breakdown of "one day i am gonna grow wings"
fic is linked here
Iâm actually writing this explanation a year after i wrote this dumbass oneshot and iâve forgotten everything about alhaithamâs various philosophies. i lowkey felt like i was analyzing someone elseâs writing but i tried my best. anyway iâm sorry if iâm wrong about my own writing because thereâs genuinely a nonzero chance of that happening :(
wc is 1.09k and you do not need to read this in order to read the og oneshot
What this oneshot is really about is jealousy and understanding. Alhaitham cannot save the MC because she is cripplingly jealous of Alhaithamâs genius and turns him away at every point. Her jealousy leads her to think of Alhaitham as a creature who can never understand her, and to some extent this is true: Alhaitham spends the entirety of the oneshot figuring MC out. Ironically his method of understanding her is extremely academic (evidence-gathering, hypotheses), which MC would probably hate. Instead of putting effort into explaining the themes in more depth I will now focus on a few important lines to sound smart:
âHeâs not particularly faithful himself, but he was never angry like you. Perhaps heâll learn.â
The big mystery of the MC that Alhaitham unravels is why the MC feels no self worth. In Teyvat, a godâs blessing in the form of a vision is a rather objective measurement of worth, but the MC doesnât care for it at all because what she really needs is recognition from herself. A Dendro Vision is a slap in the face because it seems to be an unearned reward and therefore a sign that MC is not understood by the world. She doesnât normally care for the opinions of the divine and neither does Alhaitham, but only MC is angry because Alhaitham feels no need to be understood. In the face of the Akademiyaâs indifference and lack of effort in understanding MC while heâs busting his ass trying to make sense of why MC died, perhaps he will become angry.
âWhen you are this sick, Alhaitham is not a doctor in any way that matters.â
this line is kinda stupid tbh but i thought i cooked when i wrote it
Anyway, Alhaitham is useless at comforting MC because MC would never accept such support from someone better than her. It would always be interpreted as pity. Heâs a phd doctor whose defining characteristic in MCâs eyes is his academic achievements, not a âI can help you get betterâ doctor. Hence, âit would have been better to be an ignorant man, or anything that wouldnât have been powerless at the sight of you hurtling through lifeâŠhe knows there is nothing to say if he is not a fool.â
âHe knows very well that it is impossible to save everyone, but the idea that not everyone can be savedâwell, he can almost hear someone saying he shouldâve tried harder.â
The âsomeoneâ is Kaveh, lol. I donât think pure pragmatism is always a useful philosophy. Maybe MC would have lived if Alhaitham thought more like Kaveh. Maybe not. Heâll never know now.Â
âThe more logical part of him laments that it wouldnât have mattered. Not if you looked at him that night and said, Iâm not you, and this is simple aetiology.â
Aetiology, the study of cause and effect, is the focus of the Vahumana darshan to which MC belongs. Even at death MC is ruled by academia. The disparity between MCâs lack of self-worth and everyone elseâs perception of her as a genius leaves a hole that can either be filled by actually being a genius or by not caring about not being understood. In other words, the solution is becoming Alhaitham. Because this cannot happen, MC can only remove the hole entirely.Â
âYouâre a victim of this, yet Alhaitham cannot fault you for cowardice, not if you had disregarded praise for a legacy you called an âobligationâ. It would be nothing short of nonsensical to deny you the title of genius. That makes you shortsightedâ
iâm ngl i fucked this part of the character study up a little but iâll try to save it
To my understanding Alhaithamâs character story 3 is about independence of thought. Those âwho remain blinded by perspectives advocated by the great majorityâŠhave not yet found their true selvesâ and are labeled as cowards. In contrast to such people, MC has a perfect grasp on who she is without any input from outsiders. She is not convinced by an externally given label of âgeniusâ and does not care for it at all as she strives to earn that label from herself. But in Alhaithamâs eyes, MC already is a genius, and her not realizing that makes her shortsighted.Â
âBut alas, there is no cure for a fallacy born of yearning. Itâll spread and take down every parallel soul of yours wandering the midnight oil with absent eyes. Alhaitham understands, itâs what you wouldâve wanted. All youâve ever wanted was to stave off this horrible loneliness, and you made sure he had nothing to do with that lofty dream.â
Academic pressure is not really just some glorious, tragic descent into sadness and unfulfilled expectations. It is marked by jealousy that separates you from all your peers; you cannot love your friends and you cannot love yourself, and at that point who can even begin to help you? Help is no longer what you want. You want to become a good story that finally gives use to your endless depression and loneliness, a good story that burns itself into everyone who learns it, a good story that will haunt everyone who is better than you until finally they fail just like you did. In other words, a beautiful tragedy. This is the MCâs âfallacy born of yearningâ that she hopes will spread to everyone like her, burning the midnight oil as they work dead-eyed on proving themself to themself, and drag them down. Alhaitham, who is a true genius, would be untouched by such a story and thus cannot play a part in the MCâs plan.
âYouâve poured the glass empty to draw a picture in the stain without enjoying the drink.â
In order to make art out of her life and death, MC misses everything in her life worth enjoying. Maybe her life really is all that she thinks it is. And maybe itâs not. Well, whatâs the point of tossing and turning over what label to give it, and whatâs the point of packing it into a story to tell? Itâs your one and only life to enjoy.Â
Bonus: scroll of streaming song
I wanted to use an actual Vahumana text for the book that MC puts her note in and for some reason this was the only one I can find. It worked out very nicely because it turns out Haravatat scholars were also involved in the translation of this book.Â
Thatâs enough larping my own writing. Thank you for reading now go enjoy your life instead of reading angst












