Since pure vanilla obviously loves white lily, I feel like he would (unknowingly maybe) start neglecting y/n if he were with them. So, what about PV with a reader that would leave him in a heartbeat if timekeeper (definitely not picking her just because she's my favorite) or shadow milk showed romantic interest in them?
Things had been tense for a while in your relationship with Pure Vanilla...but the tension only grew once White Lily returned. It was hard to not see the way he looked at her, gaze full of longing and love...
You knew he cared about you, but it was clear that he loved her more. Even if he didn't say anything aloud...not even to you.
He didn't mean to neglect you, and you knew it...but there was so much on his mind that he barely seemed to be able to pay mind to you. Still, you waited...wanting to see if there was perhaps a way to fix your relationship.
That was, until...you met a Cookie who looked at you with the same fierce love he directed at White Lily.
Shadow Milk
Shadow Milk had been planning for a while to drive a wedge in your relationship with Pure Vanilla...he deserves to have his heart broken, after all!
Seeing the tension created by White Lily's awakening makes for some delicious drama, too...he can't help but laugh at how Pure Vanilla is ruining his own relationships, slowly poisoning it without him even having to lift a finger!
But...the thought of you being overlooked, replaced by some other Cookie who is just deemed to be "better" in the eyes of the one you care about, gives him...an uncomfortable feeling. Like he feels...sorry for you...
He's not going to unpack any of that, nope! But he does take more of an interest in you...
As you travel to the Spire, you feel like...there's always something watching you...but there's nothing there whenever you turn to look. You try not to think about that, or about how happy White Lily and Pure Vanilla seem to be traveling together...
It's hard not to feel a little bit relieved when White Lily separates from the group. Even then, though, you can tell Pure Vanilla is still thinking about her...you try not to feel upset. Not when there are more important things to focus on.
And then, to your surprise...Pure Vanilla wakes you gently the next morning, smiling softly at you. He holds your hand as you all travel to the top of the Spire, he seems to keep stealing glances at you every so often...for the first time in a while, you really feel seen by him.
...it's quite a shock to everyone, and especially to you, that it wasn't actually Pure Vanilla...but Shadow Milk in disguise! You can't help but feel heartbroken, having your hopes briefly rise only for it to all be a lie...
Except that...even as Shadow Milk plays his games with everyone, he continues to treat you in that same kind, warm manner. Maybe it's just to get at Pure Vanilla, but...even when you're alone and there's no one else around, he still acts like that.
To have the spotlight finally focused on you...it feels wonderful. But you can't just...betray your partner like this...especially not with him of all Cookies, can you...?
"Does he deserve your loyalty, though?" Shadow Milk points out if you voice any of these worries. "Think about it: wouldn't he betray you for that half-baked Guardian if he had the chance?" He gives a fanged grin. "...hasn't he already done it?"
It...gives you something to think about. Enough that even if you don't reciprocate his flirting, or the small affectionate gestures...you don't stop him, either.
In the end, after everything in the Spire...you come to your decision. You calmly approach Pure Vanilla in his new, awakened form...and break things off with him, as gently as you can.
He's very obviously shocked, heartbroken...but he tries not to show it. He gives you a soft smile...telling you he understands. (In the back of your mind, a now-familiar voice whispers that he seems relieved, doesn't he??)
In the night, you vanish without a trace...at least, that's what it seems like to the others. In truth, Shadow Milk appeared and offered his hand to you...and you left without looking back.
Once your friends encounter you again, they'll shout accusations at him about "brainwashing" and "kidnapping"...but you and he both know that what you have...isn't actually a lie.
He'll regularly hold you close, pressing kisses against your neck...saying that Pure Vanilla was obviously a fool to not see how much of a star you are, and promising that he'll never let you go.
Timekeeper
"Well! Aren't you an interesting puzzle?" is how she first greets you. Seeming to appear from out of nowhere, hovering above you on a giant pair of scissors...tilting her head as she scans you up and down.
You're a little taken aback at first...is she referring to you? Her grin only seems to widen, and she inches closer to you. "Who else? I've seen a lot of interesting timelines...believe it or not, you're in the thick of a lot of them! Now..." Her eyes gleam as she inches ever closer. "I want to know everything. Tell me about you!"
With interest like that, it's hard to not divulge...and in return, she tells you about alternate versions of yourself that she's seen, as well as the various oddities that pop up throughout time and space.
She makes a few more infrequent visits, here and there. It isn't long before she offers a crazy proposition to you: to leave Pure Vanilla and run away with her instead!
You feel perhaps a small twinge of hesitance...but when you think about the way Pure Vanilla looks at White Lily, how he looks at you, and finally how Timekeeper looks at you with such warmth and fascination...you feel your reservations melting away.
Pure Vanilla tries to take the breakup as graciously as he can...and largely succeeds. Perhaps due to the rift that had already been growing between you both.
Hearing that you're leaving the timeline with another Cookie is...a bit more of a shock! He struggles to process this, stammers that you know you can return here any time...(He hopes, at least. He's not fully sure how...these timelines work...)
Timekeeper is elated that you've agreed to her offer, and quickly sweeps you into a tight hug, spinning you around a few times before placing you right in front of her on her scissors!
You're whisked off to the TBD, introduced to everyone there...Timekeeper is proud to tell everyone that you're her partner! So she expects them all to treat you very well!
Everyone is perhaps a little shocked at the sudden declaration, but of course they listen to her...it's not long before you're well-accepted by the group.
You hear rumors that Timekeeper is a hard one to track down, always seeming to appear and disappear on whims...but for you? You find that the second you start to miss her, she'll suddenly appear...either bringing you a gift, or offering to bring you on some kind of adventure!
It makes you feel special. Whenever you thank her for that, she grins widely...and also blushes, fiddling with her scissors. "Well! You are, you know! Doesn't that mean you deserve to feel that way?"
Self Aware AU, where the cookies come to the player's/reader's world. Pick whichever characters you wanna include, I just need to see this 🙏
→ ❛Part of your world❜
→ Characters ; Longan Dragon Cookie, Burning Spice Cookie, Shadow Milk Cookie, Timekeeper Cookie & Millennial Tree Cookie
→ Quote ; ❛❛If someone came to you and told you “One day you’ll have those who you love the most in the palm of your hand”, well… you never thought that’d become true, nor that it’d be a metaphor…❜❜
→ Genre ; Headcanons/Drabble
→ A/N ; This took me a whole ass night to make and 2500+ words to finish, I hope you like it /lh
Longan Dragon Cookie
“How quaint… to believe someone like you lives in such a… small place”
Having Longan Dragon in your home was… curious to say the least. Not something you expected, yet here you were, with a dragon looking at you as they squatted in your bedroom.
Longan would be hypercritical of the place you lived, noting things like “This looks cheap” or “Its far too small”
Despite that, Longan would be quite intrigued in your life, wanting to see how you worked or what you did, they’d follow you around when not sitting in your living room and meditating.
Nevertheless, they’re there for a reason, they’re with you for a reason, and they’ll make that reason known very, very soon.
It’d take Longan a few months, but eventually, they would come to sit by your side at the table, not sitting down on a chair but instead, sitting down by your side quite literally. They’d stare at you for long moments before finally leaning their head on your shoulder, the weight catching you off guard as you looked at them.
“... I’ll make sure you live like you deserve one of these days” They’d say, and in that moment, you understood why there had been so many disappearances of delinquents and robbers nearby…
If you’re wondering what they’d do in your world, then…
One of the few favorite activities of Longan was to read, so much so, that you had to request books from the library more often than not, but with the way Longan was reading them… It had just been a few months, and yet this dragon had consumed almost all of your local library’s books. So, when they finished reading most of your books, they’d chose to write them. And they’d write about what they saw, about everything they had seen around them, everything they had seen in this new world, and in some sense, it was intriguing to see how a dragon explored the new world they were in, the little things that werent intriguing to you were greatly important to them, in a way that got you even more intrigued by how they saw you.
“... You want to know how I see you?” They’d ask.
You knew fully well that you shouldnt expect much, after all, this was Longan Dragon we were talking about, they werent a kind dragon, they saw cookies as lesser beings, and humans now by extensions, but as you asked them that question, they’d only smile and pat your head softly.
“You’re the reason Im here… Of course I would think highly of you”
A genuine smile, it made your heart flutter as they spoke, a hand going to cup your chin in it.
“You’re interesting, perhaps, one of the most interesting things I’ve seen in this world.”
Besides writing, they’d follow you around and take note of everything you’d do… And by night, they’d curl by your side, taking most of the bed as they allow you to take rest in their chest, as they allow you to take rest in their breaths while their hands thread on your hair.
Burning Spice Cookie
“How intriguing…! Never would I have expected your home to be so… so… erm…”
Another one who seems to heavily judge your house, but also, another one who appears in your home kneeling because it is so small compared to him.
Either way, he gets eased into the ambient quite easily, his search for entertainment leading him to see through everything and all the world has to offer.
Until he… gets bored, again, because your world isnt as different from his (and in some sense, it is… actually… more boring than his old world…)
So, he moves to the next thing closest to him for entertainment!
“Little one, come here”
He’d call forward to you once, looking at you with dark yet fiery eyes and an everlasting smile, though you knew this once it hid something, after all, despite him coming to your world for x or y reason, it involved you, it always involved you…
“Entertain me” Would be his words once you approached him, his smile becoming only more cryptic as you lifted an eyebrow at his voice. Entertain, him? In what sense or way would you be able to entertain someone akin to a god?
Seeming to sense your doubt, Burning Spice would only come and hold you from your shirt, lifting you up before staring at you and then…
“Hahahah, you should’ve looked at your face, you really are an interesting one!”
If you’re wondering what he’d do in your world, then…
Besides seeking something for entertainment, Burning spice is in some sense able to somewhat pass through the crowd, and by that I mean he can somewhat pass as just a very tall human. Nonetheless, between choosing to hit the gym and sending you pictures, he’ll also follow you around, finding even the most monotonous tasks fairly entertaining if it has you in it. Its a weird combo, being outside with a dude in a hoodie and sweat pants following you around while doing groceries, or being in the metro and getting a fairly nice picture of him flexing for you. Burning spice is a menace…
“Aye, welcome home! I took care of some pesky people while you were gone… It was fun hearing their screams…”
…in far more ways than one.
Either way, you two also share a bed, its not like you have a choice with how clingy he can become when sleeping, pulling you in his arms in a heated hug (in the sense that he literally irradiates heat) while snoring loudly, you’ve gotten complaints from neighbors (if you live in an apartment), but somehow… they’ve… they’ve quieted down recently… However, when you ask Burning Spice, he just laughs it off.
Shadow Milk Cookie
“Woowee, what do we have here, sweetheart?”
Not as judgemental of your home, no, for once someone isnt as focused on where you live but…
He is focused on you, looking at you up and down, before hitting his head on the roof of your room, ouch!
He spends most of the days following you around though, using his magic to stay hidden from most people, so much that people may find you crazy for seeing you talk to… nothing!
Either way, much like the others, he’s there for a reason…
“Why Im here?”
You asked Shadow Milk once, after a good few months, what the jester had come to do in your own home. In fact, it perplexed you so much that when you asked him, the feeling seemed to be shared. It was… intriguing to say the least, but he’d only smile before clasping his hands together and saying in a song-esque tune.
“Becuase you’re sooooooooooo interesting, darlin! Just look at you, how could I NOT come here with you?”
Truth to be told, he saw you as who you really were, in some sense he saw you as someone who didnt fall for lies easily, he saw you as someone who saw beyond that and you were… interesting. You were a shot in the dark, and he just had, to have you near.
“You’re so silly, darlin, sososososo silly” He’d add in, patting your head softly as you only smiled and blushed slightly, even while knowing his smile and gaze hid a million of thoughts, and a million of even more ideas.
If you’re wondering what he’d do in your world, then…
When not reading around in your home, or following you to the library to read some books, he’d be looking over your shoulder, reading every single note, watching every single thing you do, it makes him curious, how someone so quaint has him wrapped around your finger. And yet, he cant help but smile at the idea of being just like that, wrapped around your finger in a sweet loving embrace.
He’d be the most romantic of the bunch, the one that makes it the most prominent that he’s there with you because he likes you, he dosent even hide it fully despite his jester-esque persona, he just cant hide it! So, when you ask him about what he was doing one day in the balcony of your apartment, he’d only turn and smile softly.
“Why, I'm recreating one of your world’s theatre plays!” He’d say, and you make a mental note to go to the theatre more often… “And you’ve come just in time, silly (y/n)! I need someone to play dearest Juliet!”
You add that it is a tragic love story, and he only brushes it off, adding in that “actors are actors, sweetheart, now come in and act!” so you do, and you have a fun time doing a monologue to a bunch of people who stay and watch, before claps fill the air.
And when time comes to bed, he’ll be the first to curl up in your bed, curl like a cat who welcomes you into his arms so sweetly, you feel the scent of milk, lactonic as it is, and for once you feel safe.
Timekeeper Cookie
“Well, look what we have here!”
To find Timekeeper in your home means to have done something either right or wrong. In your case, its right.
They’re very much curious about everything from the things you do on a daily basis to your home and how electronics work.
Still, and much like some others in this list, they become quickly bored about it, choosing to focus on you as main form of entertainment
Still, you can expect certain shenanigans to ensue.
It was late at night when it happened, just as you were playing when a portal opened and dragged you inside of it. You were scared shitless that much is true but, when you saw the person who dragged you in, you simply could sigh in slight annoyance.
“What? Cant I drag my favorite person in for some fun?” They’d say with that ever present smile, Timekeeper chuckling as she smiled widely at you, before noticing… “Oh, right, it is night where you’re from, guess I took you out at the wrong time!”
You huffed and yawned, before sitting up and looking at your phone… Right, it didnt exactly work when in time rifts, but then again that raised the question, why did they bring you here to begin with? As if being presented with the question loud and clear, they’d clear her throat and speak yet again.
“I simply wanted to see you, nothing wrong with that now?” They’d say quite mischievously, picking you up and bringing you into her lap “Go on, lets- Hm?”
You’d fall asleep into her arms as soon as she picked you up, your calm quiet face being shown to her as you were held in her arms. Well, guess fun had to wait.
If you’re wondering what they’d do in your world, then…
Much like the others, they also enjoy reading, however, they focus on reading about engineering and mechanics, more so about the mechanics of your world to see if they’re any different from the ones of her world. To say there isnt much difference is but an understatement, there was a hefty amount of difference counting the technology from the TBD was far more advanced, but, even then, you’d be able to get the timekeeper intrigued by the nature of your world.
“Tell me more about your world, c’mon!” They’d ask one day, floating from a time rift as you cooked dinner.
Unlike the others Timekeeper wasnt keen on staying in one place, still finding comfort in being inside time rifts most of the time, though they still visited you more often than not, more often than other places. Seeing them you’d ask her what she wanted to know, to which she’d hum before saying.
“Anything, I dont really find it entertaining seeing it myself—Explain your world to me yourself, doll!”
So when night comes after a long day chatting, it is you who clings to her softly, as she watches you sleep cozily by her side. She smiles and pats your head, because as much as she’d prefer to fade into a time rift, she knows she cant let you go so easily, no. Not when you finally showed her happiness.
“Interesting, this place is… quite interesting…”
Seeing someone as tall as Millennial Tree in your home is but a piece of the whole puzzle. You are dumbfounded but in some sense, seeing them kneel to greet you is almost laughable.
He’s big, very tall and a gentle giant overall, and it shows when he holds your hand and tells you that your world is interesting to him.
He’s just as curious as everyone else, looking at everything, looking at everyone, he’s curious about you, curious about your world, yet he knows it’d be dangerous to leave on his own.
So, you take him to the forest, planing on leaving him go but…
“I dont want to leave you alone…”
He’d speak with conviction, looking at you as your eyes widened and your face dropped. Just what you feared would happen. He’d hold your hands together, looking at you with some concern before smiling softly, kissing both of your palms.
“I came here for a reason, that much I know, and I know that reason is within you… Allow me to stay by your side, and I’ll do everything in my power to make it worth it.”
You have no power in you to say no, to turn down his offer after his gentle and sweet words, that day you realized that perhaps he did come to your world for a reason, a world so clad in evil and pain…
If you’re wondering what he’d do in your world, then…
When not travelling nor reading, he’s at home with you, cooking or revisiting each place he has gone to to help. He’s become… a sort of Messiah, you cant help it, become public enemy no.1 to some, and a savior to others, it truly depended on who you were asking. Your gaze would follow his as he trailed on a book you both were reading before he’d lean and kiss your forehead, things were… easy, happy with him there… You felt much happier.
“Is something the matter, sapling?” He’d ask, his gentleness carrying over to his voice as he hummed at your words saying it was nothing, but he knew better, still, he wouldnt push. “Are you perhaps tired?”
You pouted slightly before nodding, yes, you were quite tired, but you didnt want to admit to it. Still, he’d nod before moving the book to the side and lifting you into his arms. He’d carry you to your shared bedroom, careful on his way there before setting you on the bed with him, cozily, softly, carrying you to him as he pressed his lips on your forehead and your body to his.
“Sleep well, sunshine” He’d say, brushing hairs off your face before speaking again “Thank you for accepting me into your world…”
Honestly, how could you not at this point? With that thought in your head… You fell asleep.
I LOVE TIMEKEEPER I LOVE TIMEKEEPER I LOVE TIMEKEEPER I LOVE TIMEKEEPER I LOVE TIMEKEEPER
And the rest of the TBD gang (mainly dark fondue)
THEIR HOT OK
Anyways have this
Diff variants of y/n in a brides and grooms outfit so (almost) every gender can be included
Timekeeper wears her usual outfit because why not
This was kinda rushed ok bye
I also have a new oc
Venus flytrap cookie, shes under the cut if u wanna see her (plus the reference i used), shes an adult so feel free to request x reader of her
Btw the catipillar part things, i meant to say the catipillars will eat venus flytrap cookie, where she lives, its like the prehistoric era (huge bugs or wtv)
(Ill ALSO be getting to my current requests, COUHJ COUGH)
Teddy anon and sorry for another one if it's too many but...timekeeper x wife reader...just feel like after seeing her story and what she is going through, she deserves company she can turn immortal so even when she is her usual bored...she has a wife who likes to cuddle so they can just cuddle on her sonic embroider and just float through time...chilling lol!
Hi! 🧸 anon🌷
Honestly, i don't know what to write, but i can draw it🥹
