can you make headcannons of jotaro dating the reader who is a mermaid and the crusaders reaction when they find out she is a mermaid please?
A/N: oooo, ya really wanted to make me think a lot!!!! uhhh i really hope this is alright! i was kind of stumped for a bit, i never really considered a relationship between a human and a mermaid except for like... The Little Mermaid, aha..... i made this as gender-neutral as i could, by the way!
Jotaro w/ a Mermaid S/O + Crusaders’ Reactions
Jotaro is… quite a stoic man.
But, he would probably freak out when he found an actual, real life mermaid!
He would go to see them whenever he could and pretend it was to study marine biology. In a way, that’s kind of true…
He asks them a lot of questions, though he’s pretty bad with how he words them sometimes. He’s just excited to actually talk to a mermaid…
He really likes their tail and fins!! They’re beautiful to him and he would love to run his hands over their scales if it was okay.
Would definitely not confess to them since he would feel slightly guilty for liking a non-human creature, but he wouldn’t say no if they confessed to him
As soon as they convince him to date them, they would probably take him on an underwater adventure! They would need to pay close attention to how much oxygen he needs, so they would always have a hold of him as they lead him around the ocean to see several species of fish.
The relationship might be a bit difficult, considering Jotaro has to live on land, and he wouldn’t want to restrain them… It’s likely he would live in a house right on the oceanside, so he could see them all the time and also not keep them anchored to him.
There probably wouldn’t be constant physical contact, but that’s alright with him! He’s not always the most physical person, so he wouldn’t mind it at all.
But of course, he would have to tell the Crusaders eventually…
Kakyoin seems surprised to hear about Jotaro dating someone. And when Jotaro introduces him to them, he seems even more surprised.
“A… mermaid? Jotaro, you’re dating a mermaid?”
He’s supportive of it as soon as he wraps his head around the idea of human/mermaid relationships!
Avdol is confused by the whole situation. Certainly, Jotaro doesn’t mean he’s dating the mermaid in the water…?
Once Jotaro explains that yes, he’s dating the mermaid in the water, Avdol hums to himself and nods, moving to ask the mermaid a few questions. He’s not upset or interrogating, he’s simply curious and wants to make sure this mermaid won’t hurt Jotaro. He figures he owes at least that much to Joseph.
Speaking of… Joseph is ecstatic. He’s so happy that his grandson found someone!! He would demand to meet them immediately, and when he met them… oh boy.
He would be through the roof, making suave compliments (to Jotaro’s embarrassment) and making sure this mermaid is safe enough for Jotaro. He’s glad Jotaro found someone, but he doesn’t want Jotaro to get hurt.
Polnareff freaks out when Jotaro mentions his s/o! He immediately wants to meet them!
He also makes suave compliments, borderline flirting with them (which kind of makes Jotaro angry) and then telling them all about how Jotaro is and how his life has gone, including each embarrassing moment possible!