Agatha x Rio x non-binary Reader
Part 7 | Keep It Down, Down
Part 1 | Wanna Join, Rock’n’rolla
Part 2 | I Said Now
Part 3 | Fuck Like a Witch
Part 4 | Coven Three
Part 5 | Mommy, We're Fucked
Part 6 | Sorry, Daddy
Word count: 2.4k
Warnings: NSFW 18+ smut! Mommy, Daddy kink, public sex, fingering, oral, breast play, dominance, submission, pet names, dirty talk
***
When you came into the bedroom after quite a long shower (to digest the hell of a Friday night) the women were already sleeping enveloping each other in a warm cute hug, Rio’s hand gently covering Agatha’s waist as if to reach her breast. You lingered for a little, just to picture this moment and smiled to yourself; it was rare, when you saw them both like that, embracing like two teenagers on a sleepover, so cute and tender and even fragile. Their aftercare was a different kind of a facet, and in contrast to their rather rough sex and dirty banter, it felt like something magical and charming—their little secret they wouldn’t share in a daylight.
You dimmed the lamp on a drawer and covered yourself in a blanket beside them, just a few minutes to read a book until you drifted off and fell asleep completely.
***
‘Y/N…’
You made a huge effort to open your eyes with a groggy feeling, trying to shake off the sleepiness, and saw Agatha’s features in a vague morning blur.
‘Gods, what time is it?’
‘You’re late for breakfast time,’ she chuckled, ‘get up, get up, Rio’s at home just for the weekend, we don’t want to waste time, do we?’
‘Okay, Mommy, give me five—’
‘It wasn’t a question, hon,’ she said sternly, yet such a careful phrase as that immediately gave you warm shivers. You suddenly remembered the other night, your unexpected revelation and their even more unexpected response.
No way they really love me back. Well, your heart knew that, but your mind denied owning up to it so easily.
Agatha pulled the blanket down and tickled your exposed side.
‘Don’t test me, pet,’ she warned you once more time before leaving the bedroom.
‘Oh what? You will turn me into a toad?’ Oops, maybe it was too much. You propped yourself up on an elbow and gave her a quirky smile. Agatha looked puzzled but said nothing; she merely raised an eyebrow and swished the hem of her purple house robe, disappearing down the hallway.
***
Rio was super excited, looking for a places to visit and things to do in the city—she wanted to eat it all. What a child she was sometimes, taking a break from bossing around and making everyone feel somewhat uneasy.
‘Uh, how about that new Japanese place?’
‘You’ve just had breakfast, love,’ Agatha sighed; she looked a little bit annoyed, not to put too fine a point on it.
‘I’m still hungry! And we could go to the planetarium right afterward..... о! I definitely need new clothes, and I want you both to chaperone me. And the guys said there's a party tonight, so we could—’
‘For fuck’s sake, Rio! Knock it off and choose something,’ Agatha rolled her eyes leaning back in the chair with her legs straddled. Rio pouted her lips mockingly and raised her middle finger at her. Agatha grumbled, but somehow she seemed softer than usual. Maybe she was still guilt-tripped for Rio or just really missed her and didn’t want her to leave on tour again.
The women looked adorable though, and you couldn’t help yourself but silently laughed.
‘Our pet refuses to behave today.’
‘We’ll deal with this later, baby,’ Rio muttered not taking her eyes off her phone, managing her instagram and at the same time checking out her saved places to go.
‘God, I’m married to a blogger!!’ the woman let out an evil growl and threw her head back in despair.
‘Not my fault I'm a celebrity here,’ Rio smirked as she glanced at her wife, ‘by the way, I'm done now, so let's fucking go!’
Lee was already outside, waiting for you beside purple Mercedes and smoking. She hid the cigarette the second she saw the three of you leaving the house.
‘Sorry ma’am,’ she mumbled awkwardly but she still had those familiar metallic notes in her voice.
‘Why is everybody against me today…’ Agatha sighed, almost loosing her temper this time. So weird, last time you checked, she wasn't exactly anti-smoking, something in her behaviour was fluctuating and odd.
‘No big deal, Lee,’ Rio winked at her, ‘hey oh, let’s go, take us to Moonlight.’ Saying that she landed to the front seat in one motion and gave Lee the planetarium address.
When you and Agatha finally settled into the back seat, you sensed something different about her again and risked reaching out to her through telepathy.
Mommy, you’re alright?
Nothing to worry about
Tell me, I can feel it
Mind your own business, pet
That cold phrase hit you like a sharp blade right in the heart and you were ready to burst into tears at any second. What the fuck is happening, she’d never been so cruel with you before.
Rio was distracted, rambling something to Lee, but you heard nothing, you were dissociated, so hopeless and angry at the same time.
'Y/N? Why such a long face? The green witch turned around and noticed your sad, miserable expression. When she reached over to stroke your knee, you couldn't hold back any longer and shed a tear looking sideways.
‘I think I can guess what’s happening here,’ Rio glanced at Agatha furrowing her eyebrows. ‘You’re such a drama queen, sweetheart,’ she rebuked her wife, ‘nobody’s gonna harm you if you let them get close to you once in a blue moon. Just don’t hurt Y/N, okay?’
Agatha shrugged as if nothing happened but turned her head the other way.
‘You guys should see each other right now,’ Rio smirked, ‘Jesus, come on, Ebenezer Scrooge!’
‘Whatever she said, don’t take it seriously, kiddo,’ she patted your knee again, ‘Agatha can be moody sometimes, but don’t worry, nothing’s changed.’ Rio reached out her palm and poked a manicured finger at the tip of your nose; then she flicked her hand and a beautiful red flower appeared out of thin air. ‘This is for you, little hag.’
She really knew how to put in effort when it came to relationships and now that there were three of you, Rio took it seriously and was willing to teach you both good manners or cheer you up at times like this. Agatha had a temper, that wasn't news and now you could see that she was struggling a great deal with being so vulnerable, realizing that you knew that she loved you and had let you into her family that she had been building for ages. Yes, everything was new for her, but it was very unusual for you as well, and you deserved some respect.
Y/N
She reached your mind.
Pet
…
Honey
…
I didn’t mean to hurt you
Agatha was no good at saying the s-word, and yesterday was definitely an exception, but you were waiting for her to say it since you were stubborn and resentful. But the moment you felt her fingers gently stroking the palm of your hand, you couldn’t resist it and hold a grudge any longer; your cheeks immediately flushed and finally you gave her a smile of forgiveness.
‘That’s better,’ Rio sighed in satisfaction and turned the music louder, singing along to it.
You'll never get away from the sound of the woman that loves you…
***
Moonlight was fantastic. You never had a chance to visit it and you were amazed when you saw this show for the first time—there was a huge projection of the galaxy on the surface of the whole dome and you could not acknowledge this bewildering universe and experienced what they usually call Stendhal's syndrome.
‘Did you know that we see the light of stars that no longer exist? It’s like seeing through the past…’ you said, staring at the ceiling.
‘You’re poetic, baby,’ Rio said and put her head on your shoulder, ‘it’s cute.’
It was so romantic that you were afraid of spoiling the moment and tried to breathe lightly. Still, you were curious about their witchy stuff, and had no choice but to ask them all about it.
‘You must know everything about the stars and magical matters, don’t you?’
‘We surely do. Agatha, though, is more skilled in star magic than I am. Right, baby?’
‘Oh yeah, and I did a great job discovering this particular star…hot stuff,’ she husked the last part of the phrase in your ear, sending a new wave of sweet goosebumps down your spine. Damn, it was never enough.
‘As I said, baby, you’re more skillful,’ Rio smirked at her wife and caressed your thigh, running her fingers down to your knee and then back, higher, higher.... You jerked instinctively and spread your legs.
Meanwhile, Agatha pressed herself against you and squeezed your other thigh. Gods and heavens, you were frenzied by their touch, still looking up at the stars, at the infinite universe, drowning in it with your favorite witches. There was nothing greater than being touched by these women, melting and giving yourself to them without a trace. Every time with them felt like the first time. Every fucking time.
Just when Agatha was about to unzip your jeans, you were startled and looked around anxiously. You couldn't see a soul in the darkness, but you were sure you weren't alone in this theater room.
‘What if we get caught, Mommy,’ you sighed, but showed no signs of resistance.
‘You want us to stop, honey?’ Agatha asked in a seducing manner, slowly tracing a line from your neck to the zipper with her finger, ‘we can stop.’
‘Fuck…’ you moaned and moved your head to kiss the woman. She eagerly responded, fucking you with her beautiful, luscious lips; and that kiss sent you straight to another dangersome galaxy.
‘I thought so,’ she chuckled parting from a kiss, brushing your mouth with her rich lower lip, her hand slowly unzipping your pants.
You arched your back and let out another moan when Rio slid her hand under your hoodie and reached for your tit, massaging it gently, giving your nipple soft barely palpable strokes.
‘Rio, don’t stop, please…’
‘Come to Daddy, little slut,’ she whispered and kissed your neck.
They gotta hand it to you, you were making an effort to be quiet, but now were embarrassingly failing.
You gave Rio a fiery, passionate kiss and moaned in her face. Daddy loved to bite, and when she suddenly bit the tip of your tongue, you shrieked shortly.
‘Hush!’ ordered Agatha, shifting your panties aside and covering your pussy with her fingers, pressing them against your clit. ‘Keep it down, down.’
You were squirming and biting your lips in agony, but without a doubt you enjoyed the torture, you could have suffered like this forever, and you no longer cared if people saw you at that moment.
‘Don’t rush, Aggie, we still have work to do,’ Rio husked and squeezed your nipple hinting for Agatha to join her. The woman loved the idea and grasped your other breast while moving her tongue along your neck, giving it warm kisses. You fell into the void, trembling and panting, stroking their hair and kissing their faces until they were so close that you could kiss all together. You seemed to dissolve and merge into one, all three of you.
In a while, witches parted, smiled to each other and collapsed into a kiss, but this time you could just watch them and wait for their next move. They didn't break the kiss, but their hands moved and switched places; you felt their intertwined fingers stroking your tits again and again, playfully squeezing and stretching them in the most tantalizing way.
Agatha’s voice reverberated in your head.
Our favorite toy, my sexy, handsome rock’n’rolla
Say that you love me, Mommy
You already know too much
Please
‘Long for us to fuck you, huh?’ Agatha husked to your ear.
‘Yes…’
‘Can you handle it, baby whore?’
‘Oh Daddy…’
‘Good,’ Rio smirked and pulled down your jeans, while Agatha set you free from your ruined panties. Things got serious.
‘Spread your legs,’ Agatha brushed her lips against your ear again, ‘wider, we need more room.’ You obeyed her command and slid down in the chair.
‘And keep it quiet, or you’ll be punished,’ Rio murmured, shoving her fingers inside you very slowly.
Agatha was taking care of your swollen clit and they both were fucking you inside out in perfect harmony; you took a deep breath and held it, feeling the rising tide of your orgasm getting stronger, ready to hit you anytime now. They sensed it and paused for a moment.
‘Mind you, if you even make a tiny peep, you won’t get fucked for a month,’ Rio gasped rather strictly with a spark in her crazy, devious gaze.
‘Nod if you understand.’ You nodded, taking another deep breath; sweat covering your whole body.
‘It goes for touching yourself, too,’ Agatha hissed from the other side, tenaciously flickering your clit with her fingers.
You nodded again. So helpless, unable to control your own cumming, you were pulled at Agatha and kissed her hard, as if begging to silence you with her lips.
‘Keep. It. Quiet.’ Agatha said crisply, honing every word. Rio was watching you close from the other side; her hand fucking you harder, deepening in your soaked cunt.
The moment Agatha covered your mouth with her kiss, you arched your back and jerked in the chair, cumming silently, following their rules. You just simply couldn't disobey Mommy and Daddy. You wanted to be a good pet and be praised, lavished with their generous fucking.
‘I missed fucking you, my baby hag,’ the green witch pulled herself closer to you, waiting for her turn to kiss you. ‘You're doing great, superstar, Daddy is so proud of you.’ Her warm breath caressed the skin of your cheek, and suddenly she bit it shallowly.
‘Oh, Daddy…you always fuck me so good,’ you gasped running your fingers through her hair.
‘Shh, we're not done here yet,’ Rio covered your lips with her finger. ‘Let Mommy eat you before we go, okay? I don't want to completely ruin your pants. We're decent people, after all.’
With that said, she tilted her head as if to tell Agatha to get on her knees and suck your wetness. You leaned back in anticipation and at last, felt Agatha's warm tongue coating your drenched pussy.
You’re unapologetically skillful, Mommy
You’re unapologetically wet
The stars above you were forming beautiful constellations as you basked in pleasure and felt absolutely surreal.
***
