NYSM Halloween Headcanons
featuring a lot of ideas from @manisanythingnottaken because we were yapping abt this together
(cough sorry it's two days late)
this is set either in the year before the show (in a universe where theyve made a name for themselves within new york) or in like. a weird nondescript point in time/alternate reality where Henley hasn't left yet but Jack didn't die in their big trick My other NYSM headcanons Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4 Part 5 - You're already here! Part 6 Part 6.1 - Weed Edition Part 6.2 - December Holidays Edition
Jack loves Halloween. Like he loves dressing up and walking around New York, and even before he was with the Horsemen and actually had money and someplace to live, he would buy dollar store make up and throw on what he could for a costume to wear
When he finally has money, he dresses up super elaborately and brings bags of candy to hand out to anybody he sees in a cool costume-- kids and adults alike
Henley loved Halloween when she was a little girl, but hadn't celebrated in years beyond the occasional themed show, but when she moves in with the rest of the horsemen Jack is so excited that she gets into the spirit
She makes a GORGEOUS and elaborate costume, and she also helps make Jack's costume
Danny is against this. He does not like the idea of dressing up, nor of going out into the city at night with the sole idea of interacting with strangers
He is dragged along against his will
Danny's sentiments being "This is ridiculous. I'm nearly thirty years old, I'm not dressing up like-- like a child."
Merritt thinks he's too old for Halloween but loves seeing them happy, so he throws on a costume and goes along with them
Merritt, when out with them, is one of those adults who just LIGHTS UP at kids costumes and is like "Oh my GOD it can't be! It's really (obscure character) from my favorite show (nichest kids show you've ever heard of)???!!!"
The kids love him
Danny doesnt want to go out because he's partially embarrassed and partially because he's Incredibly Easily Scared on Halloween
Like, he gets scared by those things that are movement sensing and start talking. He spends the entire night on edge and gets genuinely freaked out by ppl in rlly good horror costumes
All three of the other horsemen spend 90% of the night upon realizing this teasing him and offering to hold his hand
Jack, on the other hand, may or may not end up breaking several things when being startled. He punches when he's snuck up on
They go to a haunted house without knowing this
A mistake.
Jack and Danny had to get one of those "scaredy cat" signs due to Danny having the heartrate of a rabbit and Jack just narrowly missing punching one of the scareactors in the nose
He messed up an actors costume at some point and felt SO bad he apologized immediately
He has a hell of a time, though. He'd never been to a haunted house and even though he couldn't experience it normally he had a lot of fun, especially watching the others gets startled by things
The three of them try to warn Danny to jumpscares
This has the adverse effect of making Danny overthink, panic, spin around in a circle, and then miss seeing the jumpscare until it's too late
Jack tapped him on the shoulder in warning once halfway through the haunted house and he genuinely shrieked
They spent a long time trying to decide what costumes to wear
Danny was going to just go in normal attire, and Merritt was planning to do the same but then pull out like a "im (random character from some show in the 80s thats just like a normal guy)" when asked what he was wearing
Henley and Jack brainstormed group/couples costumes and wound up remembering Alice in Wonderland exists
Henley was GOING to be Alice, but decided that the Queen of Hearts sounded way more fun to design and wear
Jack went with the Cheshire cat, the purple one not hte blue one because he has taste
They convinced Danny to be the White Rabbit, and stuck cheap bunny ears on his head and a cotton fluff ball to the back of his coat. He wore just like a formal suit sort of outfit and this giant painted cardboard clock Jack made for him
Merritt was the Mad Hatter and while his costume was simple it was obvious who he was supposed to be. He wore one of his many hats but Jack tied a scarf around it and stuck playing cards into it with pins
They all incorporate cards into their costumes, for obvious reasons
Henley spends forty minutes figuring out how to make her hair do the queen of hearts thing while still looking good and eventually has to recruit Danny to help her finish it because he's weirdly good with hair
Danny has to recruit Merritt who is ALSO good with hair because he needs a second pair of hands
Henley and Jack went to every thrift store in the city looking for the perfect coat and pocket watch for Merritt's costume. They had a lot of fun doing it
Jack, Henley, and Merritt all tease Danny about how in character he is as the White Rabbit because he tends to get so up in arms about being on schedule
Jack spends a lot of the night doing card tricks for kids. Danny eventually joins in on this
They walk around the city all carrying candy and handing it out to anybody they see in costume, and midway through the night they notice a group in… familiar attire and wigs
They meet four people dressed up as the Four Horsemen
They are delighted
The cosplayers don't realize they're actually talking to THE horsemen at first and just think they've met other fans who think their cosplays are cool
Jack makes a comment saying "Wow, that really looks like my jacket, and you got my stage hair down perfectly, man!"
Cue "…YOUR jacket?"
They don't believe him. He ends up having to do a trick for them. Then they believe that it's Jack and take advantage of the four of them being there by being like "ok you all have to prove it"
Danny is offended they don't recognize him and ends up doing some absolute physics breaking bullshittery to awe them
They sign the deck of cards that cosplay!Jack had with him and part ways












