I meant to write about this before I left for Toronto this month, based on a conversation I’d had with my dad over dinner one night in April, but I got caught up in final assignments and exams, and now here we are. I want to explain my strong relationship with Toronto, and how it has evolved yet stayed true to the same core roots at the same time.
I first went to Toronto in July 2011, just weeks after graduating high school. It was my first time down east and my first time in a bona fide big city. It was an amazing experience, to say the least, and I’ve been hooked on Toronto ever since. Funnily enough, it wasn’t a foray into “cool” Toronto -- I never went east of the Don, west of Bathurst, or north of Casa Loma that trip, aside from an excursion to the Zoo, back when I didn’t mind zoos (we all have a past). I did obligatory things like the CN Tower, Toronto Island, Kensington Market, Bay Street, Queen’s Park, and the ROM. It was probably the most “touristy” Toronto experience I’d done.
I stayed right off Yonge, at a now-rebranded hotel, and I remember the first night being there, going to the Sobeys late at night, and the buzz of the city. There was so much happening, so many people, going out for a weekend night. It was trippy, and reminded me of the music video for Daft Punk’s Da Funk. It was so electric. I was hooked.
I remember being mesmerized by the Kensington Market. I remember taking a sunset ferry from Centre Island back to the Harbourfront, and the post-pride crowd filling up the ferry, and just everyone making out with each other, while I awkwardly stood there. I remember getting overwhelmed by the scale of the ROM, and stumbling across the same Edward Burtynsky exhibit that was on earlier that year at the then-newly-reopened AGA. I also remember the gross humidity. It was July in Toronto, after all, and I’m from dry-as-fuck Alberta.
I remember getting back and I just felt like Edmonton could not compare. There was something about Toronto. At the time I was less traveled, though, and it could’ve just been chalked up to that. But, it’s 2018, and here I am, still with Toronto on the brain.
People who knew me back then could attest to how much I was into Toronto. The idea of moving out there dawned on me, but the idea of moving halfway across the country, thousands of kilometres from home, scared the shit out of me. I don’t think I was emotionally ready for such a huge leap. The fact that I knew no one in Toronto was very daunting, especially when I had a very fragile social network even at home at the time. That being said, it probably would’ve been easier to move then, with less established ties to Edmonton, and I do remember that dawning on me. I was very lonely at the time and less bogged down by Edmonton. Still, the fright headlined any notion of my moving, and so I never did.
I returned 3 years later, in 2014. This time I roped in a trip to Montreal, another city I absolutely adore. However, I remember, because we hit Montreal first, being there, and just longing for Toronto. The pull was strong, even after 3 years. Even having a string of bad encounters of street photography wasn’t enough to make me hate Toronto. I was in Toronto for World Pride too, which was quite overwhelming in and of itself. I branched out a bit more into the neighbourhoods this time, including Koreatown, the Beaches, and Trinity-Bellwoods. I met up with my first contact in the city. Kinda funny to think about in hindsight, actually. I remember being on the flight back to Edmonton, and the flight attendant asking me about why I was in Toronto, and explained how I visited Montreal first before taking the train down to Toronto. I remember her just absolutely raving about Montreal, and I remember just thinking about how great Toronto is in my head.
I realize Toronto is far from a perfect city. It is overpriced, it is really hot in the summer, it isn’t very confident on the international stage (it’s a place that would rather pretend to be New York). While obviously old compared to Edmonton, it definitely lacks things that you get in a city like Montreal or the old Eastern seaboard metropoli in the States. But it never really bothered me. Toronto felt great. Getting back from Toronto in 2014, I still had the “Toronto Brain” that I had previously, as I’d explained it to friends. I was just really into things out there and disillusioned by Edmonton even further.
Fast-forward another few years, to 2017, and I was back in Toronto. This time in Toronto felt fleeting. I was doing an extended roadtrip through Quebec and Southern Ontario and Toronto was merely a few days in a 2 week plus adventure, working on my Canada project. I met up with a new friend for the first time, but didn’t really have time for any other socializing, despite knowing a few people in Toronto by then. I was too busy working on getting to as many sites as possible across the GTA. This was also the first time I really experienced the 905. I had a great time, though. The weather was pretty decent for July. I walked over 20km with my new friend, learning a lot about Toronto from a local’s perspective. It was probably the highlight of that 2 week plus trip.
Interestingly, getting back from Toronto last year, it was the point at which my yearning for Toronto, while still alive, was much diminished compared with 2011 and 2014. Last year, I remember having a sense of completeness in Edmonton, but it didn’t last beyond the summer, really.
Regardless, I wanted to come back to Toronto this year, because I felt like my trip last year, within the context of my project, was too rushed. I wanted to come to Toronto, and just focus on Toronto. And now I’m here, Still in Edmonton™, on the heels of coming back from one of the greatest travel experiences of my life.
Before I was leaving for Toronto, I remember feeling this tremendous pull there, the kind of pull I’ve come to expect on the heels of coming back. That was what I was going to focus on if I wrote this last month. The feeling was that Edmonton was limiting. I felt limited by everything from the people to the urbanism here, and still do. I mean, I’d had these feelings before, but never before had I felt the sense that I could actually leave Edmonton for Toronto. It was still daunting to think about, but for the first time in my life, it felt doable. I started to feel like Edmonton was holding me back from growing as a person, that I’d gotten all I could out of this place. I’d discussed this with my dad, and some friends, and the general idea was that it made most sense to complete my undergrad here in Edmonton, and then leave. It really does make sense on paper. I have a sweet deal here, living at home, working on my degree. That’s not something everyone has, and it’s hard to pass up.
But Toronto fits better for me. As someone who adores cities, Toronto is one of the finest urban experiences in Canada, one that only Montreal can really compete with. Where in the West, you have proximity to jaw-dropping beauty, but are relatively isolated, in Toronto, you have oodles of quality cities within earshot. I love the bigness of Toronto, the haphazard urbanity, the brick architecture, the fine-grained neighbourhoods knit together by endless streetcar-oriented main streets. I love how much is going on there. I love how big the arts scene is there, and how groups there don’t feel so niche and inbred as here. It feels like I place I could more easily find other like-minded people, due to the critical mass of non-mainstream lifestyles.
Going back to Toronto this time was quite different from the previous 3 times. I was offered to stay with some amazing people, and I also went fully by myself. It was my favourite time in the city, and like I’d already said, one of the (perhaps the) best travel experience I’ve ever had. I met up with a planning contact of mine, and discussed what it’s like working in Toronto. I met up with other people. I was there, working on my project, but I also let loose and let myself socialize. The people I stayed with, I don’t really have people like them in Edmonton. I know that sounds bad, because I really do love the people back home, but it was just different. I was comfortable. I connected. I caught feelings. The near doubling of Tinder matches was a nice cameo, too, even though I did nothing with it. It made me begin to re-evaluate things and it all became (and still is) quite overwhelming.
The first day there, feeling so happy to be in Toronto. But, there was this little part of me, in the back of my head, aware of how fleeting this was, and it made me sad. As the week progressed, that only grew, until it was monumental before I left. I started feeling this dread towards Edmonton. This sense that staying in Edmonton for another 2-3 years would be stunting my growth, that I’d be regressing, reverting to a previous iteration of who I was. On the flip side, I felt that by leaving Edmonton, I’d be losing a chunk of who I am. I later realized that that person is already lost, that I am no longer that person. I am an aspiring Torontonian. By moving, I’d be leaving behind who I was, but becoming who I am now. I know I’m relatively young (despite me often feeling like the crypt keeper on campus), but still, 2 or 3 years feels like a long time to put yourself on hold, just for convenience.
Last Monday, I was on the GO Train out to Hamilton, and I just remember feeling so overwhelmed by it all. I was up till 4am the previous night, though, which probably didn’t help (zero regrets, truly). I was holding back tears and I feeling a weird connection with Avril Lavigne’s “I’m With You”, which I proceeded to play on repeat. I know that sounds really dumb, but it is what it is. I don’t care as much about how I’ll be perceived, except perhaps to the people that matter. I think that’s a huge part of why I feel more comfortable with moving halfway across the country. I am more assured of myself now than I was 7 years ago. Having people I know out in Toronto is no doubt a huge help, too.
I had such an amazing last night in Toronto, too. I was roped into riding a bicycle for the first time in 11 years, which was exhilarating. I almost died a few times, even! In hindsight, I’m amazed I was able to just enjoy myself, instead of crawl into a hole of despair over going back to Edmonton. The company probably helped. And the bicycle was a good distraction.
Leaving Toronto on Wednesday felt just so incredibly difficult. It was very emotional. I didn’t want to go and part of me still wishes I just stayed, as ridiculous as that would’ve been. I couldn’t believe I was already heading back. For those that are wondering, this isn’t a simple situation of traveling somewhere and not wanting to get back to my real life. It was a sense that Toronto was real life, and Edmonton was something else. I think that’s why it felt so surreal being back in Edmonton. I was such a mess on the plane back, ruminating in my thoughts for 4 hours. I’m pretty sure I looked crazy to onlookers, switching between failing to hold back tears to listening to really upbeat music on my iPod (cuz it’s 2006, right?) and quasi-dancing along to it to make me feel better. When I landed, I’d had enough of ruminating in my own thoughts, and just needed to talk to someone. Everyone in Edmonton was still at work, or had a broken phone, or something, but luckily I was able to call Toronto back, and it calmed me down. Now I’m filling my time with seeing people just so I don’t have to be alone in my thoughts. Well, not just that, as I do enjoy seeing people, but it’s definitely an aspect of it.
I’m not going to lie, I’ve been a distracted mess ever since I got back (arguably even before). Edmonton feels so off now, and I have even more trouble focusing on things than usual. I wish I was in Toronto so much. That trip, that experience, it brought forth a new immediacy to moving out east. Before, it was nice and easy to assume Toronto was a few years out, and I could mentally prepare for it, and cherish Edmonton for now. I mean, even if I don’t feel a belonging to Edmonton anymore, it really isn’t a bad city and there’s a lot of momentum here. But now? I don’t know what to think anymore. If I could move tomorrow, I probably would. What’s tiding me over right now is returning to Toronto in the summer, maybe roping in Georgian Bay or Detroit. But I hate waiting for it. I can’t believe I’m back here. Why am I here?
The reaction at home to all of this has been quite interesting, too. Some of my friends are boosting me up, in an effort to push me towards Toronto, and make it easier for me to leave. Another referenced how I often feel behind relative to peers in life, and that moving out there, doing my thing, will perhaps cause me to catch up and grow up. My dad feels alienated and is having a hard time relating to me right now. Everyone seems to agree that I shouldn’t rush into this, and I really need to consider everything, and make sure I’m making the best decision for myself.
Believe me, I am not an idealist. I am realistic when it comes to Toronto. I know there will be challenges, there will be many things I will have to put up with that I don’t have to now. I know I’ll have to be more responsible. I know, even though some amazing people exist in my life in Toronto, I know far less people there. I’m even aware there will be challenges to moving and living there that I can’t perceive of right now. I know Toronto is expensive. I know it’s hot as balls in the summer. But I don’t care. I feel like those challenges and sacrifices are worth the move. Everyone seems to think I’ll probably be happier out there, because let’s be real, I don’t really fit in with Albertan culture. A friend once referred to me as a “wannabe Laurentian,” referencing how my values and orientation mimic more of an Ontarian or Quebecois, despite growing up in the West. To quote another friend, I “belong” in Toronto. I’m not sure I’d go that extreme, as I don’t think people necessarily belong to anything, but the sentiment resonates nonetheless.
I also know it’ll be hard to leave Edmonton behind. One of the biggest things that kept me here for so long was the people. I think my childhood best friend moving to Seoul earlier this year really did a number on me for that. It was hard seeing her go, but I realized, if she’s willing to leave, isn’t willing to hold herself from growing by leaving, nor should I. People aren’t sticking around for me, and they shouldn’t, and nor should I. People here have said they’ll miss me, but that I shouldn’t stay here for their sake. As well, I’ve witnessed with my friend that we’ve been able to stay in touch quite well. It’s not the same as having her physically here, but we message each other often, and video chat every couple of weeks. With a little bit of effort, I can stay in touch with people here. And I know I’ll visit. And people can visit me. One of my friends already expressed how much fun she thinks visiting me in Toronto would be. I wish I could be this cool about people I love leaving me.
It’s still scary, the thought of moving, and it still makes me emotional. But aren’t these life-defining crossroads what make life worth living? Isn’t this the sort of shit that invigorates people? Isn’t this the stuff you write stories about? One day I’ll be old and dead and I’ll be looking back on this, and I really hope I’m looking back on me taking this risk, rather than chickening out yet again. I really, really want to, even though this is all causing me a lot of anxiety. Maybe by writing this out there is now an official record of this predicament, and it’ll force me to hold myself to it, rather than settle on life out of convenience. I know at some point this intense feeling will mellow, but I hope the drive is still there. I really, really do. It broke my heart enough having to come back to Edmonton. I don’t want that to be in vein.
I don’t even mind the humidity that much anymore. Being back in Edmonton, I’m complaining about how chapped my lips are from the dryness. But I’m also complaining about not having a very frequent streetcar a block away and how I’m not with the people out there.
I still don’t have a game plan. I still have no idea what I’m going to do. It was suggested that, regardless of what I end up doing, I should research what exactly it would take to move out there now, rather than after undergrad. I’m gonna try and start that tonight, if all goes according to plan, which rarely happens in life. Case in point: my trip to Toronto last week.
Life is so frighteningly fleeting. I don’t know what will happen next. But for now, I’m here. In Edmonton. A place that I thought I’d always end up back at, and now even that is seemingly fleeting. Things I never imagined happening in Toronto did, and even though it’s caused me this anxiety and sadness, I wouldn’t trade it for the world. Where I go from here, I don’t know.