Just finally finished a binge watch through of AMC's The Walking Dead. I had heard good things, here are my thoughts and theories. (Preface: I have only watched the TV adaptation. I have not read any of the comics on which it is based.) COMA THEORY - Rick is still in a coma - season 1-2. I truly believe this was the original intent of the writers. There's tons of evidence to support it espescially in the pilot. (Which I must say was just a cinematic masterpiece.) All the wall clocks in the hospital had stopped. Wall clocks are usually battery powered. Although Rick has been unattended for at minimum several days, his hospital gown and bed sheets are unsoiled. Also his wound seems to have changed places and severity. Throughout the first two seasons the morality challenges Rick faces are all very personal. He cannot ever keep both his family and the larger group safe simultaneously. I think this harkens back to the last thing Lori said to him before he was shot. "I wonder if you even care about us at all." Rick seemed awfully upset about this line in particular as he confides in Shane. I feel that the entire first two seasons were a dieing Rick struggling with the conflicting moralities of protecting his family vs his duty as a cop to protect strangers. Also writing, directing and cinematography were all excellent the first two seasons, specifically in that superb S1 opener. This theory of course comes to a crashing halt in a December 2012 Vogue Magazine interview with TWD writer and creator Robert Kirkman when which TWD about the coma theory stated emphatically that the events in TWD are, "Definitely happening!" However, he followed this with a line about how all the other characters were in Rick's head. This to me sounded like so much sour grapes from a man who's master plan had been outed early, and easily. I believe Kirkman changed the core philosophy of the show between seasons 2 and 3 with a shake up of new writers and directors. Most will agree the show took on a decidedly new look and feel season 3 as it's popularity and budget grew. Which brings me to theory number two... PURGATORY THEORY - All the characters are dead - seasons 3, 4, and 5. Starting season 3 the morality challenges extended out to the general characters and the idea of the heroic sacrifice is introduced. Also the show began to emphasise heavily the I Am Legend themes which it hadn't touched on since the pilot. In I Am Legend the zombies are the new normal and it's the remnant humans who are the monsters. Deep. We are introduced to Michone which begins a slew of biblically named characters. Abraham, Noah, Gabriel... I feel at this juncture Kirkman moved Rick from his own personal purgatory into the actual biblical purgatory where those who've died but weren't good enough for heaven or bad enough for hell must ultimately prove themselves worthy for one or the other to gain entrance. We see this often on both sides. Beth, Herschel, and Lori heroically sacrificing themselves so the others could go on, and the Governors, Merles and Gareths of the world driving themselves and those around them headlong to their doom. These themes stay steady and show quality relatively high right up to a high point of Tyreese's death. Which is easily the best episode since the pilot. The I Am Legend themes are glaring in this episode which also marks the last traditional heroic in my purgatory theory as Tyreese is basically taken by the hand and walked into the next world. This also marks another change up of management of writing and directing and from this point on the show morphed slightly towards my third theory... RAPTURE THEORY - All characters are alive and experiencing the biblical apoccolypse - seasons 5, 6 and 7. It was an easy move for Kirkman to take his creation from a metaphorical purgatory to an actual one and I believe this happened after Tyreese's death. The challenges facing the characters from this point on are much more real world. Water, food, shelter, politics. The I Am Legend themes disappear, the zombie reality is a fully accepted reality and the people who've survived this far are the one most adept to do so. Moralities are still tested but in much more visceral and real ways. Characters here often have to live on with their decisions and continue contemplating their own humanity. No more easy outs. If you look up a description of the rapture in the bible it reads like a literal plot synopsis of the walking dead, and biblical names come hot and heavy seasons 6 and 7. Ezekiel, Noah, David... Jesus for Christ's sake. Now these are just thematic tones. I don't think TWD in general or any of it's individual episodes are analogies of any specific bible stories. More a modern take on biblical ideas. Perhaps this is where the show was all along. It's possible. I'm sure if you asked Robert Kirkman he'd say so. If it's where it was at all. I still posit my first theory is possible and we're all still in Rick's head. It's also entirely possible that none of these theories is true and it's what it is on the surface, a zombie show, and I'm reading way to much into it, (Likley), but hey I'm just saying what I see. P.S. DIVINE INTERVENTION THEORY - Some characters are divine - All seasons. All three theories leave open the possibility of divine intervention and I've had a nagging feeling that certain characters just may be Angel guides, and one in particular God himself, based on their actions, luck, decision making, names, appearance, and other subtle clues. MICHONE - St. Michael - archangel protector of the innocent - carries a flaming sword. Michone had been steadfastly at Rick's side since her appearance. Her advice is always very morally guiding. She's perfectly capable of solving his problems for him but rarely does. Instead she often attempts to guide Rick, and Carl sometimes, into making the right decision themselves. DARYL - ANGEL OF DEATH - Rides a horse of the apoccolypse, wears wings. As Michone is to Rick, Daryl is to Carol, and to a lesser extent the group at large. Often boldy refusing to solve their problems which everyone knows he can. He brusquely forces the group to face their own moralities and is completely unafraid to usher someone into the next world. Goodly or badly. MORGAN - GOD - Creator of all and iniator of the apoccolypse. Easily the most caring and emotionally attached character. The others very often survive directly due to Morgan ex machina. In my Morgan is God theory, in the beginning God has initiated the apoccolypse and essentially given up on his creation. Leaving the earth a battlefield for the remaining souls to duke it out and define their eternities. He decides to walk among them just so he can be with his children in their dieing moments. (Personified in Morgan's on screen son). He meets Rick, and realizes that in some small way this wasn't a fair decision for him as he wasn't technically conscious the moment God flipped the apoccolypse switch, so he helps him directly, lays down the rules for him, and gives Rick, (perhaps the personification of humanity in general), a fighting chance. God has his mind made up still about humanity in general until he bumps into Eastman. In Eastman he meets the most humanist of humans. A man who has experienced the worst, committed the worst, yet still exhibits the best. With no excuse to do so, and every excuse not to, Eastman does the right thing. He loves. He codjules Morgan back to sanity in spite of him being hell bent on destruction and death. Here the child rehabilitates the parent and God changes his mind and decides to help humanity through love, giving them a new chance.