episode four isnāt even officially out in most of the world and the number of vile racist takes iāve seen about louis and armandās park scene is already crazy.
this episode has armand explain to louis that both his current name and the name he had before that, āamadeo,ā were forced upon him: āamadeoā by a man who bought him from a brothel and then ādonatedā him for his sexual services to his friends, āarmandā by the coven that burned down the only home he had at that point and forced him into their ranks.
he ends his story asking louis āwho am i, louis? am i my history that has happened to me? am i my job i do not want?ā
in the scene in the park, louis first offers him a way out of the ājob [he] does not wantā and, then, calls him by his birth name, āarun,ā the only thing armand has from before his āhistory that has happened to [him],ā the only name that wasnāt forced upon him by an european master, a name from his homeland. and surely we all can see how louis, a black man from the united states, might see the value in reconnecting with oneās roots after being ripped from them and sold into slavery, right? and why he might want to offer armand freedom from a role that was forced upon him? right?
can there be a less charitable interpretation of the scene? sure. is louis being manipulative? i mean, itās what jacob said in the episode insider, letās run with it! but to jump straight from louis using armandās birth name in this scene to saying that he called him by his āslave name,ā that he was āacting like a pimp again,ā or that āthe plantation owner jumped outā (all real quotes) is, in my opinion, fucking insane.
smarter people than me have already said this, over and over, but we keep coming back to the same tired, disingenous argument. book!lewis was a plantation owner. and book!armand was already a sex slave. sex trafficking and rape were structural to the slave plantation system, and yet there were never widespread arguments about what it meant for lewis and armandās relationship that lewis was a slaver. so, to act like thereās some entirely new imbalance or conflict in the show, where louis was a pimp, which wasnāt present in the books, is at best very fucking weird, and at worst a willfully racist whitewashing of the history of the transatlantic slave trade.