It wasn't just having a tag preference on Ao3. It was claiming people were actually dumb and/or transphobic/homophobic (whatever the point needed to be) for headcanoning A&C having a pussy/being nb/genderfluid (and even being totally gendergent. some of them really hated the Ineffable Wives), because it went "against what the source material said", and also an insult to two supernatural beings who made the conscious choice of presenting as male, which if anything made them trans men, not women or nb or anything.
It was also about some of them being fatphobic (not shown on the screenshots available, but Moony would not stop going on about people wanting to "give Michael an eating disorder" for drawing Aziraphale kind of fat (and also a brilliant instance of Zoey saying it was not a crime to want to draw Aziraphale with a "normal weight". Yes she used those words)
It was about being heavily judgy of kinks that weren't theirs, about asexuality, about being sexual in general, and also very weird comments made about pregnancy and how people were weird fucks for enjoying pregnancy content (it /had/ to be a weird fetish, you understand...).
But it was mostly about the bullying. It was creating this little server with the intent of making fun of people in it. Making fun of their opinions, making fun of them personally. And at first that even took place in a secret room /in/ the server. Not even the courtesy of doing it in DMs. It was collectively and systematically aking fun of the same artists/writers, dismissing some of them because they clearly wrote with their hand in their pants (and that's BAD!).
It would be easy to carry on but hey! Lots of remaining grievances are mostly irritating personality traits which are only the cherry on top, but not really things worth discoursing about in public. People are allowed to be annoying!
I just wanted this out there because, you know, it's a bit weird seeing some of the stuff in those screenshots being pulled out of its context, because honestly, half of what's circulating on tumblr/bluesky is really not what people think it is about. Some of it really was just jokes in a certain context (senses of humour are what they are). It was just a bit weird seeing people missing the (imho) real stuff that was directly harmful to the fandom (ie: people expressedly attacking and belittling other fandom members)
Just sharing this because it has a lot of the info I didn’t have the spoons to type out last night