I DO think that out of the all of them Hen is the one most likely to get stuck in a time loop because she gets to try everything over and over again until it’s perfect, not in a traumatic way, just because her ideal life is solving every problem ever with no help and I think that’s beautiful. Don’t look behind the curtain.
Like Buck and Eddie would get stuck in a time loop because they’re trying to find the one thing that lets them out of it without learning the lesson the loop is trying to force them to learn, yanno? And Buck would eventually learn it, but Eddie would rather be stuck forever than experience a meaningful change to his worldview. He gets out after having the world’s second worst breakdown.
Chimney is out after like a week though, he’s genre savvy and reads the universe like a book. And by god is he good at learning lessons. #1 student of life. I think he would intentionally stay in the loop for a while because he IS a huge nerd and it’s cool af, but unlike the rest of the team he does not experience the I Have To Fix It/Control It mentality (again, as a person who learns and internalizes life lessons), so he gets bored and figures it out.
I think Maddie deserves to scooby doo her way out of a time loop. No trauma just get the gang together and solve a mystery. Free my girl.
S1 Bobby would not leave the loop as a form of punishment, s2-6 bobby would not get stuck in a time loop. S7-8 bobby is actually in the loop right now and this is how alobby can still wi-
Athena would strong arm her way out of time loop. I fully believe that she would just shoot the time loop dead. Like Eddie, she takes a ‘I am not fucking learning that lesson’ approach to life, but unlike eddie she would not have a mental breakdown about it. Like she’s stuck until she can figure out how to murder a metaphysical life lesson mechanic but she’ll do it.