--------------------------------------------------------
Brel, that poet !
It was a weekday of the month of April, I'm at my parents'house in the French Provence... sometimes I go there to work... the props of writing for a living. I'm sitting by the window looking at the sky, lazying about and stressing over a piece « in the pipeline », when the telephone rings. I pick it up right before my mom :
- Oui, âllo ?
- Âllo, Harun ? C'est France à l'appareil.
It was Brel's daughter on the line. She called me at my parents' house, used my first name and it just felt like we knew each other for years. « I can't speak at the set time, » France said, she was with students interested in Brel's writing, and wanted to know if it was okay to postpone some thirty minutes... of course it was! I was restlessly waiting for her call, thinking of the right questions, she probably had them all before... I had to convey Brel's genius to non-French speakers... talk about a mission! I thought if only I could translate some of his lyrics, it would suffice in showing the literary strength of Brel.
« And then... and then... and then there's Frida
Who's pretty like the sun
Who's love for me is the same
As my own love for Frida »
Cross that. It doesn't sound right. Maybe this:
« Who's pretty like sunshine
And who loves me like I
Yes like I love Frida »
Not quite. It is crooked. Too much is lost in translation. Brel's text is precise, it is mathematics. « Racontent » rhymes with « compte » like two plus two equal four. It couldn't have been otherwise. In Ces gens là people aren't speaking with each other, they're not recounting anything, too worried about the money, all they do is count. One can explain that, it's not hard to understand, but how do you translate it in a five or six syllables rhyme? It's doomed to fail like trying to recreate the incipit of Nabokov's Lolita, or describing the chiaroscuro in a painting by the Caravaggio to a totally blind friend. We humans are limited and often have to live with our frustrations. The translation of Le port d'Amsterdam, to Mort Shuman, must have been an exhausting entreprise... full of disappointment. Of course he did a fine job, the best anybody could have done, but something is missing from the English version... not quite sure what. The « fly » is there but the « rancid » accordion isn't, the « oriflamme » has been forgotten too, and so has the « heart of fries ». But the main loss in translation ?« Ocean languors »? Perhaps. This is probably it. Shuman's version hasn't got any « languor » whereas Brel paints Amsterdam, in his entire song, as slumberful and langourous... submerged in a thick heat. So thick is the heat that one could easily taste it, it stays pasted to the tongue. Maybe this is why, in the only version of Amsterdam, a live clip of Brel gleamingly sweating his glee, the great Belgian sticks the tip of his tongue out on the « n » of océanes ! To show the crowd the evidence that what he's interpreting before them is the truth.
« Brel doesn't interpret, » a friend of mine once told me, « he paints. » Each one of his song is a fresco with its amazing landscapes in the back, the detailed portraits of his characters, the modest interiors, the rough texture of a fatherly moustache, but also the sounds and smells – the slurps of Those folks eating soup or the house of The elders which smells of thyme and of the language of yesteryear.This is my Brel, but there are many of him... in fact there are as many Jacques Brels as people listening to him ; between the ears of men and women across the globe is where Brel is found.With France and her husband Francis we shared some brelian anecdotes.
« Some time ago we went back to the old building where Brel used to live in his youth, explains Francis, and we met an old man from Africa, he's walking out the building with his cane, painfully, marked by the time that never stops. We asked him if we can take some pictures... when he realised who we were, he told us 'you can do whatever you like, Brel taught me French' .»
Those stories go by the dozen... I have a friend in Algeria who's father owns a textile brand. For the longest time, in our youth, we wondered what he named the brand after... it is only recently that we realized it was after the iconic Frida in Brel's songs.
That's how global his impact was. His song Vesoul has been translated in tens of languages and counts over 100 covers. The main reason behind such a success might be the sincerity of his enterprise... he loved the common man, and when everyone else tried to embellish life, he worked at rendering a more truthful and real image, full of happiness sometimes, but also despair very often. He was an observer and understood the beauty of everyday life.He was obsessed by time passing. Surely that must have motivated him to stay a little longer with us... in posterity.