I want Boromir to have lived so bad. Like Faramir makes sense to be steward, he is canonically better at it. But Boromir should have had a (longer) redemption arc. Gotten to chase the hobbits around Rohan, gotten to fight once more for Gondor, gotten to apologise to Frodo and more importantly gotten to see Gondor in peace.
He would have been a brilliant best man for Faramir, an amazing Dad in the future and would have become Aragorn's number 1 supporter.
















