In an alternate universe where Supergirl landed on HBO instead of the CW, they’re allowed one (1) threesome scene. Who’s in it?
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Sam Arias
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Andrea Rojas
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Lucy Lane
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Red Daughter
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Imra Ardeen
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Nia Nal
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Kate Kane
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Metallo Lena
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, James Olsen
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Roulette
Kara Danvers, Lena Luthor, Reign (requested by a mutual 😉)
Lena Luthor, Sam Arias, Andrea Rojas
Voting ended onJun 29, 2024
Supercorp and other couples, respectively, could (but are not required to) have multiple love scenes throughout the course of the show. This is a one off and it does not become a throuple situation.
Lena/Andrea/Sam. Sam moves back and her and Andrea start to “compete” for Lena and her love. But it turns into them all being together. Just something that starts out rocky but turns sweet in the end
When Sam returns to National City with her daughter, she expects things to be exactly the way she left them– without the Worldkiller flavor-shot. She expects a welcoming party, which she receives in the form of Lena and their friends waiting at baggage claim with a large Welcome Home sign between them. She expects L-Corp to be steadfast and steady– which of course it is.
Most importantly of all, however, she expects to have Lena largely to herself.
This, she rudely finds, does not go entirely to plan.
Oh, she has time with Lena, deepened by their shared experience of fighting Reign and loving Ruby. But unlike before, where Sam could walk into Lena’s office and expect an immediate acceptance of an impromptu lunch or movie night with Ruby, Sam now faces a fifty-fifty chance that Lena will respond with an apology.
“Sorry, but I already have plans with Andrea.”
Andrea.
The woman plagues what time Lena does allow her. Andrea said this, Andrea did that. It rankles Sam in a way nothing ever has before.
Oh, she knows about Andrea. Lena told her all about what happened between her and her childhood friend. She’d even heard the bitterness of a hidden crush brutally devastated by betrayal.
So why, Sam wonders, does Lena devote so much of her time to the woman now?
“I know,” Lena says when Sam gently reminds her to protect her heart. “But I’m learning forgiveness. And I can’t do that until I try.”
Sam’s heart swells at that, to hear that her friend is finally examining the trauma that had resulted in Lena’s one-strike policy in all things.
So Sam endures the thwarted plans and frequent mentions of Andrea Rojas. She even manages to keep her smile in place when they finally meet at one of Kara’s infamous game nights (and if she claims Lena as a partner a little too aggressively, well… she isn’t ashamed of it). But even so a dark seed of jealousy swells and grows with every mention of CatCo’s owner.
What’s even worse is that despite her careful smiles, her displeasure doesn’t go unnoticed. Once, when she pauses her listening to Lena’s story about Kara and some sort of puppy on the street, her carefully concealed scowl is caught by Rojas herself, whose gaze happens to land on hers at the exact moment Sam looks over. And then, to twist the knife, the woman has the nerve to grin. No, not grin.
Smirk.
That does it. That night, Sam goes uninvited to Lena’s building to talk. To give her best friend a piece of her mind, to confess her distaste for Andrea, to address her misgivings that Lena has allowed such a toxic person back into her life. (A fact Sam knows to be based on actions committed almost a decade ago, but a fact that she has no intention of mentioning to Lena tonight.)
But even now, the universe conspires against her, for who does she run into in the small foyer between the elevator and Lena’s door but the she-devil herself.
“Miss Arias,” Andrea greets, still with that same damn smirk.
“Rojas,” Sam returns, taking special care to roll the ‘r’ like it’s a curse.
“What brings you here at this hour?” Andrea asks, slipping seamlessly into her native Spanish.
Sam’s eyebrow lifts, not unlike Lena’s when she wants to make someone feel small.
“I might ask you the same thing,” she responds, just as silkily, the Spanish sliding off her tongue like butter.
Andrea smirks again. “Same as you, I imagine. Visiting a friend.”
The damned woman’s smile shifts, emulating a cheshire who’s stumbled across a secret. Or spawned one of her own.
Jealousy once again flares low in Sam’s belly.
“Yeah,” she snips. “About that–”
The door before them opens then, revealing a visibly unimpressed Lena Luthor.
“I can hear you,” she declares, joining in on their spanish with nary a wayward accent. She glares at them sternly, long enough for Sam to shift guiltily in place. Andrea, on the other hand, remains unrepentant.
In the end, Lena sighs. “If you’re going to argue, at least do it inside and not on my doorstep.”
She steps aside to admit them. Sam makes sure she’s the first one to shoulder her way through, but as she sheds her blazer Andrea comes in behind her to to gracefully step towards Lena and greet her with a kiss to the cheek.
“Mi amor,” rumbles from the woman’s throat, a purr if Sam ever heard one.
Lena scowls. “Stop teasing,” she orders her friend. She gives them both a stern glare. “Living room. Now.”
They obey without a word. When Sam moves to take the armchair furthest from Andrea’s seat on the loveseat, Lena tsks.
“Couch, both of you.”
Again they obey. Sam does her best to avoid Andrea’s gaze, lest she say something they’d all regret. Lena stands in front of them, arms folded across her chest.
“Sam– do you think I haven’t seen the way your cheeks flush when I mention Andrea?”
Sam has no words, but feels more than sees Andrea regard her with a self-satisfied smirk. But Lena isn’t one to let anyone off the hook.
“And you,” she chides Andrea. “Don’t think I haven’t seen you trying to get a rise out of her.”
Only then does Andrea have the decency to look mildly chagrined. Lena pointedly holds their gazes.
“You are two of my best friends,” she declares. “And I will not have you at each other’s throats.”
Silence stretches between the three of them for a long moment, before Lena softens. To Sam’s surprise, Lena smoothly kneels before them, taking one of their hands in each of hers.
“That said,” she continues, her voice now soft, nearly a purr of its own, “I think I know the source of the tension between us– and I’m sure we can find a solution that meets each of our satisfaction.”
And just like that, the knot of jealousy in Sam’s belly releases into a flood of warmth that spills downwards to pool between Sam’s legs. She knows her cheeks burn, but she can find no words to save face.
Andrea, for her part, hardly seems ruffled. She extends one finger to tap under Lena’s chin, tilting her face up to kiss her sweetly. “I thought you’d never ask.”
They turn to Sam, who stares back at them, drinking in the sight of Lena on her knees, gazing softly up at her with Andrea’s hand gently stroking her hair. She takes a deep breath, and when she exhales, she releases her embarrassment for have been seen through to clearly, her irritation that Andrea had seemed to be on Lena’s page all along, her frustration that once again Andrea fucking Rojas has beaten her to the punch.
Empty of all that, curiosity and arousal rushes in to fill the vacuum.
Donning a smirk of her own, Sam relaxes. She even lets her legs spread ever so slightly, allowing her thigh to bump against Andrea’s, so close are they sitting. With a cool and confident tilt of her chin, Sam retakes control.
This whole question thing reminded me of my idea I'll never write. So I started making notes. So I won't forget that idea I'll never write. Anyway, do you got any answers for Sam/Andrea/Lena? Whichever question you want, I'm too lazy to actually go back and read them. If you don't feel like thinking of a question... SFW 7. Which exists and of that I am sure. :)
OKAY Andrea x Sam x Lena headcanons. I did all SFW ones but let me know if you want a NSFW one.
1.Who cooks?
Andrea loves to cook but she does t have time to do it as often as shed like. when she does its a full on feast like coulda had 3 more ppl over. Pulled pork, salsa picante, pickled vegetables, empanadas, sirloin steak when she feels like sharing home and shes also real into italian cooking. Sam picks up easier meals more frequently. But come on really if these three are living together theres a personal chef involved. And yes I am available for hire.
2 Who's the messiest? The cleanest?
Oooo interesting Im gonna go ahead and say Lena’s the messiest. I mean that girls life is HECTIC. The others are just as busy but they know how to delegate. The kinda messy we’re taking about is adhd messy here so she just doesnt see the mess. Shell have the intention of putting something away but gets distracted. Also, when she puts things away she then cant find them so whats the point? Shes gonna need it again soon anyways. Andrea’s the cleanest, she mighta been a rich kid but she was still expected to keep her own room clean and it stuck. Sam picks up after Lena so Andrea doesn't get mad.
4.Living space has a leak! Who fixes it?
They live in the riciest richest situation so a repair person is always like 2 seconds away. Sam’s the one calling and mitigating the situation
6. Going out to eat: Who pays? Who orders the
most food? And who has dessert?
Andrea. Andrea. Andrea. She absolutely loves spoiling her girls.
7. Would they go to the beach?
This isnt a common occurrence. If its in National City Ruby is the reason they go (lenas not the biggest fan but shed do anything for Ruby). Fancy vacations are a whole diff story that everyone enjoys and looks forward to.
12. Can they stand silence? Who talks the most?
Who talks the least?
Lena loves silence! Andrea loves giving the silent treatment. And Sam wishes she could just get one moment of silence please??? Andrea talks the most hands down. Lena talks the least.
Listen...I love Sam Arias. I LOVE her. A whole freaking lot. She just checks so many boxes. Beautiful/sexy/legs for days/looks good in suits/congrats on the hair/face/neck? Intelligent? Successful? Is a good mom and loves her daughter more than anything? Dorky pancake o clock side? Good bean? Great dynamics with Lena, Alex and Kara? “I’m like Supergirl” reaction to finding out she has powers? No comp het hell? Best redemption arc on this show/in the Arrowverse? Need I say more?
She also strikes this balance for me of having so much in canon to adore about her but also enough room to fill in the blanks and be versatile with her in fanon that it doesn’t feel entirely ooc...which is awesome for an aspiring storyteller.
All the people I ship with this character
Oh god this is such a call out to my multishipping ways. First of all, Alex Danvers is her wife. She & Lena fuuuuuuucked in Metropolis. I am currently obsessed with idea of her angry hate-sex dynamic with Andrea (that may or may not feature them cursing at each other in Spanish, both when Lena wants them to play nice but they don’t want to so they switch to sniping in Spanish because Lena was forced to take Latin but ESPECIALLY in the bedroom) and it’s all @stennnn06’s fault (thank you Sten 😉.)
I headcanon that Sam knew she was a lesbian in her early teens. Her sleeping with a guy and conceiving Ruby was more about her being in denial about her feelings for her best friend at the time/desperately trying to conform to heteronormativity (because peer pressure) while at the same time rebelling against her mother. I mention this because I created an OC that was Sam’s best friend whom she loved in high school. She finds out post Ruby’s birth that her friend liked her back and they at least kiss one time (maybe they hook up, maybe not) because they’re both really young, going in different directions and weren’t ready for the long haul (or u-haul, as the case may be.)
Its also amusing to think of Sam having a fling with Lucy in the land of forgotten characters after season 3. I like the idea of her and Kelly too. They’re both beautiful, I think they’d get along and I like tall/smol dynamics. Sam/Alex/Kelly and Sam/Alex/Lena are OT3s and Sam/Lena/Andrea is just delicious. Wasn’t a fan of Sam/Kara until I read that one fic where Kara works at the juice bar at Sam’s new gym.
And last but certainly not least (as if they even were a least with Handsome Sam), if I’m not the founder of the S.S. Wonderreign, I’m definitely one of its first and largest supporters. Swords and beautiful women, amirite? But also the idea of Sam recovering on Themyscira post-Reign and Diana believing in San and helping her heal in more ways than one is something I’ve wanted for over two years now.
My non-romantic OTP for this character
Jack Spheer. You know they knew each other in Metropolis through Lena and even if there may have been some competition for her affections a long time ago, they’d strike up a bond all their own. Also Kara in non-juice bar AU settings...they were both adopted! and super! And they never talked about it! Gah!
My unpopular opinion about this character
Message me if you want to know who Ruby’s father is in my crack AU. Also, I like Rojascorp and it think it is more popular at the moment but I personally still prefer Reigncorp (I know, I know...why not both and you’re right but still...I’m hard pressed for an unpopular opinion on Sam. Most of her fans are on the same page about her.)
One thing I wish would happen / had happened with this character in canon.
Her marrying Alex. Or confirmation of past Reigncorp. In either event she kept her freaking powers and Lena made her a better version of the big lesbian Reign sword that she uses when she’s Superwoman, but she’s only Superwoman reluctantly. She doesn’t do it every night like Kara because she has Ruby but she will help when she’s needed.
GIVE ME A CHARACTER and I’ll break their ass down!
