#witcher decisions

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

Witcher Decisions: ForeFather’s Eve

Wikia Entry

ForeFather’s Eve is a quest that begins after you complete A Towerful of Mice in Velen. It involves The Pellar, who will contact you outside of Keira Metz’s house or at the forge in Crow’s Perch, depending on if you have completed the Family Matters quest yet. The Pellar will ask you to protect him and a group of villagers during the ForeFather’s Eve ritual on Fyke Isle.

Once the ritual begins, you will have to fight off some drowners, drowned dead, and a water hag. After that, The Pellar will summon a ghost which turns out to be his father, Ambros. After this, three witch hunters will appear as they believe the ritual to be a site of necromancy and you will get to make the big choice of this quest. You can either keep protecting The Pellar or leave and let the witch hunters disband the ritual. I always choose to keep protecting The Pellar. I am never a fan of the witch hunters and even though I think that the ritual is strange, that does not mean that it should not be allowed to happen. Choosing this will mean that you must kill the three witch hunters but they are all scum so who cares. This will also mean that you must then fight off spirits that were attracted to the blood from the fight. Defeat them and then you must travel into Crookback Bog and burn the body of The Pellar’s father so that his wraith will never return. After that, return to The Pellar to complete the quest.

Killing the witch hunters will result in a lot more of a hastle for this quest but I still always choose it. Fuck the witch hunters. Thank you for reading and let me know what you chose for this quest! :)

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

Witcher Decisions: Missing in Action

Wikia Entry

Missing in action is a secondary quest that takes place in the beginning of the game in White Orchard. I usually start this quest by reading the “Brother Missing” post on the notice board in the village. In this quest you assist Dune in finding his brother. The big choice in this quest is whether or not to save the life of a Nilfgaardian deserter named Rhosym who you find out is the reason that Dune’s brother Bastien is alive. I’ve played through the game four times and every time I chose to save Rhosym. Rhosym saved the life of Bastien and in return I think Dune should do the same. Convincing Dune to save Rhosym means that he will take him in and harbor him. Although this is a crime in the currently Nilfgaardian occupied White Orchard, I believe it is the right thing to do as this means that they both saved each others lives.

I think that this quest is a very good introduction to The Witcher 3. It shows the types of tough choices that the game will have you make. Taking Rhosym in is a very risky thing for Dune and his family to do as if caught could lead to dire consequences. But as this game teaches you, the right thing to do isn’t always the smart thing to do.

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

Hello there! for the Witcher decisions, the quest "Possession" on Skellige concerning Uldaryk, you trick the hym or fight it?

Thanks for the ask! :)

Witcher Decisions: Possession

I like to trick the hym. I will always stick with Cerys even though her plan is a bit insane, I love it. In my mind, Geralt just knocks out Udalryk’s men instead of killing them because that would be one downside of siding with Cerys. Overall I don’t think either choice is bad here, but the scene with trusting Cerys, I prefer over the fight with the hym.

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

Ask sent in message by @greeni2402. Thanks for the ask! Sorry it took me so long, I forgot about this one because it was in a message not an ask. :)

Witcher Decisions: Where the Cat and Wolf Play

This is another quest with a very tough decision. I think both choices are very justified. Ultimately I usually prefer letting Gaetan live. I still am not sure if he is telling the truth or not as there are a lot of variables. He could be lying but I usually choose to believe him when he says that the villagers tried to cheat him. Yes, he extremely overreacted but I understand why he went off the handle if the villagers did in fact try to cheat him. I also would not feel right killing a Witcher as they are already so few in numbers. Plus, he does give you an extra reward if you let him live. Then, I always go back an help the little girl of course. :)

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

Letting Ciri meet Emhyr or not ?

Thanks for the ask! :)

Witcher Decisions: Letting Ciri meet Emhyr or not?

No. I always tell her that he wanted to see her firstly and then when she wants to know what I would do, I say don’t go and see him. If their was an option for Ciri to visit Emhyr without her becoming empress (Besides Radovid living) then I would because I really like the scene that takes place. But ultimately I don’t care for Emhyr and I want Ciri to become a Witcher.

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

The Volunteer?

Thanks for the ask! :)

Witcher Decisions: The Volunteer

For those that do not know, “The Volunteer” is the quest that involves Trololo the Troll, aka the Redanian Patriot troll. Firstly, I always let him live. I don’t think that the troll had bad intentions, he was just doing the job that was asked of him in protecting the boats that the Redanian soldiers seized. He clearly did not mean to kill anyone and then the reason he cooked them was because he was hungry. He is just a troll after all and food isn’t easy to come by for him. Secondly, I get him the paint and then put my Witcherly painting skills to the test for him. Which I know everyone jokingly mocks Geralt’s painting skills but honestly I think he did a good job. This is one of my favorite side quests in the game as it gives you a tough decision in whether or not to let the troll live and then if you decide to let him live, you get a very cute and funny scene. :)

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

Did you Kill the werewolf in the red riding hood quest Or let her Kill the villager?

Thanks for the ask! :)

Witcher Decisions: Little Red

I think I prefer to kill Little Red and her band. They are bandits afterall and she is a werewolf. Geralt was hired to protect the man. The bandits would likely cause more harm in the long run if left alive. All the man did was turn her in to the authorities. I don’t like having to kill a lot of people, but that is what I feel is right during this quest.

[witcherislovewitcherislife]

What about the one where you have to choose between the Baron's wife and a village or a group of orphans?

Thanks for the ask! :)

Witcher Decisions: The Whispering Hillock

I think that this is one of the toughest choices, probably the toughest in the entire game. It is classic Witcher in the sense that there is no right or wrong decision and with this quest there really isn’t a good one either. I think I prefer saving the village and Anna over the children. As sad as that is. The five children are eaten sadly but there is a lot of other people that get to keep their lives. The entire village of Downwarren is able to survive, as well as Anna and the Baron. Plus, I believe that the tree spirit would cause the world a lot of evil (I think somewhere it is mentioned that this is the case).