Head cannons on how slashers/killers would react to reader calling them pretty. Includes OG! Michael Myers, RZ! Michael Myers, Ghostface (Stu and Billy), Pyramid Head, Thomas Hewitt and Mark Hoffman (SAW series)
OG! Michael Myers
You notice him stalking you throughout the week, and it was needlessly to say you found it oddly interesting.
Of course you knew who he was, and apparently, for your brain, that was ‘attractive’ enough to wonder about him
So, the night he decided to break in to obviously kill you, you took action
Somewhere between all the struggle you made, his unexpressed latex mask flew off, somewhere around your kitchen floor
The light that came from outside was enough to see his face, and boy, you find him attractive
He panic at the fact of not having his mask, and quickly look for it and successfully found it. With a single swift move his mask was back on. He was ready to kill you when you spoke
“Y-your pretty Michael, you know that?”
He tilted his head at your statement, you couldn’t see it, but his cheeks were blushing. He didn’t know what hated the most, the fact that he couldn’t kill you now or the fact that he actually liked you calling him pretty
His hand holding the knife stutter for a second before letting you go and giving you his signature head tilt again
It’s not necessary to say that since that night he came to your home every night and took off his mask in front of you so you can call him pretty again
And this time you do see him blush
RZ! Michael Myers
You were a childhood friend of his, and the crush was mutual
Tho when you were like around 9yo, you moved to another town so you never found out about Michael killing his stepdad and sister, or at least you had no idea until many years later, when you moved back to Haddonfield
What he did was horrendous, yet you couldn’t stop feeling bad for him somehow
So this night you were getting ready to go to bed, brushing your teeth you notice a man standing behind you
You could see his reflection through the mirror you had in front of you
You knew Michael was, well a killer, but you didn’t know how he looked like, so many years have passed and the last image you had of him was completely different
Non the less, that didn’t stop Michael from recognizing you
You were about to scream when he got closer and covered your mouth with his enormous hand. By now you were struggling and panicked
Michael noticed this and with his free hand took his mask off, revealing his face. He was different but still you knew it was him
“Michael…?”
He didn’t answer, instead he moved his hand from your mouth and gently turned you around, slowly looking at your form head to toe
From the moment you saw his eyes you knew he didn’t have to answer, he was Michael indeed, how couldn’t you recognize his beautiful blue eyes?
“Michael!” You say happily
He stays silent, but a small almost invisible smile formed on his lips
You cupped his cheek with your hand, and rubbed his skin with your thumb
Smiling you tell him “We haven’t seen each other for over ten years and still your the pretty one” You smile
His hole face turned red when he herd the word pretty
You always wanted to tell him how you felt, but never got an actual chance for it
Once you told him how you’ve felt all this years, his reaction was the sweetest
He gave you a bag hug and swing you in the air, he was beyond happy
Ghostface (Stu)
“You know, you’re…pretty Stu…”
You were in his house, music as loud as it could be, you were hoping he didn’t hear you, cause you just kinda declared to him
He gave you a ‘what did you said’ look, waiting for you to answer
“Nothing…just forget it”
YEAH, YOU THOUGHT THAT WAS GOING TO WORK? Well it didn’t
He took you by the hand and made you fallow him upstairs
When you asked him why upstairs he gave you a lame excuse
“I didn’t catch what ya said down there” he said moving closer to you
“I said you’re pretty…” you look at him straight in the eyes
“Oh…I know, I heard you. I just wanted to have some…privacy” He had a mischievous smile on his lips
You grin before he pull you down to his bed
(Billy)
You two were having a heated kiss by the window of your bedroom when you herd footsteps coming up the stairs
You assumed it must be your dad or your mom
“Billy, you should go…someone’s coming”
He pouted and gave you his puppy eyes
“Pleaseeee?…” He asked
As much as you wanted to tell him ‘yes’, you knew better than to piss your dad or mom
“Come on pretty boy, you know I can get in trouble..”
He blushed a pale tone of pink at your words, he was staring at you like you left him dumb or something like that
He then snapped out of it “Okay, okay…see you tomorrow?” He asked
“Yeah pretty boy, see you tomorrow…”
He giggled and stumbled at the word ‘pretty’
Pyramid Head
Did you just called him pretty? No way, he must’ve herd you wrong
Oh…apparently he didn’t YOU DID CALLED HIM PRETTY
Now it’s stuck in his head and it’s all he can think about
He likes it tho
And definitely expect him to want you to call him pretty all the time
With time he even let you adorn his pyramid with cute little pink stuff
He won’t say that he likes it but trust me HE LIKES IT
Specially if you call him your ‘pretty monster’
He’ll definitely want you to call him pretty during segsy time too 😏
Thomas Hewitt
You called him pretty? Why tho? Haven’t you seen him?
That’s what he thought the first time you called him that
Immediately you receive the princess treatment
Cause why not? You treat him well, he wants to do the same with you. You’re his love after all
Expect him to giggle a little bit whenever you call him pretty or beautiful or what so ever
And if you kiss his unmasked face while you call him pretty? You’ll give him a heart attack
He loves it
He’ll make sure you feel loved and pretty as well
He’ll make you dinner and give you flowers every now and then
Basically anything you want, you get
Definitely expect him to want you to call him pretty 24/7
He’s like a child OK!?
Mark Hoffman
He thinks you’re joking, you must be joking
Nobody calls him pretty, and you wouldn’t be the exception, right?
Ha! Liar….deep down he loves it, and not just because you bust his ego, but also you make him feel loved….somehow
He thinks he’s unlovable, I mean, he’s a monster right?
Well, that doesn’t stop you from loving him or calling him pretty
The first times you would call him that, he would show no emotion or reaction whatsoever
But once you get to his, somehow, ‘tender’ side, he’ll slowly start reacting
Maybe a ‘you’re pretty as fuck too’ or maybe even a peck to your lips
And consider yourself blessed if you see him blush….cause he rarely does
And if you happen to see him blush..? Well you didn’t
Cause how could he blush right? Him? He’s mean and bad, he doesn’t blush
You even reacted once, to his blushing
“If-if you ever, you wouldn’t-Ahgg, please don’t tell anyone” He said, as he blushed even more, the tone on his voice defeated
You just laugh since you found him cute
“You’re little…pink secret is safe with me, detective” You told him
You kissed he blushed cheeks and called him cute
“Hey! I’m not!”
“Yes you are!” You said as you walked away
“I love you so much….” Mark said, knowing you weren’t around to hear it
Cause you would have died right there in the spot
Well, I hope you enjoy this!! I’m also working on a Ghostface x Michael x F!reader fic, so stay tuned 😏
the idea was initially to make a keychain, based on the riddler one, but he ended up being way bigger than anticipated, so I'll just keep him like that.
honestly, the sewing is a mess, he is kinda misshapen like in the "ears" and hair since I didn't anticipate how he would look after stuffing, and I wish I made him more detailed, but I've been working on him for hours and just wanted to finish it already .
but besides everything I still think he looks great and he is very dear to me, my newborn son.
