The Nutcracker: Conclusion
The goal of my adventure through the Nutcracker was to learn more about the story, its background, and why it became important to American culture. Through this project, I hoped to gain and share a deeper understanding of the story I grew up with, so that we can have greater insight the next time we see a nutcracker or hear the chimes of the Sugar Plum Fairy music. I wondered if there was something deeper in the fanciful fantasy of the Nutcracker story-- why would it become an icon of Christmas time around the world? The meaning behind, and evolution of, the Nutcracker brought together our class discussions of author and adaptation, of the unique features that accompany shifts between media, of the importance of both audience and author in establishing purpose, and of setting and space. The Nutcracker is a fairytale, meant by its original author Hoffman to be a macabre anti-fairytale that commented on tradition, but that nonetheless emphasizes the mystical and fantastic in all of its numerous adaptations.
I focused on Hoffman's original book "Nutcracker and Mouse King" and on the Nutcracker ballet, and their contrasts in storytelling methods. I briefly forayed into Dumas's book adaptation and the new Disney movie, "The Nutcracker and the Four Realms". However, Dumas' plot was very similar to Hoffman's, and the Disney movie was wildly different from the original and ballet plots. Being interested mainly in the ballet, and having enjoyed reading Hoffman's original tale, I contained my project to discussing the subtle differences and more large scale changes between these two forms, and the background and origin of the ballet story I knew.
In these respects I answered many of the questions I had when I started. Because I was interested in the change, evolution, and adaptation of the Nutcracker story, I focused on the story's history and origin, and on comparisons between written and dance media. My project answered how the medium of ballet adapted the Nutcracker story uniquely to enable ease of storytelling. I explored how the Nutcracker developed into a Christmas tradition— through a fortuitous combination of Tchaikovsky's timeless music, extravagant and popular Balanchine choreography and production, an abundance of children's dance roles, and an enthralling sense of exoticism, wonder, and magic. It was interesting to trace various adaptations of the story through history and across place, and consider the unique contemporary adaptations of the ballet in different contexts such as Hawaiian, South African, and Durham-ian.
Continuing this project, I would have liked to discuss in more depth these recent adaptations of the Nutcracker ballet, and how they engage with the audience and wider community discourse. For example, the Walltown Durham's unique Nutcracker is helping to promote diversity and discussions of equity and inclusion, which is something most traditional productions do not aim to target. While I mentioned throughout my project the Nutcracker's exploration of different realities, I would cover in greater detail the stories' plays with point of view, and how this translates to the ballet stage. I was surprised by the layered story-within-the-story in Hoffman's tale, another example of layered realities. Called the "Tale of the Hard Nut," this embedded tale served as an indirect background story for the Nutcracker. Because this satirical, absurd anti-fairytale was entirely left out of the ballet, I did not focus on it, but it would have been interesting to pick apart.












