We should be meaner to atheist and pagans who claim that women who were killed during the witch trial were actual witches
Deeply devout christian women who practised medicine that was accessible to their communities, disabled women, what we maybe would call queer in our own context , poor women, deeply devout Christians who under torture refused to recant their faith should not be reinterpreted as witches.
It is an insult to their memory, and we are once again , listening to the men that prosecuted them over their own voices in what they should be called.
This is not apologetics for Christianity or the witch trials. it's just as bad as retroactively baptising people. we are once again removing the autonomy of these women , not listening to them in their own words and deciding that we know their real secret identities despite all of their public proclamation of their devout faith.