False Prophet?
Not a chance in hell!
Ewen McKenzie is the truth.
This is not the result we wanted, but itās the result we needed.
Link's strategy was right, it was the execution that let him and the boys down in the end. āBoysā being the operative word. A young team with the burden of the world on their shoulders. They needed to be baptised in fire. To purify the errors that incidentally marred their game.
The idea to ābloodā Cooper back in was brilliant and the insightful will appreciate its merit and its long term significance. Quade āthe Oracle of Suncorpā Cooper is the best fly-half in this country. Anyone doubting that does not clearly appreciate what the chief role of the fly-half is. I can assure you if your main advantage as a fly half is defence, then you are missing the whole point of the role. Defence just scrapes into what I consider the 5 core requisites of a great fly half:
Vision: the ability to see the game and know what you and your team need to do at each stage of the game and position on the field ā thereafter to orchestrate those next steps.
Distribution: The ability to slot yourĀ back-lineĀ into gaps through ball distribution. From short deft passes to long wide passes ā the whole gamut.
Kicking: both positional and place kicking. Iām still very much a traditionalist in that I think the fly half should often carry the burden of place and positional kicking.
Dexterity/Opportunism: I have amalgamated these into one but I am essentially meaning the ability to manipulate gaps for your own benefit i.e. finding a gap and taking it yourself as opposed to putting someone else into it.
Defensive Positioning: the operative word there is positioning. It is great if you can tackle but really its more how you commandeer yourĀ back-lineĀ into place defensively and anyone else (loose trio) to assist covering line gaps in broken play.
So please lets end the bickering about who should be no. 10. Using the above criteria, it is clear who should wear the no. 10. McKenzie knows this. But there are many reasons Toomua had to start. At a glance I would guess a couple:
Player Morale: As a head coach itās important that form is rewarded and more often than not the determining factor in selection. For players to believe this they have to experience it. Toomua experienced it and will be eager to build on his ārespectable-to-say-the-leastā, if not somewhat bland, debut.
Strategic 1: We all knew the pressure would have been compounded considerably if the NZ enemy no. 1 had started. I would call this a brilliant strategic move on links part.
Strategic 2: the idea of going blow for blow until the game opens up to introduce a distributor into the foray to spruce up attack and exploit late game fatigue is self-explanatory I believe. Great idea.
Now that that is settled, I think if I were to give a brief review of the players it would be:
15. Jesse Mogg
I am beginning to fear that if there is a false prophet in the team, its Jessie. I think he has the most potential of the debutants, but just proving too unreliable and somewhat timid. 3/10
14. Israel Folau
Folauās plight I fear is tied into the no. 10 plight. Until we have a solid distributor that can create holes and plays that get his back-line into gaps and generally moving forward, he will struggle. Yes he should look for more ball but wingers are primarily finishers not hunter gatherers. 3/10
13. Adam Ashley-Cooper
I have always rated AAC but lamented his struggles in formaĀ couple of season ago. I think he is an outstanding player that speaks with his performance. 8/10
12. Christian Lealiifano
Outstanding on the boot and coming into his own in general play. The try he cost was largely an issue between 9 and 10 if you ask me. Sloppy back-line organisation and poor communication between passer and receiver. For that reason I canāt hold the try against him. 8/10.
11. James O'Connor
I liked him at full back. I think he was safe under high ball and showed what he can do if given half a gap. More of him at 15 please. 6/10
10. Matt Toomua
My biggest issue with Toomua is that he is renowned for what I generally consider the least of the core skills I would like to see in a number 10. Defence. Our back-line was struggling for direction, creativity and as a unit we lacked the right field position to mount any pressure. This is essentially where we lost the game (aside from the obvious defence issues). Sorry. I think he is just not ready to start. His form warrants a bench spot though. 3/10.
9. Will Genia
I think the new scrum laws got under his skin a bit. And that threw his game off. A solid night none the less, but unto whom much is given, much more is expected. 6/10.
8. Ben Mowen
I love this guy. But as in the case with Will, I expect more from him because of that. I believe he should actually be the captain and not Horwill. Sound game. But we want more. 6/10.
7. Michael Hooper
Easily the best Wallaby player on the park. Industrious at the breakdown and a nuisance in attack. Typical for the modern flank I guess. Better than McKaw on the night. 8/10.
6. Hugh McMeniman
A previously huge fan slowly starting to doubt if he has it in him to perform consistently at test level any more. Liam Gill had more impact off the bench than Hughās whole game. Bring in Kane Douglas I say. 3/10.
5. James Horwill
Iām concerned about big Kev. I canāt quite put my finger on it, but I am just no longer convinced he is our man to lead us. Mowen is the natural choice in my humble opinion. James had a very quiet game. We expect more. 4/10.
4. Rob Simmons
I was very happy to see him contribute more in broken play and very happy with his line-out, but most impressed by his tight play. Best game his played in the green and gold for a while. 7/10.
3. Ben Alexander
Iām concerned here too. I like Ben. He has been a good servant to the wallabies but I am thinking he has given his best to us already. That kid Sio is by far better than him on form currently. Broken and tight play. 4/10.
2. Stephen Moore
I am beginning to see this position as a problem for us. Stephen is always putting in solid performances but what all the major competition has in common nowadays is that this position has marquees players! Think SAās Adriaan Strauss, NZās Hore or Mealamu... In Tatafuās absence, we need more here. While Saia is great in broken play, his tight work is a concern to me. 3/10.
1. James Slipper
Was generally happy with James. Sound game broken and tight. 7/10.
Bench?
All played reasonably well. Kuridrani showed potential but a few too many errors. I still think long term he is our man at 13. Quade showed enough for me to see him getting the nod to start the next test. Nick White was good too.
Key Match take aways:
Hookers need to learn how to hook again! All nations!
Link needs our trust, patience and commitment and he will deliver.
We have the team to do it. We just need the belief. We were literally half way there!
The all blacks areĀ beatable.
Faith, composure, fearless attack and brutal defence are key to this.
I look forward to this weekend. Will we execute our vengeance, or will we be beaten to a pulp?
Iām tipping a much closer game. The team hungriest will take it.
I tip Wallabies by 3 points.










