smile/everette as a character(+others)
SMILE EVERETTE FOCUSED RANT
(Note: i'll be referring to his character in the well world/post death as Smile and his pre death self as Everette)
Timeline headcanons(or general theory) ill be referring to:
2016/2017 - Everette Dies(11-12)
2021 - 2023 - Chris(15-16?) gets tormented by Smile + dies
ill be going over 3 main sections in this rant
1: Everette's trauma and its affect on Smile
Everette was presumably 10-12 during/around the events of his POV videos(what friends are for/my house/minecraft lets play), known from his mention of being in 5th grade during the house showcase. He has a dog, a caring mother, a grandmother(? i think he has one that bought him minecraft??? idk i may be hallucinating details here). However, his father isn't the nicest, verbally and physically abusive towards everette, causing everette to hide in the bathroom to avoid him. (dog died too? i think? dont remember by what means) Later on, his mother dies, an unknown reason to everette but to us, it is assumed that she was murdered by everette's father, possibly buried in the well in their basement. Not only is his home life traumatizing, but he is lonely at school. His "friends" destroying a minecraft world that was so precious to him, most likely a form of escape from the tragedy in his life, exploding the builds he worked so hard on. Everything added up, causing him to end his life(by drowning in a well?).
Everything that has happened in his life has always been out of his control. Never once was he able to change the course of his life(whether for the better or for the worse) or have the ability to stand up against what happens to him. How does this trauma reflect onto his later form, Smile? As the leading entity of this minecraft world, he holds power to do whatever he wants.(under certain assumptions of how the entities work when we dont see them through video, for ex. time works linear(a year irl is a year in minecraft world), smile is possibly in creative mode? stuff like that. idk. weird worldbuilding. hope that gets expanded on or given some info abt) Smile is able to create whole office buildings, govern over hundreds of little minions that do his bidding. In this world, he is given control, he is able to choose what happens to him AND other people. However, it doesnt change how lonely he is. Sure, the minions exist, but (to our knowledge), they can't speak, can't offer much to Smile other than silent company. We assume that during the Smile - Chris era, the smilelings did NOT exist as chris never mentions them(which hell usually do in one of his journals). I think that Smile was trying to take over Chris' body but wasnt able to as he had hid the bones all over in differnt worlds.
Though, why would Smile want to seize another person's body? From what we know of Everette, it doesn't exactly seem to me that he wanted to die just to die. moreover, i feel that he wanted to be somewhere different, away from his current life. And with what power he had, the only "different" place he could go was death. His house isnt friendly, his safe space got ruined, what more did he have? Due to his loneliness in the well world, he probably figured he wanted more. Even though we don't know Chris' full backstory or family relations, I personally assume he had similar situations to Andrew, having friends(mentioned by chris) and family that cared for him. Smile most likely knows this, and with potential power(?) to be able to take over someones body, someone who has a loving family and friends who genuinely care, why wouldnt he try? He doesn't have anything to lose anymore so as soon as Chris appears, he will snatch that chance and do everything in his power to succeed. Being tormented previously, he knows what hurts people, he knows how to take someones darkest fears and turn them into reality, breaking victims bit by bit. He puts on this fake persona, pretending to be an evil villain with no ulterior motive other than to torture and toy with his victim.
2: Smile's manipulation tactics
Expanding on the previous point on how Smile REALLY breaks down his victims.
Andrew has a secure life, he has caring family, good friends, the stress from school being his only major worry.(or as weve been told, as andrew said, he did have a period of time where he struggled a lot with his mental health(?) and chris was his escape from all of his problems). However, at the start of the story, he seems to be doing alright, maybe not the best, but not as bad as Everette had it. He's mentally stable. However as the story goes on, he is broken down bit by bit by Smile, going from someone who was simply reminiscing of past times to someone with frequent nightmares, neglecting his own health, and losing control of his emotions.
Smile REALLY takes advantage of chris' death to the max, using their close connection as andrew's breaking point. He lets them reconnect again, reforming their distant friendship just to crash it all down by revealing Chris' traumatizing and horrifying death. However, due to the previous reconnection, Andrew has motivations to keep going forward, unable to quit as he had already promised Chris he'd do this for them. At this point, andrew is starting to get REALLY annoyed by everything going on, sick and tired of Smile's constant mind games. He desensitizes Andrew to violence in MEMORY CONSTRUCT, making him believe that violence is necessary to proceed. He starts to become more unstable, slowly breaking under the pressure of everything happening in the game. It's not like he can leave anymore, he's gone too far to stop now. However, Chris is still an issue, so, knowing Chris' opinions on using violence, he puts the two against each other, breaking their relationship, completely isolating Andrew from any outside support. From here on, it's kinda easy, Andrew's already nearing his lowest, all Smile needs is to just get him to complete the final goal of giving him the bones.
Andrew's only weakness is Chris, and Smile horrifyingly used that for his downfall. Could also take in to consideration the possible theory(i think other people have thought about this) that the Chris we see isnt the REAL Chris. Just a bullshitted version Smile created to fuck with andrew even more. What if chris didnt die the way we thought he did? what if it was ALL an act? As the viewer, we actually don't know alot about chris' personality. We know he's good at tech, he was a bit of a prankster with Andrew, he has fascination over the creativity of minecraft, and hes has perseverance, following through the journey that andrew is currently going through right now. (going a little off topic here please be kind with me im just a guy who goes on tangents….) Chris really reminds me of Connor Murphy from the Dear Evan Hansen Musical. A guy who dies at the start of the series, only for a fabricated and imagined version of him to appear throughout the show. No one really knew him, but from the details of the book, we learn that he is aggressive, impulsive, and not the "kind" and "caring" figure the main character describes him to be. Of course, i'm not suggesting that chris IS like him, i think chris is definitely in a more stable mental state than him, but it still carries that same idea of, is the chris that is presented to us ACTUALLY an accurate representation of his true personality.
3: Personal Theories about pre-death Everette
Always wondered what Everette meant by (paraphrasing here) "If you're reading this, that means I've succeeded." That implies that he KNEW a way to get into the minecraft world which is quite insane. I can see it working by like him testing the wells —> child imagination thinking it could work with the well in his house —> it actually working. but still, he also mentioned (paraphrasing once again) "it was so beautiful there". not sure if thats referring to the minecraft world? its very strange and ive been thinking about it a lot.
Another thing i've sorta been thinking about is what andrew's reactions to finding out smile = everette.
Based on what we know of his character, i definitely think he'd feel guilty or at least have sympathy for what happened to everette but i wouldn't blame him if he completely lashed out on Smile.
What i think would happen is andrew yelling at Smile and basically trying to give him a wake up call. He knows Smile is traumatized, and maybe by bringing up his past trauma(not a good thing btw, entire situation is very complex), he could break down that fake persona he is putting up as means to protect himself. i do see it possible for smile to deflect all of andrew's comments because allowing himself to be vulnerable and show guilt for his actions = loss of power which i believe is smile's biggest fear in all of this.
end note: holy fucking shit have we entered yap continent or what cause this is an entire city of words
this is 1550 words btw, what am i doing with my life