Book Review — “The Witches: Suspicion, Betrayal, and Hysteria in 1692 Salem” by Stacy Schiff (2016, @hachetteus)
Categories: Nonfiction, US History, 17th Century, Puritanism, Witches and Witch-hunts
Ratings: 3.25 on GR (20k ratings), my rating 3 stars ✨
Presented by a Pulitzer Prize-winning author, this book is a lengthy exposition of what scholars and historians know and theorize about the infamous Salem Witch Trials of the 1690s.
In the colonial Massachusetts lands, the witch trials resulted from a town’s mass hysteria involving people claiming possession by devil or knowledge of those working with demonic forces. Puritan sensibilities made this accusation detrimental to one’s reputation… and eventually, their lives and freedom.
Topics this book substantially covers:
• Salem: what was the town like?
• Church + Religion: What was its importance in Salem and how did town politics get involved in the church?
• Members of Community: Relevant people such as prominent families, those afflicted with bewitching, those accused of witchcraft, the authorities + ministers, skeptics.
• The Bewitching: How the first young girls acted and theories held by community, Tituba’s involvement, getting info about the accused from known people to strangers from afar
• Accused: interrogators/investigators, jailing and its conditions, trial and jurors + accusations & defenses
• Symbols: Things the puritans described as signs of guilt or trouble, including their elaborate stories of the accused’s antics and seeing black cats, red books, brooms, different types of animals, etc.
• Hysteria & Sociology: the social contagion + mass hysteria of the witch-hunt and high profile cases. Some theories on why this happened.
And much more. The book fills in gaps and bridges material with details contextualizing the trials. Anything from pointing out influences of feuding families to describing PTSD from Indian attacks, the book provides some padding to the sources. At some points, it’s a bit of a slog because it takes a lot of winding away from the point it’s making, but in all, a decent collection of info presented in a narrative style.
Goodreads Page: www.goodreads.com/book/show/24819449-the-witches
Bookstagram Post: A Home Library 🌸 #Bookstagram (@ahomelibrary) • Instagram photos and videos