a little smugness into her voice, and she could imagine Lucy pouting on the other side of the wall.
Kara’s voice was sweet, not at all bothered by their teasing, “Lena, you can stay out there, but will you at least make soup?”
“Of course, Kara.”
“But don’t actually make it from scratch, that’ll just make me sicker,” Lucy chimed in, followed by more coughs.
Despite the soft teasing, concern slipped into Lena’s voice, “Are you okay?” She took a few steps towards the open door to the bedroom, sending an encouraging smile to the women inside.
“I’ll live,” Lucy smiled back.
“To do that, you’ll need some more water,” Kara pointed out. She kissed Lucy on the cheek, then grabbed the empty glass besides the bed. “Be right back.”
Kara was smiling as she approached the door, then stepping into the kitchen, holding her free hand out to take one of Lena’s. The brunette, however, stepped back.
“Wash your hands. Just because you can’t be sick doesn’t mean you can’t carry germs.”
Giggling, Kara made a show of washing her hands, making direct eye contact with Lena while Lucy called, “Germaphobe” weakly from the other room.
Long fingers sparkling with water, Kara held out her hands, “Clean enough?”
Lena answered by taking both of them in her own and kissing Kara softly on the lips, “Good to see you.”
More giggling, and that stunning Kara Danvers smile, “You too. How was your day?”
“Better, now that I’m here with you and Lucy.”
“Good.”
The word was definite. Beautiful. So simple, but it sounded like love and acceptance and safety. It sounded like coming home, which Lena supposed she just had. But for once in her life home was more than the place she was living. Home was people who loved her and were there for her and put all they’re feelings into short, basic words.
And on that note, Lucy threw up again from across the apartment.
Both of the other women crossed into the bathroom, where Lucy was on the floor in front of the toilet. “I hate being sick.”
Still buzzing from the rush of feeling from moments before, Lena knelt down and wrapped her arms around Lucy’s waste, resting her head on her shoulder, “I’m sorry, Luce.”
She sighed contently, then said, “Aren’t you afraid you’ll get sick?”
But by then, Kara had sat down beside them and taken their hands in her own. And Lena thought that if she got sick tomorrow, it would be worth it for this moment.
That was sappy. So she didn’t say that. Instead, Lena smiled, “L-Corp will survive without me, I’m sure.”
—
It took two days for Lucy’s bug to really breakdown Lena’s system. And she had forgotten how much she hated throwing up.
“I hate you, Lane,” Lena’s voice was embarrassingly hoarse and weak.
