Okay I know i'm a bit late but I really want to talk about THIS
Now a lot of people have been saying it's 3, which for a lot of the fanbase would be the best case scenario. Now while I do know Luke LOVES to troll us on SMG34 and basically dangle it right in all of our faces, I'm going to look at this on a hopeful SMG34 perspective.
So we all know it's Pride Month, meaning this would be the BEST time to let 3 and 4 have their little gay moments.
I've seen a lot of people mention the Mickey Mouse monstrosity, but I also think the bomb should be noted.
The significance of the gift becomes exemplified when you realize 3 wanted Boopkins to rizz someone up with it. This means 3 sees it as a romantic item, something to potentially give to a loved one. The bomb 4 has in his suitcase also matches the ones on top of 3's cafe, meaning 4 probably got the bombs from YOU KNOW WHO.
So what does this all mean?
What I like to think is that SMG34 is already canon, except it isn't directly stated to the viewer's. I think 3 and 4 are going to show signs of romance, and if you put the pieces together you can code it's for each other. I think 3 confessed to 4 since it's Pride Month and gave him the Mickey Mouse statue plus some bombs because that's what 3 loves, and 4 accepted his confession. But I don't think we'll ever see this really happen, we won't see them kiss or anything but there will be moments throughout the month that can be seen as romantic coming from those two.
If my theory is right then for future episodes we'll be given hints regarding their relationship yet it won't ever be specifically stated. That is of course unless Luke decides to grow some balls and make it officially canon/j (Srry Luke ily)
Honestly I think the main reason why it hasn't become canon already is because of backlash from the community, especially now that OG SMG4 "fans" keep shitting on his content instead of minding their own business.
By making SMG3 and SMG4 have romantic moments/tension yet never be confirmed gay for each other, Luke is essentially making both sides "happy", wanting to please everyone because that's just how he is.
Sorry I got sidetracked! Honestly I understand if you didn't want to read all that, but if you did, kudos to you! I just kinda wanted to talk about this because it's been on my mind for awhile.
Thanks for listening! Oh! And if you made it this far, have a free pic of some plushies
Omg WHERE DID YOU GET THE EGGDOG PLUSH?????? I NEEED TO KNOW also sorry... what? About the whole og smg4 fans becouse didn't like way way back smg3 say something like "no smg4 would be the boyfriend and smg4 would be a girlfriend" unless we are talking like from the moments when smg3 first apear... whoch i do jot even know when or how... this is confusing
I'm sorry for the confusion! Firstly you can get high quality Eggdog plushies at eggdog.shop which is run by Zamsire! And I just wanted to clarify I meant the old fans who hate basically any change in modern SMG4. Like the redesigns or arcs, some older SMG4 fans like to say that modern SMG4 sucks and that he "fell off". Most of these OG fans crap on the changes Luke has made throughout SMG4 and want things to go back to how they were before. Due to this Luke has been doing remakes of old videos to please those fans while also doing things how he likes it. I think that because of the toxic "fans" it would make him less likely to make that big change in making 3 and 4 canon, because it risks even more backlash and potentially risking a lot of (probably homophobic) fans leaving the community.
I see what you mean though! I mean Snowtrapped is a classic episode, however it was taken as more of a joke back then. You see 3 and 4's relationship has progressed so much that it's not really viewed as a joke anymore (except 3's tsundere act). The romantic moments that they share can be comedic at times but can also be emotional and impactful on the viewers. This is the difference between old SMG34 and modern SMG34, something that some of the og fans can't handle.
Sorry for ranting again, just felt I needed to explain the issue just a bit further. Thanks for interacting!
















