Hi! I would like to know if utrinque is meant to be exclusive of people who feel like they are both/neither cis and/nor trans for not physically "looking like" one's assigned gender even though they are their assigned gender, or if it's for anyone who doesn't feel like they don't fit cis or trans in general? I'm asking because the OP kinda implies it's exclusive, but doesn't outright say so. x_x
To be brief: it is an exclusive term. I thought the OP made that clear.
To be long: it’s exclusive, and I also really don’t like this phrasing.
My situation makes it to where I cannot entirely identify with the experiences of cis or trans girls, but can identify in part with the experiences of both. I identify myself as nonbinary because of my alienation from cisness; I cannot identify with womanhood in the same way I used to.
I identify as utrinque because of my relation to our body and society. I am legally male, and I am on testosterone, and our body passes as male. I am actively read as a transfeminine person. There is no gendered restroom I can feel SAFE in. Not comfortable, safe. I’m too feminine for the men’s room, too masculine for the women’s. It’s more than feeling like I’m not cis or trans, I can’t. I’m not ACCEPTED as either. Not really.
My situation is distressing. Extremely so. Because I know that I put our system at risk every time I leave the house as myself, and that my situation is niche and no one really thinks about it. Cis and trans were meant to be inclusive of pretty much everyone (intersex people have their own term for if they identify with neither, but it escapes me at the moment), but people like me fall through the cracks.
It’s not for just anyone that doesn’t identify with cis or trans, because I really don’t want this term used to describe experiences that literally are cis or trans, or are generally considered to be under umbrellas, like nb people who just don’t identify as trans but aren’t cis either —that’s a valid identity, but that isn’t really the criteria for utrinque. Similarly, I’ve seen trans people that stopped identifying as trans because they transitioned, but obviously weren’t suddenly cis: that’s not utrinque either.
Experiences I’ve consciously recognised as applicable to utrinque thus far
- alters in DID/OSDD systems that match the body’s assigned gender at birth, but whose systems have made the decision to transition. This was outlined in the OP- people whose bodies produce too much of the “wrong” sex hormone or too little or the “correct” one, if this results in an atypical, non-cis relationship to their gender
I’ve also given special permission to a system I know whose adult body reads as an androgynous prepubescent child, causing significant gender dysphoria regardless of the gender of who is fronting.
If you’d like to tell me why you don’t identify with trans/cis, I’m happy to tell you if utrinque applies, but it is an exclusive term. I hope this clarifies.